Civil revision against substitution of legal heirs dismissed — Patna High Court, 2026

Sakshi Bhatnagar

Reviewed by: Sakshi Bhatnagar

License Number: BR/2891A/2019

Last Reviewed On: 16-11-2026

Sakshi Bhatanagar is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing criminal law. She represents clients in criminal proceedings before the Patna High Court and subordinate courts, handling bail applications, criminal appeals, NDPS matters, and customs-related cases. Her practice focuses on criminal defense and litigation across multiple forums in Bihar.

Original plaintiff died during a land dispute case, and her heirs sought to continue the suit. The trial court allowed their substitution. The Patna High Court upheld this order and dismissed the civil revision. The title suit will now proceed with the legal heirs on record.

Case Background

The dispute began with Title Suit No. 82 of 1987 filed in the court of Sub-Judge-III-cum-ACJM-IV, Buxar. The original plaintiff, Most. Rajmati Kuwar, sued for a declaration that defendant no. 1 had acquired no valid title or interest over her property on the basis of four sale deeds dated 03.03.1987.

She alleged that her thumb impression and signature had been taken fraudulently on documents at the registry office. According to her, the sale deeds were without consideration, their real nature was never disclosed to her, and they were not binding on her. Along with this declaration, she asked the court to confirm her possession over the suit land or, if she was dispossessed during the case, to restore possession to her.

After learning of the alleged fraud, she got the sale deeds cancelled before the Registrar, Buxar, on 21.03.1987. Soon after, she filed the title suit challenging the effect of those deeds.

However, the plaintiff died on 07.09.1987, leaving behind seven daughters. This death created a procedural issue: unless her legal heirs came on record in time, the suit risked abating (coming to an end) under the Code of Civil Procedure.

On 30.10.1987, her youngest daughter, Durgawati Devi, said to be a minor and unmarried at that time, filed an application under Order XXII Rule 3 CPC for substitution through her uncle, Srinivas Pandey, acting as guardian/next friend. On 09.12.1987, the two sons of another daughter, late Chinta Devi, applied under Order I Rule 10 CPC to be impleaded as heirs of their deceased maternal grandmother. On 10.12.1987, daughter Indrawati Devi also moved a petition under Order I Rule 10 CPC seeking impleadment of the heirs of the deceased plaintiff as party plaintiffs.

These applications remained pending. During this period, the case was transferred from one court to another by order of the District and Sessions Judge on 26.04.1991 due to court vacancy. The transferee court fixed dates for hearing on the substitution petitions, but, according to the heirs, the matter was repeatedly adjourned due to non-cooperation by defendants.

Later, on 27.05.2002, the suit was again transferred and fixed for 21.06.2002. On that date, as the plaintiff’s counsel did not appear, the suit was dismissed for non-prosecution. After learning this, Durgawati Devi filed Miscellaneous Case No. 51 of 2002 seeking restoration of the suit. On 09.10.2004, after hearing both sides, the trial court restored the suit.

Subsequently, petitioner no. 1 (defendant no. 1 in the suit) filed a petition on 01.12.2016 to recall the restoration order dated 09.10.2004. The trial court rejected this recall plea. That rejection has been separately challenged before the Patna High Court in Civil Revision No. 31 of 2017, which is stated to be pending.

Meanwhile, all the heirs and legal representatives of the deceased plaintiff jointly filed a fresh petition dated 06.10.2015 with an affidavit. They stated that separate substitution/impleadment applications had been filed back in 1987 within limitation, but no final order had ever been passed. They therefore requested deletion of the deceased plaintiff’s name and entry of all her heirs on record. The Sub-Judge allowed this joint petition on 19.04.2022. This order became the subject of Civil Revision No. 28 of 2022 before the Patna High Court.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The Patna High Court, per Hon’ble Mr. Justice Khatim Reza, examined whether the trial court was right in allowing substitution of the legal heirs by order dated 19.04.2022. The key question was: had the suit already abated for want of timely substitution, or were the 1987 applications sufficient to keep it alive?

