Case Background
The petitioner was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in a government school in Bihar. His appointment was not a routine one. It came pursuant to directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in SLP (C) No. 26824 of 2012.
He was one of 34,540 teachers appointed on the recommendation of a committee headed by Hon’ble Justice S. K. Chattopadhyay. This committee was constituted under the directions of the Supreme Court to supervise selection and appointment of teachers to vacant posts identified by the State of Bihar.
The petitioner joined service on 09.02.2012 and was posted as an Assistant Teacher in the upgraded middle school, Basthi, Ramgarhwa, in East Champaran district.
The petitioner had obtained his B.Ed. degree from Lord Buddha Mission Primary Teachers Training College, Kartaha, Vaishali. On 31.01.2020, by Memo No. 328 issued under the signature of the District Education Officer, East Champaran, Motihari, his services were terminated. Before passing this order, the authorities had issued a show cause notice to him, to which he submitted his reply.
The ground for termination was that the B.Ed. college from which he had obtained his qualification was allegedly not a recognized institution and had never been granted approval by the State of Bihar for running a B.Ed. course.
The petitioner challenged this termination in the Patna High Court through the present writ petition (Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15260 of 2023). During the pendency of this writ petition, an important development took place.
By Memo No. 5090 dated 22.08.2024, issued by the District Education Officer, East Champaran, Motihari, the petitioner and others were reinstated in service. However, the memo clearly stated that, applying the principle of “no work no pay”, they would not be paid salary for the period during which they had remained out of service.
In the petitioner’s case, this meant denial of salary from the date of termination, 31.01.2020, until his date of superannuation, 31.10.2022. After reinstatement, the original reliefs in his writ petition became infructuous. He therefore filed I.A. No. 1 of 2025 to seek additional prayers, especially for back wages.
The Court allowed I.A. No. 1 of 2025 and treated the prayers therein as part of the main writ petition. The dispute then narrowed down to a single question: whether the petitioner was entitled to salary for the period between his termination and superannuation.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The petitioner’s counsel argued that the termination itself was unjust and based on grounds already settled by higher judicial forums. The core submission was that he had been appointed under the direct supervision of Hon’ble Justice S. K. Chattopadhyay Committee, constituted by the Supreme Court, and as one among thousands of teachers selected in that special process.
According to the petitioner, the later termination on the plea that his B.Ed. institution was not recognized was legally unsustainable, because the question of eligibility and verification had already been considered during the selection process overseen by the Committee.
It was further argued that during the pendency of the writ petition, the authorities themselves reinstated him through Memo No. 5090 dated 22.08.2024. This act of reinstatement, without any finding of misconduct or fraud on his part, showed that the earlier termination was wrongful.
The petitioner’s counsel stressed that he had been “forced not to work” due to the illegal action of the authorities. Since there was no fault on his part, the principle of “no work no pay” should not be applied mechanically to deny his livelihood for nearly three years, including up to his retirement.
To support this claim, the petitioner relied on a previous decision of a learned Single Judge of the Patna High Court in CWJC No. 969 of 2025 (Shambhu Paswan and Anr. vs. The State of Bihar and Ors.), decided on 12.05.2026. In that similar matter, the Court had directed the authorities to compute and pay entire back wages and other consequential benefits from the date of termination till reinstatement, along with simple interest at 6% per annum.
On these grounds, the petitioner sought full salary for the period 31.01.2020 to 31.10.2022.
On behalf of the State, the learned counsel did not dispute two key facts: that the petitioner had been terminated on 31.01.2020 and that he was reinstated by Memo No. 5090 dated 22.08.2024. However, the State argued that during the period between termination and superannuation the petitioner had admittedly not performed any work.
The State relied on the general principle of “no work no pay” and submitted that because the petitioner did not discharge duties during this period, he was not entitled to salary. According to the State, the order contained in Memo No. 5090 dated 22.08.2024, denying back wages, did not suffer from any illegality.
The Court then proceeded to examine the broader legal background of similar appointments and terminations. It noted that the petitioner was one among 34,540 teachers appointed pursuant to the Supreme Court’s directions in SLP (C) No. 26824 of 2012 and that his joining had been accepted on 09.02.2012 as an Assistant Teacher at Basthi, Ramgarhwa.
The Court highlighted that the petitioner and several others had been terminated on the same day, 31.01.2020, all on the ground that their B.Ed. degree was from an institution which was not recognized or approved by the State Government.
Crucially, the Court referred to an earlier judgment of a Division Bench of the Patna High Court in LPA No. 1254 of 2016 and analogous cases. In that decision, the Division Bench had dealt directly with the issue of verification of documents and degrees of persons appointed under the Supreme Court’s directions in the same SLP.
The Division Bench had held that teachers appointed as per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, under the supervision of Hon’ble Justice S. K. Chattopadhyay, could not be terminated on the ground that their qualifications had not been properly verified, unless the Supreme Court itself had permitted such action.
