Petition Against Land Passage Order Dismissed — Patna High Court, 2026

Shubham Shivansh

Reviewed by: Shubham Shivansh

License Number: D/7102/2022

Last Reviewed On: 16-11-2026

Shubham Shivansh is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in civil disputes, service law, and GST matters. He represents clients in property disputes, contractual disagreements, service-related grievances, and tax compliance matters before the Patna High Court and other jurisdictions. His practice handles civil litigation, employment-related disputes, and regulatory matters for individuals and businesses across Bihar.

One party challenged a Sessions Court order about using a piece of land as a passage. The Patna High Court upheld the Sessions Court and refused to restore the earlier Executive Magistrate’s order. The Court held that Section 147 Cr.P.C. cannot be used to finally decide private land disputes. The petitioner must go to the civil court for any permanent relief.

Case Background

The dispute relates to a small piece of land in village Telhara, P.S. Telhara, District Nalanda. The land is recorded in Khata No. 45, Khesra No. 90/547, measuring 22 decimals.

On 02.07.1992, the petitioner filed an application before the Sub Divisional Officer (S.D.M.), Hilsa, Nalanda under Section 147 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. He requested that this land be declared a passage or way for his use, alleging that the opposite parties had blocked his access by raising obstructions.

On this application, Case No. 88 MP/1992 was registered. The opposite parties were given notice. After hearing both sides, the Executive Magistrate (S.D.M.), Hilsa, Nalanda passed an order dated 03.06.2000.

Through this order, the S.D.M. allowed the petition. He directed the opposite parties to remove the obstructions such as wall and hut from the disputed land. He further ordered that, if they failed to comply, the obstruction would be removed with police help.

The opposite parties challenged this order in Criminal Revision No. 38 of 2000 before the learned 2nd Additional Sessions Judge, Hilsa, Nalanda. By judgment dated 19.12.2005, the revisional court set aside the S.D.M.’s order. It held that the proper remedy for the petitioner was under Section 145 Cr.P.C. and not Section 147 Cr.P.C.

The petitioner then approached the Patna High Court in Criminal Revision No. 307 of 2014. By order dated 01.02.2016, the High Court did not interfere with the 2005 judgment but directed the revisional court to call for a report, hear both sides again and pass a fresh order within three weeks of receiving the report.

In compliance, the learned 2nd Additional Sessions Judge sought a report from the S.D.M., Hilsa, Nalanda. The S.D.M., after obtaining inputs from the Circle Officer and other authorities, reported that Plot No. 547 was raiyati land. He stated that there had already been a partition between two brothers, each having a half share, and that the disputed land was not a public way or passage used by the public.

Relying on this report, the revisional court passed a fresh judgment on 30.08.2016 in Criminal Revision No. 38 of 2000 (restored as per the High Court’s 2016 order). It again set aside the S.D.M.’s order dated 03.06.2000, holding that the land was raiyati land, not a public way, and that no case under Section 147 Cr.P.C. was made out.

Aggrieved, the petitioner filed the present Criminal Miscellaneous No. 52293 of 2016 under Section 482 Cr.P.C. before the Patna High Court, assailing the revisional court’s order dated 30.08.2016 and seeking a direction to use the land as a passage.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The High Court heard learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State. It also carefully examined the earlier orders and the statutory framework, especially Section 147 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

The petitioner’s counsel argued that the 2nd Additional Sessions Judge, Hilsa, Nalanda did not properly appreciate the evidence and the legal scope of Section 147 Cr.P.C. According to the petitioner, the S.D.M. had rightly allowed the use of the disputed land as a passage because the petitioner and his family had been using it since partition and there was allegedly no other access to their share.

The revisional order dated 30.08.2016 was termed by the petitioner as a non-speaking order without sound legal reasoning, and therefore liable to be set aside. The petitioner also contended that Section 147 Cr.P.C. is not confined to public land; it applies to disputes over the right of user of any land or water, whether such right is claimed as easement or otherwise. It was argued that the revisional court failed to appreciate these aspects.

On the other hand, the Additional Public Prosecutor submitted that this litigation had been continuing since 1992 and had already come once before the Patna High Court. He referred to the earlier High Court order dated 01.02.2016 in Criminal Revision No. 307 of 2014, where the Court had purposely avoided detailed interference considering the age of the matter and had only directed the revisional court to obtain a report and pass a fresh order.

