Case Background
The petitioner is a Joint General Manager in an Ordnance Factory, originally posted at Ordnance Factory, Nalanda in Bihar and later transferred to Ordnance Factory, Dehradun in Uttarakhand. A departmental disciplinary proceeding was held against him under the Ministry of Defence.
Following this inquiry, the disciplinary authority in the Ministry of Defence passed an order dated 30.08.2013 imposing a major penalty on the petitioner. The penalty was described as withholding two annual increments in the form of “reduction to two stages lower in the time scale of pay” for one year with non-cumulative effect.
This punishment order was later confirmed by a reviewed Central Government administrative order dated 28.04.2015. The petitioner challenged these orders before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Patna Bench, by filing Original Application (O.A.) No. 050/00583/2015 along with Miscellaneous Application No. 050/00263/2017.
On 03.01.2019, the CAT, Patna Bench, dismissed the petitioner’s O.A. and upheld the departmental action. Aggrieved by this, the petitioner approached the Patna High Court under its writ jurisdiction in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 9540 of 2021.
In the writ petition, the petitioner asked the High Court to set aside the CAT order dated 03.01.2019, to quash the reviewed order dated 28.04.2015, and to quash the original penalty order dated 30.08.2013. He also sought any other relief to which he might be entitled.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The Division Bench of the Patna High Court, comprising Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vikash Jain and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Kumar Verma, heard both sides. The focus of the hearing was not on the correctness of the disciplinary proceedings themselves, but on whether the writ petition could be entertained after a significant delay.
At the very outset, counsel for the respondents raised a preliminary objection. In paragraph 6 of their counter affidavit, they pointed out that the CAT order was dated 03.01.2019, whereas the writ petition had been filed only in 2021. This meant that the challenge had been brought after a delay of more than two years.
The respondents highlighted that the petitioner had not, in his writ petition, given any facts or details to show that the disciplinary inquiry had not followed proper procedure or that any provision of law had been violated. Instead, they focused on the fact that the petition was late and did not carry any explanation for this delay.
Once this objection was raised, the petitioner sought to justify the delay in his rejoinder. He specifically relied on paragraph 16 of the rejoinder affidavit, which the Court reproduced in its judgment.
In that paragraph, the petitioner narrated that his O.A. before the CAT remained pending until 02.01.2019. He stated that he was transferred in July 2016 from Ordnance Factory, Nalanda to Ordnance Factory, Dehradun. According to him, this transfer did not come to the knowledge of his then counsel handling the CAT case.
The petitioner further claimed that he had lost his old mobile number, in which his counsel’s contact details were saved, and that he had to purchase a new mobile with a different number. Because of this, he said, a communication gap developed between him and his counsel, which continued for a long time.
He also mentioned that, during the first wave of COVID-19 in April 2020, he and his family members fell ill. He asserted that only after recovering did he travel to Patna on 24.01.2021, while on the way to his native village near Barh. During this visit, he contacted his counsel.
According to the petitioner, his counsel then informed him about the CAT’s decision, gave him a certified copy of the order, and only then did he decide to challenge it before the High Court. The petitioner claimed that he immediately resolved to file the writ petition, engaged new counsel, and the writ was filed on 27.01.2021 and registered on 29.01.2021.
In the same paragraph, he pleaded that the two-year delay was caused by these unavoidable circumstances: transfer, loss of mobile contact, illness due to COVID-19, and the communication gap with his lawyer. He requested that the Court condone or ignore the delay, insisting that he had not intentionally caused any delay and that he was “quite innocent” in this context.
The Patna High Court closely examined this explanation. The Bench was not convinced. The judges observed that it appeared “highly unlikely” that, after being transferred from Nalanda to Dehradun in July 2016, there was no communication between the petitioner and his lawyer for about five years.
The Court also found the explanation about the lost mobile phone to be vague. The petitioner had not provided any concrete details such as the actual mobile numbers involved or the dates on which the phone was lost or the new number was obtained. The absence of such specific information weakened his claim.
Further, the Court reminded that writ jurisdiction is essentially an equitable jurisdiction. The principle is that “an equity court comes to the aid of a diligent litigant.” In other words, a person who wants the Court’s extraordinary relief must show that he has been reasonably careful and active in pursuing his case.
In this case, the Court noted that the petitioner had not indicated what steps he had taken, if any, to contact his counsel or to check the status of his pending case before the CAT during this long period. There was no record of letters, emails, calls, or any other effort from his side.
Another important point for the Court was that the writ petition, at the time it was filed, did not contain any explanation at all for the delay. The reasons were supplied only later, in the rejoinder, and only after the respondents had pointed out the delay in their counter affidavit. This sequence suggested that the explanation was an afterthought rather than a genuine account of continuous difficulties.
Taking all this into account, the Bench held that the delay and laches on the part of the petitioner had not been satisfactorily explained. “Laches” is a legal term meaning that a person has slept over his rights and approached the Court too late, without a good reason.
Because the writ petition was found to be barred by unexplained delay, the Patna High Court decided not to interfere with the CAT’s order. The Court did not go into the merits of the disciplinary proceedings or the correctness of the punishment.
In conclusion, the Court dismissed the writ petition. This meant that the CAT’s order dated 03.01.2019, which had upheld the reviewed government order of 28.04.2015 and the original penalty order of 30.08.2013, continues to stand. The major penalty imposed on the petitioner therefore remains effective.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is important for government employees and other public servants who face departmental action and want to challenge it in court. It shows that even if a person feels the punishment is harsh or unfair, the High Court will not examine the case if the challenge is brought too late without a solid, believable explanation.
The Patna High Court has underlined that a litigant must stay in touch with the case and with their lawyer. Simply blaming transfer, change of mobile number, or general hardship is not enough, especially when the delay is long and the details are vague.
The decision reinforces the principle that courts in writ jurisdiction are meant for those who act diligently. For employees, it sends a clear message: if you receive an adverse order from a tribunal or a department, you should seek legal advice and move the High Court within a reasonable time, or you may lose the chance altogether.
Legal Issues and Answers
Issue: Whether the Patna High Court should entertain a writ petition filed in 2021 challenging a Central Administrative Tribunal order dated 03.01.2019, in the absence of a convincing explanation for the delay.
Answer: No. The Court held that the petitioner failed to satisfactorily explain the delay of more than two years, showed lack of diligence, and therefore the writ petition was liable to be dismissed on grounds of delay and laches.
Cases Cited by the Court
- The judgment does not mention or rely on any cited precedents by name.
Case Details
Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 9540 of 2021
Case Title: Prashant Kumar vs. The Union of India & Ors.
Citation: 2022 (4) PLJR 72
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vikash Jain and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Kumar Verma
Advocates: Mr. Shambhu Sharan Singh, Advocate for the petitioner; Mr. Raj Kamal, Central Government Counsel (CGC) for the respondents
Nature of the Case: Writ petition under civil writ jurisdiction challenging a Central Administrative Tribunal order upholding a major penalty in departmental proceedings
Date of Judgment: 02.11.2021
Link to Judgment: Click here to view the official Patna High Court judgment
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



