Case Background
The case arose from an incident that took place on 19.05.2007 at about 11:30 A.M. in village Adapur, under Surajgarha Police Station, District Lakhisarai.
On that day, informant Rabindra Kumar Rai was going along with his father, Ram Lakhan Rai. Near the house of one Shravan Kumar Rai, they noticed a heated altercation between the appellant, Sudhir Rai @ Sudhir Mahato, and one Sachin Poddar.
According to the prosecution, during this quarrel the appellant took out a pistol from his waist and threatened Sachin Poddar. At that stage, Ram Lakhan Rai intervened in order to pacify the dispute. The appellant then fired from the pistol, and the bullet hit Ram Lakhan Rai in the right panjra/rib-cage region.
The injured man was first taken to Surajgarha Hospital and then referred to P.M.C.H., Patna. Despite treatment, he died there on 24.05.2007.
After the firing, the appellant allegedly tried to flee. Villagers caught hold of him and snatched the pistol and the empty cartridge. These were later produced before the police.
On the basis of the written information, Surajgarha P.S. Case No. 140 of 2007 was registered initially under Section 307 IPC and Sections 25(1-B)(a), 26 and 27 of the Arms Act. After the death of Ram Lakhan Rai, Section 302 IPC was added. A charge-sheet was filed, and the case was committed to the Court of Sessions.
The trial was held as Sessions Trial No. 681 of 2008 before the learned Additional District Judge, Fast Track Court No. 1st, Lakhisarai. By judgment dated 04.02.2019 and order dated 08.02.2019, the trial court convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act, sentencing him to life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC and three years’ rigorous imprisonment under Section 27 of the Arms Act, with fines. Both sentences were to run concurrently. He was acquitted under Sections 25(1-B) and 26 of the Arms Act.
Aggrieved, the appellant filed Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 296 of 2019 before the Patna High Court.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The Patna High Court, through a Division Bench comprising Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bibek Chaudhuri and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rana Vikram Singh, examined the entire evidence on record and the arguments of both sides.
The prosecution had examined twelve witnesses in all. Among these, PW-2 Sital Rai, PW-3 Kajoma Devi, PW-4 Sachin Poddar, PW-5 Ishwar Rai and PW-6 Rabindra Kumar Rai were the key witnesses on the occurrence.
PW-3, the wife of the deceased, stated that a dispute was going on between the appellant and Sachin Poddar, and that her husband tried to pacify the quarrel. At that point, the appellant fired at her husband.
PW-6, the informant and son of the deceased, also stated that the appellant fired the shot that hit his father. Importantly, he clearly admitted that the appellant had no enmity with his father. According to him, the appellant was inimical towards Sachin Poddar due to a previous Mukhiya election.
PW-1, PW-5 and PW-7 were not eyewitnesses to the actual firing. They reached the spot on hearing the sound of the gunshot, saw the injured person and the apprehended appellant.
PW-8, Dr. Arbind Kumar Singh, conducted the post-mortem on 24.05.2007. He found an entry wound over the front of the abdomen. On dissection, he recovered a metallic object resembling a bullet embedded in the rectum wall. He opined that death was caused by abdominal injury and infection due to firearm. The post-mortem report was marked Exhibit-3.
PW-9 and PW-10 were seizure witnesses. PW-11 produced the country-made pistol and empty cartridge before the Court. PW-12, another Arbind Kumar Singh, was the Investigating Officer, who proved the seizure and investigation steps.
On the basis of this evidence, the trial court had held that the appellant fired the shot which caused the death and convicted him for murder under Section 302 IPC. At the same time, because the pistol and empty cartridge were not recovered directly from the conscious possession of the appellant but were produced by villagers, the trial court acquitted him under Sections 25(1-B) and 26 of the Arms Act, though it still convicted him under Section 27.
Before the High Court, the appellant’s counsel made two main submissions. First, that the entire incident arose out of a quarrel between the appellant and Sachin Poddar, and the deceased only intervened to pacify them. There was no prior enmity with the deceased. Therefore, according to the defence, there was no intention on the appellant’s part to cause the death of the deceased, and a conviction under Section 302 IPC was not justified.
Secondly, it was argued that since the weapon was not recovered from the conscious possession of the appellant, his liability under the Arms Act and for murder became doubtful. In the alternative, the defence argued that, at most, the case would fall under Section 304 Part II IPC (culpable homicide not amounting to murder, with knowledge but without intention).
