Murder conviction set aside for poor investigation — Patna High Court, 2026

Shubham Shivansh

Reviewed by: Shubham Shivansh

License Number: D/7102/2022

Last Reviewed On: 19-11-2026

Shubham Shivansh is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in civil disputes, service law, and GST matters. He represents clients in property disputes, contractual disagreements, service-related grievances, and tax compliance matters before the Patna High Court and other jurisdictions. His practice handles civil litigation, employment-related disputes, and regulatory matters for individuals and businesses across Bihar.

Three men convicted for a double murder in Sitamarhi challenged their life sentences. The Patna High Court found serious doubts in witness stories and police investigation. The Court held that guilt was not proved beyond reasonable doubt and acquitted all appellants. It also ordered a high-level review of the investigation and wider action by the State.

Case Background

The case arises from a firing incident on 2 November 2018 near a murhi–kachri shop at a bandh (embankment) in village Madhaul Sani, Police Station Runnisaidpur, district Sitamarhi.

According to the written statement (fardbeyan) of Sudhir Kumar Singh (PW‑2), recorded at 23:12 hours on 02.11.2018 at Maa Janki Hospital, Muzaffarpur, he had gone in the evening with his son Deepak Singh and his cousin Dinkar Singh @ Sunny to a place where a bridge was being constructed on the bandh.

PW‑2 stated that Deepak and Dinkar were eating murhi–kachri near a shop when, at about 6:00 PM, eleven persons arrived on five motorcycles and started indiscriminate firing on them. He claimed he was at some distance and, when he reached, he saw the 11 named persons fleeing westward on motorcycles, each allegedly holding small firearms.

PW‑2 said his uncle Chhotan Singh (PW‑1) and villagers Mukesh Singh, Shivam Kumar, Prince Kumar (PW‑5) and Jai Prakash Singh (PW‑4) helped take the injured to hospital and also identified the accused. Dinkar later died at SKMCH, Muzaffarpur; Deepak was treated at Maa Janki Hospital. PW‑2 alleged that the motive was an earlier case from 2014 in which his wife Mala Devi had been murdered and that the present firing occurred in the course of compromise talks in that matter.

On this fardbeyan, Runnisaidpur P.S. Case No. 663 of 2018 was registered on 03.11.2018 under Sections 302/307/34 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act against eleven named accused.

After investigation, the police filed Charge‑sheet No. 09 of 2019 dated 19.01.2019 only against four persons — Subodh Kumar, Amarnath Kumar, Baijnath (Baidyanath) Purvey and Randhir Singh — under Sections 302/34 IPC and Section 27 Arms Act, keeping investigation pending against the other accused.

The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sitamarhi took cognizance on 14.03.2019 and sent the case for commitment. The SDJM, Sitamarhi committed it to the Sessions Court on 18.09.2019, where it was registered as Sessions Trial No. 419 of 2019.

On 13.01.2020, charges under Sections 302/34 IPC and 27(i) Arms Act were read over to the four accused; they pleaded not guilty. After trial, the Additional District and Sessions Judge‑XV, Sitamarhi convicted all four under Section 302/34 IPC and Section 27(i) Arms Act, sentencing them to life imprisonment with fine of Rs.10,000 each under Section 302/34 IPC and three years’ imprisonment with fine of Rs.5,000 each under the Arms Act, sentences to run concurrently.

Three separate criminal appeals (DB) Nos. 15, 28 and 38 of 2023 were filed before the Patna High Court by the convicts challenging both the conviction and the sentence.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The Division Bench of Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajeev Ranjan Prasad and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sunil Dutta Mishra heard counsel for all appellants, the learned Amicus Curiae for one appellant, and the Additional Public Prosecutors representing the State.

The core of the prosecution case was identification of the assailants by three alleged eye‑witnesses: Chhotan Singh (PW‑1), Sudhir Kumar Singh (PW‑2, informant) and Prince Kumar (PW‑5). Another named eye‑witness, Jai Prakash Singh (PW‑4), turned hostile and did not support the prosecution story.

The defence argued that there was, in truth, no reliable eye‑witness; that only related witnesses were examined; that medical evidence did not support claims of “indiscriminate firing”; and that the investigation was dishonest and defective. They pointed out contradictions about how the injured were taken to hospital, about distances and lighting at the scene, and about the alleged recording of a statement of injured Deepak Kumar, which was never produced.