He pointed out that, in obedience to this direction, the 2nd Additional Sessions Judge had called for a fresh report from the S.D.M., examined it, and found the disputed plot to be raiyati land and not a public way. As such, there was no occasion for the Executive Magistrate to exercise power under Section 147 Cr.P.C., and his order dated 03.06.2000 had rightly been set aside.

Before examining the specific facts, the High Court undertook a detailed analysis of the ambit and purpose of Section 147 Cr.P.C., which deals with “dispute concerning right of use of land or water”. The Court reproduced the entire text of Section 147 and then summarised the key points.

First, Section 147 is concerned with apprehended breach of peace arising from disputes about the right of user of land or water. If an Executive Magistrate is satisfied, on a police report or other information, that such a dispute likely to cause breach of peace exists, he must record the grounds of his satisfaction in writing and call the parties to file their claims.

After considering statements and evidence, the Magistrate may decide whether such a right exists. In doing so, the procedure under Section 145 Cr.P.C. may be followed as far as possible. If the Magistrate finds that the right exists, he may prohibit interference with that right and, where necessary, order removal of obstructions.

The High Court highlighted that the power under Section 147 is preventive in nature. It is intended to preserve public peace and tranquility, not to finally decide private civil rights like a civil court. The Executive Magistrate must record his subjective satisfaction about the likelihood of breach of peace and about recent exercise of the claimed right within the preceding three months (or the last relevant season), as required by the proviso to sub-section (3).

Relying on earlier Patna High Court decisions, including Guru Govind Singh v. State of Bihar (2017 Cri. L.J. 3307), Ratichandra Mandal v. State of Bihar (2017 Cri. L.J. 3861), and Md. Sarfuddin @ Sarfuddin Mian v. Sabir Thakur & Anr. (2005 SCC Online Pat 939), the Court reiterated that:

– Section 147 proceedings are summary and temporary;

– the Magistrate is not to decide title, right, interest and possession like a civil court;

– no final order under Section 147 can be made unless the Magistrate finds that the right of user was actually exercised within three months prior to receipt of the police report or information;

– the central requirement is apprehension of breach of public peace, which must be clearly recorded.

The Court further explained the broader legal context. Chapter X of the Cr.P.C. (Sections 129 to 148) is devoted to maintenance of public order and tranquility. Sections 145 to 148, under this Chapter, specifically deal with disputes about immovable property. The statutory scheme is designed to give Executive Magistrates limited, preventive powers to avoid public disturbances, not to substitute for regular civil or criminal courts.

The Court clarified the distinction between “public order and peace” and ordinary “law and order” issues. Public order concerns disturbances affecting the public at large—such as riots, affray, or public unrest. Disputes confined to a few individuals, especially over private land, do not ordinarily fall within this concept. Such disputes must be resolved either through civil suits or, where offences are committed, through regular criminal proceedings.

With these legal principles in mind, the Court turned to the facts of the present case, particularly the S.D.M.’s order dated 20.06.2000 and the consequential operative direction dated 03.06.2000.

On perusal of the S.D.M.’s order, the High Court found that the Executive Magistrate had not recorded any satisfaction regarding apprehension of breach of public peace. Instead of confining himself to preventive measures, he examined the partition arrangement between the parties. Treating himself like a civil court, he decided their inter se rights and ordered provision of a passage based on alleged terms of partition.

The High Court noted that there was no finding in the S.D.M.’s order about any circumstance likely to disturb peace and tranquility in the locality. The order did not state that the disputed right of user had been exercised within three months prior to the initiation of proceedings. Thus, the basic statutory conditions for invoking Section 147 were missing.

In contrast, the revisional court, acting on the High Court’s earlier direction, had obtained a detailed report from the S.D.M. and other authorities. This report clearly stated that Plot No. 547 was raiyati land, already partitioned between two brothers with equal shares, and that it was not a public way. Accepting this factual position, the 2nd Additional Sessions Judge held that no case under Section 147 Cr.P.C. was made out and, therefore, set aside the S.D.M.’s order.