The State opposed the appeal. The State’s counsel pointed out that several eyewitnesses consistently stated that it was the appellant who fired the shot. Their accounts were supported by the medical evidence of firearm injury leading to death. The State argued that the appellant fired at a person who was only trying to stop the quarrel, and there was no reason to interfere with the conviction.
The High Court first examined whether there was any doubt about the identity of the shooter. It found, on the strength of the consistent evidence of the material eyewitnesses and the medical findings, that there was no reason to doubt that the appellant fired the gunshot which struck Ram Lakhan Rai. The bullet injury, subsequent treatment, and death clearly linked the shot to the death. Thus, the Court agreed with the trial court that the appellant caused the fatal injury.
The main question then became: did this act amount to “murder” under Section 302 IPC, or was it a lesser offence, namely culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 IPC?
The Bench stressed that the circumstances of the occurrence were important. The prosecution case itself showed that the quarrel initially was only between the appellant and Sachin Poddar. The pistol was taken out in that context. The deceased entered the scene only to pacify the dispute. PW-3’s evidence showed that her husband was pacifying the scuffle when the appellant fired. PW-6’s evidence made it clear that there was no prior enmity between the appellant and his father; the appellant’s hostility was towards Sachin Poddar because of the earlier Mukhiya election.
From this, the Court concluded that the deceased was not the person with whom the appellant was originally quarrelling. He was an intervenor. There was no evidence of any previous grudge against him. The firing was undoubtedly deliberate, but these surrounding circumstances did not convincingly show that the appellant intended to cause the death of the deceased.
The trial court had reasoned that because the appellant took out the pistol and fired immediately after the deceased intervened, the act must have been intentional, and therefore it was murder. The High Court disagreed with this inference. It held that merely because the firing was a deliberate act does not automatically mean that the specific intention required under Section 302 IPC—to cause death or such bodily injury as is sufficient to cause death—was present. The mental element has to be judged from all the facts.
At the same time, the Bench emphasised that using a firearm and firing at a person clearly carries the knowledge that the act is likely to cause death. The appellant’s conduct could not be excused. The Court held that his act was culpable, but given the sudden quarrel, the intervention by the deceased, lack of prior enmity, and the fact that his real dispute was with Sachin Poddar, this was a case of culpable homicide not amounting to murder. It fell under Section 304 Part II IPC, where there is knowledge that death is likely but no intention to cause death.
To support this legal conclusion, the Court relied on several decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court and a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court.
In Dattatraya v. State of Maharashtra, (2024) 14 SCC 286, the Supreme Court had converted a conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part II IPC in a case arising out of a sudden fight. There, the Court held that though the accused knew his act could result in death, there was no intention to cause death.
The Bench also referred to Jhaptu Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2014) 12 SCC 410. In that case, as in the present one, the deceased had intervened to pacify an altercation and received a single fatal gunshot. The Supreme Court found no prior intention to kill and altered the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC.
Further, the Bench relied on the detailed principles laid down in Anbazhagan v. State rep. by the Inspector of Police, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 857. In that case, the Supreme Court explained the difference between “intention” and “knowledge” in distinguishing murder under Section 302 from culpable homicide under Section 304, especially in single-injury cases and sudden quarrels. The Patna High Court quoted paragraph 66 of that decision, which summarises when an offence will fall under Section 304 Part II IPC.
The Patna High Court also noted the decision of the Allahabad High Court in Shyam Naresh & Anr. v. State of U.P., 2025:AHC:106362-DB. There, too, a sudden altercation led to a shooting with a country-made pistol. The conviction was modified from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part II IPC due to lack of premeditation and intention to kill. That Bench had also relied on Jhaptu Ram.
After applying these legal principles to the facts, the Patna High Court held that the present case clearly fell under Section 304 Part II IPC. Accordingly, it altered the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part II IPC.
On the Arms Act charge, the Court considered that the pistol and cartridge were produced before the police by villagers and not recovered from the appellant’s own custody, a fact already used by the trial court to acquit him of offences under Sections 25(1-B) and 26 of the Arms Act. However, the High Court pointed out that consistent eyewitness evidence showed that the appellant actually used the firearm during the occurrence. PW-3 and PW-6 directly attributed the firing to him. PW-11 and PW-12 proved the production and seizure of the country-made pistol and cartridge. On this basis, the Court saw no reason to interfere with his conviction under Section 27 of the Arms Act.