The Amicus Curiae stressed that only eight bullets were medically detected though 11 persons were allegedly firing for 1–2 minutes, that seizure lists and inquest reports were not exhibited, the kachri shop owner and seizure witnesses were not examined, and that the memo of arrest did not show intimation to any family member, violating arrest procedure. He further highlighted inconsistencies in the post‑mortem timing vis‑à‑vis the alleged time of occurrence and the absence of any recorded dying declaration of Deepak Kumar.

The State argued that PW‑1, PW‑2 and PW‑5 were consistent eye‑witnesses whose evidence sufficiently established the occurrence and the identity of the accused. The State also stated that the case diary mentioned a statement by Deepak Kumar, though it was not treated as a dying declaration.

Assessment of PW‑2 (informant)

The High Court carefully dissected PW‑2’s testimony. In his fardbeyan, he said he was “at some distance” when firing started and, by the time he came, he saw the accused fleeing on motorcycles while his son and cousin lay injured.

In court, during examination‑in‑chief, he stated he was at the bank of the bridge under construction with others, while the two deceased were at the nearby murhi–kachri shop. He repeated that eleven persons on five motorcycles came and started indiscriminate firing.

However, during cross‑examination he described the shop as being surrounded on three sides, open only to the north, and placed himself at 2–4 “laggi” (a local measure) from the shop, standing in open space. He further admitted that when he first saw his son and cousin, they were already lying in a pool of blood and the assailants were fleeing westward. Later he claimed that he had seen the accused fleeing at a distance of 10–20 laggi away on motorcycles.

The Court observed that the firing was said to have occurred at 6:00 PM in early November, when it would already be dark. Given his own description of the shop’s structure, his position at the bridge towards the south, and the distance he later mentioned, the Bench found it difficult to accept that PW‑2 could have clearly seen and identified the accused from that position and in that lighting. It concluded that PW‑2 was not a true eye‑witness to the actual firing; at best, he may have seen persons leaving the area.

The Court also noted contradictions about Deepak’s condition. In fardbeyan, PW‑2 stated Deepak was unconscious and would give statement later; yet in court he claimed to be present when Deepak’s statement was recorded. The Investigating Officer (PW‑3) admitted that when he first reached the hospital he was told Deepak was not in a condition to make a statement, so he recorded only Sudhir’s fardbeyan. This further weakened the claim that Deepak’s statement existed as a piece of evidence.

PW‑2 also admitted his and Deepak’s involvement as accused in two kidnapping cases of 2014 (Runisaidpur P.S. Case Nos. 108 and 212 of 2014) and that compromise talks were ongoing. The defence suggested that one appellant, Randhir Singh, was a witness against him in those cases, indicating possible motive to falsely implicate Randhir, though PW‑2 denied knowledge of some related cases.

Assessment of PW‑1 (father of one deceased)

PW‑1 stated he was also standing near the bridge and that the victims were on a “machan” at the kachri shop. He claimed that all eleven accused lined up and fired for 1.5–2 minutes, and that he told police exactly which accused fired at which victim and on which body part.

However, the Investigating Officer (PW‑3) testified that PW‑1 had never given such specific details in his earlier police statement and that, during inspection, no “machan” was found at the shop. This contradiction severely dented PW‑1’s credibility.

PW‑1 also accepted that none of the four appellants had been accused in the older murder case of Mala Devi and that Amarnath, one appellant, had no personal enmity with him or the deceased. Defence suggested that Amarnath was roped in because he had married the daughter of one Shiv Shankar Singh against wishes, but PW‑1 denied this. Even so, his own admissions showed that the alleged old murder motive did not directly involve these four appellants.

Assessment of PW‑5 (son of the informant)

PW‑5, Prince Kumar, also claimed to be an eye‑witness. He too placed himself at the bridge while the victims were at the snack shop. He spoke of eleven persons arriving on five motorcycles and firing, after which the victims fell in a pool of blood.

Yet in cross‑examination he admitted that when he first saw Deepak and Sunny, they were already lying injured and bleeding outside the shop, and that he did not stay at the spot but immediately took Deepak to Runnisaidpur hospital on his motorcycle with his father sitting behind.

This version directly conflicted with PW‑2’s statement that Deepak was taken by a hired four‑wheeler and that nothing was said about travelling on PW‑5’s motorcycle. The Court treated this as a material contradiction, especially regarding post‑occurrence conduct and whether PW‑5 was actually present at the critical moments.

PW‑5’s omission to mention the presence of PW‑1 and PW‑2 with him at the bridge — though both elders placed him with them — was also seen as significant.