The High Court agreed with this approach. It held that the dispute between the parties stemmed from conditions mentioned in their partition deed and concerned use of their respective shares of land. This was purely a private, civil dispute. There was no material to suggest that it affected public order and peace or involved a public pathway.

Since the dispute was limited to rights between private individuals, it fell exclusively within the jurisdiction of the competent civil court. The S.D.M., by using Section 147 Cr.P.C. to decide these civil rights, had exceeded his jurisdiction and had encroached upon the domain of civil courts.

The High Court observed that the powers given to Executive Magistrates under Chapter X are “extraordinary” and must be invoked sparingly, only when there is credible apprehension of breach of public order and peace. Misuse of these powers to handle ordinary civil disputes would harass citizens and render civil and criminal courts redundant.

On this reasoning, the Court concluded that the order dated 30.08.2016 of the 2nd Additional Sessions Judge, Hilsa, Nalanda, did not suffer from any legal infirmity. It was based on sound principles and proper appreciation of the law. Consequently, the petitioner’s application under Section 482 Cr.P.C. was held to be devoid of merit and was dismissed.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is important for villagers and landholders who face similar disputes over pathways or right of way through private land. The Patna High Court has made it clear that Section 147 Cr.P.C. is not a shortcut for obtaining permanent rights over land.

Executive Magistrates, such as S.D.Ms, can act under Section 147 Cr.P.C. only to prevent breach of public peace. They cannot behave like civil courts and decide long-term rights based on partition deeds or private agreements.

Where the dispute relates to use of land between family members or neighbours and affects only them, the correct forum is the civil court. People cannot expect permanent solutions to such disputes through criminal law proceedings aimed merely at keeping the peace.

The judgment also serves as a reminder to Magistrates not to exceed their limited preventive powers. If they do, higher courts are likely to set aside such orders.

Legal Issues and Answers


  • Issue: Can an Executive Magistrate under Section 147 Cr.P.C. grant a right of passage over raiyati land arising out of a private partition dispute?

    Answer: No. Section 147 Cr.P.C. is meant only to prevent breach of public peace regarding right of user of land or water. It does not authorise the Magistrate to finally decide private civil rights arising from partition or ownership; such matters lie within the jurisdiction of civil courts.

  • Issue: Was the revisional court justified in setting aside the S.D.M.’s order granting passage to the petitioner?

    Answer: Yes. The revisional court, after obtaining a report that the land was raiyati and not a public way, rightly held that there was no case under Section 147 Cr.P.C. and set aside the S.D.M.’s order, which lacked findings on apprehension of breach of public peace and recent exercise of the claimed right.

  • Issue: Should the High Court exercise its inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to restore the S.D.M.’s order?

    Answer: No. The Patna High Court found no infirmity in the revisional court’s order dated 30.08.2016 and therefore dismissed the petitioner’s application as devoid of merit.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • Guru Govind Singh v. State of Bihar, 2017 Cri. L.J. 3307 (Patna High Court).
  • Ratichandra Mandal v. State of Bihar, 2017 Cri. L.J. 3861 (Patna High Court).
  • Md. Sarfuddin @ Sarfuddin Mian v. Sabir Thakur & Anr., 2005 SCC Online Pat 939.
  • Maheshwar Pratap Singh v. State of Jharkhand & Ors., 2008 Cri. L.J. (NOC) 814 (Jharkhand).
  • AIR 1955 Patna 265 (referred to in context of the proviso to Section 147(3) Cr.P.C.).

Case Details

Case Number: Criminal Miscellaneous No. 52293 of 2016

Case Title: Ram Pyare Mistri v. The State of Bihar & Ors.

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rana Vikram Singh

Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 37

Advocates: Mr. Sanjay Kumar, Advocate for the petitioner; Mr. S.M. Rahman, Additional Public Prosecutor for the State/opposite parties

Nature of the Case: Petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. challenging revisional order in a proceeding originally initiated under Section 147 Cr.P.C.

Date of Patna High Court Judgment: 28.08.2026

Relevant Statutory Provisions: Sections 145, 147, 148, 482 Cr.P.C.; Chapter X of the Code of Criminal Procedure

Link: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/NiM1MjI5MyMyMDE2IzEjTg==-3NR88rgmrEU=

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News