Counsel for the petitioners (defendants) argued that three different substitution-related applications contained contradictory claims and did not correctly identify all legal heirs. Because of these inconsistencies, the trial court had ordered an inquiry under Order XXII Rule 5 CPC on 11.01.1989. During this inquiry, twelve witnesses were examined, and the matter was later posted for hearing on the substitution petitions.

The petitioners contended that the heirs repeatedly failed to appear, leading to the dismissal of the suit on 21.06.2002. They further asserted that the substitution petition dated 30.10.1987 was itself rejected by order dated 07.08.2002, and that no review, recall, or appeal was filed against that rejection. On this basis, they claimed the suit had abated and that the 2015 petition could not revive it without an order setting aside abatement and condoning a delay of nearly 28 years.

The High Court, however, carefully checked the lower court records (L.C.R.). It noted that no order dated 07.08.2002 rejecting the 30.10.1987 substitution petition existed on the record. Instead, the L.C.R. showed that the entire suit was dismissed on 21.06.2002 and later restored on 09.10.2004. In this situation, there could not logically have been a separate order on 07.08.2002 dismissing the substitution petition before the suit itself was restored. Therefore, the factual basis of the petitioners’ argument was found unsupported by record.

Because the supposed rejection order was not traceable, the Court held that the plea that the substitution application had been finally rejected and that the suit had abated could not be accepted.

The petitioners further argued that the 06.10.2015 petition was a fresh substitution application. According to them, since no effective substitution had been ordered earlier, the suit had abated after the death of the sole plaintiff, and any later attempt in 2015 required (a) setting aside of abatement and (b) condonation of long delay. As neither had been done, they contended the trial court acted without jurisdiction in allowing the 2015 petition.

On the other side, counsel for the opposite parties (heirs of the plaintiff) maintained that the 2015 petition was not a new substitution request at all. Instead, it was simply a joint reminder asking the court to finally decide the already-filed applications of 1987: the substitution application of 30.10.1987 and the impleadment applications of 09.12.1987 and 10.12.1987. They stressed that these earlier applications were filed within the limitation period after the death of the plaintiff on 07.09.1987.

They further explained the family situation: the plaintiff’s husband had died in 1982. One daughter, Chinta Devi, died on 19.07.1985, leaving behind two sons (Ashok Pandey @ Ashok Kumar Pandey and Pramod Kumar Pandey). Another daughter, Anjani Devi, died in 1985, leaving behind a minor daughter, Saroj Kumari @ Saroj Devi, about five years old. Indrawati Devi, another daughter, died in 1986. Defendant no. 1 was alleged to be the younger brother of Anjani Devi’s husband, who was serving in the Armed Forces and posted outside Bihar. Taking advantage of the absence of close family members, defendant no. 1 allegedly manipulated the plaintiff into putting her thumb impression and signature on blank papers at the registry office on the pretext of “corrections” in consolidation papers, and then got the disputed sale deeds registered.

The opposite parties highlighted that the minor daughter Saroj Kumari was represented in the substitution petition dated 10.12.1987 through Indrawati Devi, described as her stepmother and maternal aunt. Hence, according to them, the estate of the deceased plaintiff was already fully and substantially represented in the case by timely applications of her heirs. The 2015 petition only sought to have those pending applications decided; it did not introduce any new claim.

After hearing both sides, the Patna High Court examined the statutory framework of Order XXII CPC. Under Rule 1, the death of a plaintiff does not cause a suit to abate if the right to sue survives. Under Rule 3, when a sole plaintiff dies and the right to sue survives, the court must, on application, bring his or her legal representative on record. Only when no such application is filed within time does abatement occur under sub-rule (2).

The Court then turned to the actual dates. The plaintiff died on 07.09.1987. The first substitution application, filed by minor daughter Durgawati Devi through her guardian on 30.10.1987, clearly fell within the prescribed 90 days. The other two applications, dated 09.12.1987 and 10.12.1987, were under Order I Rule 10 CPC for impleadment of the heirs as party plaintiffs. All of this, in the Court’s view, showed that the legal heirs had acted within limitation.