Investigating Officer’s shortcomings

The Court was strongly critical of the investigation conducted by PW‑3, Investigating Officer Gorakh Ram.

He said he reached the place of occurrence at 19:05 hours on 02.11.2018, but the case diary showed cuttings in date and time entries, where “03.11.2018, 04:50” had been cut and replaced with “02.11.2018, 19:05” with initials. The Bench held that such overwriting without clear explanation made the entry suspicious.

PW‑3 admitted several important lapses:

  • He did not examine nearby residents properly.
  • The owner or staff of the murhi–kachri shop were not examined.
  • No seizure list of articles from the place of occurrence was prepared and produced.
  • Empty cartridges allegedly seized were not sent for forensic examination; no detail of calibre or type of weapon was ascertained.
  • No blood‑stained soil or similar physical evidence was sent to a Forensic Science Laboratory.
  • No photographs or videos of the scene were taken.
  • He did not obtain any medical certificate of Deepak’s fitness before allegedly recording his statement and did not mention the time of such recording.
  • No hospital records (bed‑head ticket, admission register, etc.) from Maa Janki Hospital were collected to show Deepak’s treatment there.

These deficiencies, coupled with the absence of any exhibited inquest reports or seizure lists and the fact that the bullets recovered by the doctor were handed to a chaukidar who was never examined, led the Court to conclude that the investigation was “not conducted properly” and in fact raised “huge doubt” whether the I.O. had visited the place of occurrence as claimed.

Medical evidence

Doctors PW‑6 and PW‑7 conducted post‑mortems on Dinkar and Deepak respectively. PW‑6 found nine injuries on Dinkar, with five firearm entry wounds and two bullets recovered from the abdomen. PW‑7 found multiple firearm injuries on Deepak. Both opined that deaths were due to firearm injuries.

However, the bullets and recovered material were never analysed by any forensic laboratory and the chaukidar, to whom bullets were handed, was not examined. The defence and Amicus Curiae also highlighted that the total number of bullet injuries was inconsistent with the story of 11 men firing indiscriminately for 1–2 minutes.

Bench’s conclusion on evidence

After reviewing all testimonies and documents, the High Court held that none of the key witnesses — PW‑1, PW‑2, PW‑5 — could be categorised as “wholly reliable”. Their accounts were inconsistent with each other, with their own earlier statements, and with physical possibilities like distances, lighting and shop structure.

Since no prosecution witness was wholly reliable, one doubtful witness could not be treated as corroboration for another doubtful witness. The Court also rejected the trial court’s approach of brushing aside contradictions as “minor” merely because the witnesses were from rural backgrounds with limited education.

Referring to Supreme Court precedents in Mahavir Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2016) 10 SCC 220 and Kali Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh (1973) 2 SCC 808, the Bench reiterated that in criminal law, if reasonable doubt arises, the benefit must go to the accused. It emphasised that wrongful conviction of an innocent person is far worse than an acquittal of a guilty person, and conviction can rest only where the accused “must be” and not merely “may be” guilty.

Applying this principle, the Court held that the prosecution had “failed to establish its case beyond all reasonable doubts.” Accordingly, the judgment of conviction dated 18.10.2022 and order of sentence dated 21.10.2022 were set aside, and all appellants were directed to be released forthwith if not wanted in any other case.

Directions on investigation failures

Beyond acquitting the appellants, the Bench took the investigation lapses very seriously. Citing State of Gujarat v. Kishanbhai (2014) 5 SCC 108 and Ankush Maruti Shinde v. State of Maharashtra (2019) 15 SCC 470, it noted that every acquittal due to poor investigation is a failure of the justice delivery system, harms victims’ families, and can also mean an accused undergoes years of trial despite serious doubts.

The Court expressed concern that earlier directions issued by it to the Bihar Home Department and DGP regarding action against erring Investigating Officers might not have yielded significant results. It called on the Home Department, DGP Bihar and Director, Directorate of Prosecution to sit together and review policy on such matters.

Specifically for this case, the Court directed the Director General of Police, Bihar to constitute a three‑member committee of senior police officers of repute to review the manner in which PW‑3 conducted the investigation and, based on the committee’s findings, take appropriate action on the administrative side within three months of receiving the judgment. The action taken is to be communicated to the appellants, who are free to pursue the matter further if they wish.

The Court also directed the Bihar Home Department to inform it within one month about its policy on reviewing cases where courts have pointed out lapses in investigation or prosecution, and about how many such enquiries have been initiated and with what results.