Regarding sentence, the Court took note that the appellant had been in custody from 19.05.2007 to 28.08.2009, and again from 04.02.2019 (the date of conviction). An application for suspension of sentence recorded that he had already undergone more than seven years and eleven months of imprisonment at that stage.
Considering the sudden nature of the incident, the absence of proven prior enmity with the deceased, the re-classification of the offence to Section 304 Part II IPC, and the period already spent in jail, the Bench held that a sentence of ten years’ rigorous imprisonment would meet the ends of justice for the offence under Section 304 Part II IPC.
The conviction and sentence under Section 27 of the Arms Act were maintained, with both sentences directed to run concurrently. The Court also directed that the period already undergone in custody should be set off in accordance with law. If, after this set-off, the appellant had already completed the sentence and was not wanted in any other case, he was to be released forthwith.
In conclusion, the appeal was partly allowed: the conviction was scaled down from murder to culpable homicide not amounting to murder, and the sentence was reduced accordingly, but the finding that the appellant fired the shot and used a firearm illegally was upheld.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is important for families and accused persons in Bihar whose cases involve deaths arising out of sudden village quarrels.
The Patna High Court has shown that even where a firearm is used and death follows, the court will closely examine whether there was any prior planning or personal enmity with the victim.
If the victim is someone who only steps in to stop a quarrel, and there is no earlier grudge against him, the case may fall under culpable homicide not amounting to murder, not Section 302 IPC.
At the same time, the judgment also makes it clear that using a gun in a quarrel is a very serious act. Even without intention to kill, knowledge that such an act is likely to cause death can still lead to long jail terms, as seen from the 10-year rigorous imprisonment imposed here.
The Court further clarifies that even if villagers recover the weapon, a conviction under Section 27 of the Arms Act can stand if there is clear evidence that the accused used the firearm during the incident.
Legal Issues and Answers
- Issue: Whether the appellant’s act in firing at the deceased amounted to “murder” under Section 302 IPC or “culpable homicide not amounting to murder” under Section 304 IPC.
Answer: The Court held that due to the sudden quarrel, intervention of the deceased, absence of prior enmity, and the fact that the original dispute was with another person, the case fell under Section 304 Part II IPC, based on knowledge but without intention to cause death. - Issue: Whether the conviction of the appellant under Section 27 of the Arms Act could stand when the pistol and empty cartridge were not recovered from his direct possession but produced by villagers.
Answer: Yes. The Court held that consistent eyewitness evidence showing that the appellant used the firearm, supported by production and seizure of the weapon, was sufficient to uphold the conviction under Section 27 of the Arms Act. - Issue: What sentence was appropriate after altering the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part II IPC.
Answer: Taking into account the circumstances of the incident and the period already undergone in custody, the Court imposed a sentence of ten years’ rigorous imprisonment under Section 304 Part II IPC, with the sentence under Section 27 of the Arms Act to run concurrently.
Cases Cited by the Court
- Dattatraya v. State of Maharashtra, (2024) 14 SCC 286.
- Jhaptu Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2014) 12 SCC 410.
- Anbazhagan v. State rep. by the Inspector of Police, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 857.
- Shyam Naresh & Anr. v. State of U.P., 2025:AHC:106362-DB.
Case Details
Case Number: Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 296 of 2019, arising out of Surajgarha P.S. Case No. 140 of 2007, Sessions Trial No. 681 of 2008.
Case Title: Sudhir Rai @ Sudhir Mahato v. The State of Bihar.
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bibek Chaudhuri and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rana Vikram Singh.
Judgment Date: 17.08.2026.
Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 59
Advocates: For the appellant: Mr. Arjun Prasad, Advocate, and Mr. Parmanand Pd. Nr. Sahi, Advocate. For the State: Km. Shashi Bala Verma, Advocate.
Nature of the Case: Criminal appeal (Division Bench) against judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the Additional District Judge, Fast Track Court No. 1st, Lakhisarai.
Statutory Provisions Involved: Sections 302, 304 Part II of the Indian Penal Code; Sections 25(1-B)(a), 26 and 27 of the Arms Act.
Link to Full Judgment: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/NSMyOTYjMjAxOSMxI04=-DIl1tadFUpE=
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar, you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