Importantly, the Court treated these later impleadment applications as being “in continuation” of the first substitution application. The joint petition of 06.10.2015, filed by opposite party nos. 1 to 7, was also viewed as a continuation—essentially a consolidated request to finally decide and allow the long-pending 1987 applications.

The Court emphasised a well-settled principle: if at least some legal representatives of a deceased party are already on record, the suit does not abate merely because all heirs are not yet substituted. For this, the Court relied on the Full Bench decision in Jagarnath Singh v. Smt. Singhashan Kuer and Others, reported in 1984 PLJR 217.

It noted that there was no dispute about the existence of Durgawati Devi, the youngest daughter. Since her substitution application was filed within limitation, the court was duty-bound to implead her, and through her, the estate stood represented. The subsequent applications of other heirs strengthened, rather than weakened, this representation.

On this reasoning, the Court held that there had been no abatement at all. Once it is accepted that a valid substitution application was timely filed, the question of condoning delay or setting aside abatement simply does not arise. Therefore, the criticism that the trial court failed to condone a 28-year delay was misplaced.

Finally, the Court concluded that the petition dated 06.10.2015 could not, in law, be seen as a fresh substitution plea filed beyond limitation. It was only a joint petition drawing the court’s attention to earlier applications and seeking their disposal. Allowing that petition did not amount to reviving an abated suit but to completing a procedural step which had started well within time.

In view of this factual and legal background, the Patna High Court found no jurisdictional error or illegality in the trial court’s order dated 19.04.2022 allowing substitution. The civil revision was accordingly dismissed, and any pending interlocutory applications were disposed of.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is important for families involved in civil cases where a party dies mid-way, especially in long-running land disputes. It shows that if at least one legal heir files for substitution in time, the case does not automatically die, even if the court takes years to decide the application.

For ordinary litigants, the ruling clarifies that separate applications by different heirs, filed around the same time, will be treated together. A later joint reminder asking the court to act on those earlier petitions will not be seen as a new, delayed application.

The judgment also underlines that claims of “abatement” must be supported by actual court records. Defendants cannot rely on untraceable or non-existent orders to argue that a case has lapsed.

Overall, the decision of the Patna High Court strengthens the protection of substantive rights over technical lapses, where the heirs have genuinely tried to come on record within limitation.

Legal Issues and Answers


  • Issue: Did Title Suit No. 82 of 1987 abate after the death of the sole plaintiff because her legal heirs were not properly substituted in time?

    Answer: No. The Court held that an application for substitution was filed on 30.10.1987 within limitation, followed by related impleadment applications. Hence, there was no abatement.

  • Issue: Was the petition dated 06.10.2015 a fresh, hopelessly delayed substitution application requiring condonation of delay and setting aside of abatement?

    Answer: No. The Court held it was merely a joint petition in continuation of the 1987 applications, seeking their consideration and disposal.

  • Issue: Did the trial court commit jurisdictional error in allowing substitution by order dated 19.04.2022?

    Answer: No. The Patna High Court found no illegality or jurisdictional error and upheld the trial court’s order.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • Jagarnath Singh v. Smt. Singhashan Kuer and Others, 1984 PLJR 217 (Full Bench, Patna High Court)

Case Details

Case Number: Civil Revision No. 28 of 2022; arising out of Title Suit No. 82 of 1987

Case Title: Ramakant Pandey & Ors. v. Durgawati Devi & Ors.

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Khatim Reza

Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 198

Advocates:

For the Petitioners: Mr. Amit Srivastava, Senior Advocate; Mr. Manu Tripurari, Advocate; Mr. Girish Pandey, Advocate; Mr. Uday Pratap Pushkar, Advocate; Mr. Hritik Anand, Advocate; Mr. Apurv Harsh, Advocate; Ms. Tanu Priya, Advocate.

For the Respondents: Mr. Brij Mohan Kumar Singh, Advocate; Mr. Utsav Kumar, Advocate; Mr. Mukul Kumar, Advocate.

Nature of the Case: Civil revision under the Code of Civil Procedure challenging an order allowing substitution of legal heirs in a pending title suit.

Link: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/vieworder/OCMyOCMyMDIyIzMyI04=-9YxvaZVil9s=

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News