Why This Judgment Matters

This Patna High Court decision is important for two separate but related reasons.

First, it shows that in murder cases, even where deaths by gunshot are undisputed, courts will not uphold convictions if key witnesses are unreliable and the investigation is badly handled. Family members’ statements are not rejected simply because they are related, but contradictions about where they were standing, what they saw, and how the injured were taken to hospital can create serious doubt.

Second, the judgment puts a spotlight on police investigation standards in Bihar. The Bench did not just acquit the appellants; it ordered a high‑level police committee to review the specific Investigating Officer’s conduct and asked the Home Department to report on its overall policy for dealing with such lapses. This can have wider impact on how murder and other serious cases are investigated in the State.

For ordinary people, especially in rural areas, the judgment underscores that:

  • Court decisions in criminal cases depend on clear, consistent evidence, not on suspicion or past enmities.
  • If investigation is careless — no seizure lists, no examination of key shopkeepers or neighbours, no forensic testing — it can result in acquittal even in grave crimes.
  • At the same time, courts are conscious that wrongful conviction of an innocent person is a grave injustice and will intervene where evidence falls short.

Legal Issues and Answers


  • Issue: Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellants participated in the firing that caused the deaths of Deepak Kumar and Dinkar Singh @ Sunny, so as to sustain their conviction under Sections 302/34 IPC and 27(i) Arms Act.

    Answer: No. The Patna High Court found major contradictions and improbabilities in the testimonies of alleged eye‑witnesses, serious investigative lapses, absence of reliable corroboration, and therefore held that the prosecution failed to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The convictions and sentences were set aside and the appellants were acquitted.

  • Issue: How should courts respond when investigation and prosecution lapses appear to have caused failure of a murder trial?

    Answer: Relying on Supreme Court rulings in Mahavir Singh, Kali Ram, Kishanbhai and Ankush Maruti Shinde, the Court held that benefit of doubt must go to the accused, but also directed systemic corrective action. It ordered constitution of a three‑member senior police committee to review the I.O.’s conduct in this case and required the Bihar Home Department to report on its broader policy and action against erring officers.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • Mahavir Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2016 (10) SCC 220
  • Kali Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (1973) 2 SCC 808
  • State of Gujarat v. Kishanbhai and Others, (2014) 5 SCC 108
  • Ankush Maruti Shinde v. State of Maharashtra, (2019) 15 SCC 470

Case Details

Case Numbers:
Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 15 of 2023
Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 28 of 2023
Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 38 of 2023
Arising out of Runisaidpur P.S. Case No. 663 of 2018, District Sitamarhi

Case Title:
Subodh Kumar Singh @ Subodh Kumar @ Guddu Singh & Anr. v. State of Bihar (Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 15 of 2023)
Randhir Kumar Singh @ Randhir Singh v. State of Bihar (Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 28 of 2023)
Baidyanath Purvey @ Baijnath Purvey v. State of Bihar (Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 38 of 2023)

Citation:
2026 (6) PLJR 298

Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajeev Ranjan Prasad
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sunil Dutta Mishra

Date of High Court Judgment:
23.09.2026 (uploaded 30.09.2026)

Trial Court:
Additional District and Sessions Judge‑XV, Sitamarhi, in Sessions Trial No. 419 of 2019

Advocates:
For Appellant No. 1 in Cr. App. (DB) No. 15 of 2023: Mr. Ajay Kumar Singh, Advocate
For Appellant No. 2 in Cr. App. (DB) No. 15 of 2023: Mr. Anil Singh, Amicus Curiae
For the State in Cr. App. (DB) No. 15 of 2023: Ms. Shashi Bala Verma, Additional Public Prosecutor
For the Appellant in Cr. App. (DB) No. 28 of 2023: Mr. Kumar Dhirendra Pratap Singh, Advocate; Mr. Diwanshu Kumar, Advocate
For the State in Cr. App. (DB) No. 28 of 2023: Mr. Sujit Kumar Singh, Additional Public Prosecutor
For the Appellant in Cr. App. (DB) No. 38 of 2023: Mr. Mritunjay Kumar Mishra, Advocate
For the State in Cr. App. (DB) No. 38 of 2023: Mr. Manish Kumar No. 2, Additional Public Prosecutor

Nature of Case:
Criminal appeals (Division Bench) against conviction and sentence for offences under Section 302/34 IPC and Section 27(i) of the Arms Act (double murder by firearm).

Link to Judgment:
https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/NSMxNSMyMDIzIzEjTg==-giQygbdj2pk=

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar, you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News