It was recorded that the petitioner’s eligibility had been settled by the Justice S. K. Chattopadhyay Committee, which had been appointed by the Supreme Court to oversee the selection and appointment to the vacant teaching posts identified by the State of Bihar in its undertaking before the Court.
The Division Bench had also noted that while verification of credentials and qualifications was directed, such verification could not be reopened at a very late stage to unsettle appointments made under Supreme Court orders. Further, it had been observed that the State should have been more vigilant at the time of making appointments, instead of punishing the appointees later for its own lapses.
Relying on this Division Bench judgment, the Single Judge in the present case concluded that the termination of the petitioner on the ground of his B.Ed. college not being recognized was contrary to the legal position already laid down in LPA No. 1254 of 2016.
The Court then specifically examined Memo No. 5090 dated 22.08.2024, by which the petitioner had been reinstated but deprived of back wages on the basis of “no work no pay”. In the Court’s considered opinion, once the foundational ground of termination had been found unsustainable in light of the Division Bench decision, the consequence could not be pushed entirely on the petitioner.
The Court held that, in these circumstances, the principle of “no work no pay” could not be applied against the petitioner, because his non-working during the period was not voluntary. Rather, it was the result of an order which itself stood on a legally weak footing, contradicted by the Division Bench ruling.
Therefore, the Court found that the part of Memo No. 5090 which denied him any salary for the period of termination was liable to be interfered with.
Accordingly, the Patna High Court directed the District Education Officer, East Champaran, Motihari, to pay the petitioner his salary for the period 31.01.2020 to 31.10.2022, which is the period from termination to his superannuation.
The Court further ordered that the entire salary must be calculated and paid within three months from the date the order is received or produced before the authority. It also provided a clear consequence for non-compliance: if the payment is not made within three months, the petitioner will be entitled to simple interest at 6% per annum on the due amount from the date of filing of the writ petition till the date of actual payment.
With these observations and directions, the writ petition was allowed. Any pending interlocutory applications were also disposed of.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is important for teachers and other employees appointed under special recruitment processes supervised by courts or independent committees.
The Patna High Court has reinforced that when appointments are made under the direct control of the Supreme Court and a judicial committee, the State cannot later unsettle them by reopening qualification issues, unless the Supreme Court allows it.
For similarly placed teachers in Bihar, especially those among the 34,540 appointees under SLP (C) No. 26824 of 2012, this decision clarifies that wrongful termination and later reinstatement cannot automatically be followed by denial of back wages on “no work no pay”.
The ruling also sends a clear message to government departments: they must be careful and thorough at the time of appointment and cannot shift the burden of their own lack of vigilance onto employees many years later.
Practically, for workers who are removed due to administrative mistakes and later brought back, this judgment shows that courts may grant full salary for the period of forced unemployment, especially where there is no fault of the employee.
Legal Issues and Answers
- Issue: Can a teacher appointed under Supreme Court-supervised recruitment be denied salary for the period between wrongful termination and superannuation on the basis of “no work no pay” after later reinstatement?
Answer: No. In light of the Division Bench ruling in LPA No. 1254 of 2016 and the special nature of the appointment process, the Patna High Court held that the denial of salary was unjustified and directed payment of full back wages for the termination period, with interest in case of delay.
Cases Cited by the Court
- SLP (C) No. 26824 of 2012, Hon’ble Supreme Court of India (regarding recruitment of 34,540 teachers and supervision by Justice S. K. Chattopadhyay Committee).
- LPA No. 1254 of 2016 and analogous cases, Division Bench of Patna High Court (holding that teachers appointed under the Supreme Court-directed process cannot be terminated on late verification of qualifications, unless permitted by the Supreme Court).
- CWJC No. 969 of 2025, Shambhu Paswan and Anr. vs. The State of Bihar and Ors., Single Judge decision dated 12.05.2026 (granting full back wages and 6% interest in a similar termination and reinstatement scenario), cited by the petitioner.
Case Details
Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15260 of 2023 (CNR No. BRHC010910372023)
Case Title: Vishnudeo Prasad Sah vs. The State of Bihar and Others
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ritesh Kumar
Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 183
Advocates:
- For the Petitioner: Mr. Gyanendra Kumar Shukla, Advocate; Ms. Anushka Ritu, Advocate; Ms. Shweta Kumari, Advocate
- For the State: Ms. Bandana Singh, SC-19; Mr. Ambrish Kumar, AC to SC-19
Nature of the Case: Writ petition under civil writ jurisdiction challenging termination and denial of back wages to an Assistant Teacher appointed under Supreme Court directions, and seeking consequential monetary benefits.
Link: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MTUjMTUyNjAjMjAyMyMxI04=-yjmv–ak1–Uck5S0=
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



