Rejection of adopted son’s job claim set aside — Patna High Court, 2026

Shubham Shivansh

Reviewed by: Shubham Shivansh

License Number: D/7102/2022

Last Reviewed On: 20-11-2026

Shubham Shivansh is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in civil disputes, service law, and GST matters. He represents clients in property disputes, contractual disagreements, service-related grievances, and tax compliance matters before the Patna High Court and other jurisdictions. His practice handles civil litigation, employment-related disputes, and regulatory matters for individuals and businesses across Bihar.

In this case, a man challenged the refusal of a government power company to give him a compassionate job after his adoptive mother’s death. The Patna High Court set aside the rejection orders. The Court held that the authorities took an overly technical view of adoption and delay. The company must now freshly consider his claim within three months.

Case Background

The case arises from the death of a Class IV employee of the electricity department at Begusarai. The maternal grandfather of the petitioner worked under the then Bihar State Electricity Board/North Bihar Power Distribution Company Limited. After his death, his widow, Late Reshma Devi, was appointed on compassionate ground as a Messenger in the Electric Supply Sub-Division, Begusarai.

The petitioner is the biological son of Shri Ram Karan Sah. He is the fourth child of his biological parents. From childhood, however, he resided with his maternal grandparents. After the maternal grandfather died, the maternal grandmother decided, with consent of his biological parents, to adopt him as her son.

To record this decision, Reshma Devi swore an affidavit before a Notary Public on 18.02.1999 stating that she would adopt the petitioner. The petitioner, in turn, swore his own affidavit on 22.07.1999 before the Notary at Begusarai, declaring that he would live with his maternal grandmother for her whole life and would support and look after her in her old age and illness.

Subsequently, on 12.01.2001, a registered Deed of Adoption was executed by his biological parents in favour of Reshma Devi, as adoptive mother. This deed was registered formally, well after the affidavits.

While still in service, Reshma Devi died in harness on 25.11.2007. After her death, the petitioner approached the electricity authorities in January 2010. He sought both compassionate appointment and payment of death-cum-retirement dues on the basis that he was her adopted son.

The authorities instructed him to obtain a succession certificate. He accordingly filed Succession Case No.33/2010 before the court of the Sub-Judge-I, Begusarai. On 15.05.2013, the court issued a succession certificate in his favour. He submitted this certificate to the electricity authorities.

On 09.01.2016, the Executive Engineer (Electrical), Electric Supply Sub-Division, Begusarai (respondent no.6) issued letter No.52. In that letter, the officer accepted the petitioner’s claim to death-cum-retirement benefits as adoptive son and sought guidance from the Superintending Engineer (respondent no.7) regarding the rules for compassionate appointment.

The petitioner was then orally asked to produce a family members’ certificate of the deceased employee. He applied for it, and the Circle Officer, Barauni, issued Certificate No.19 dated 07.02.2017 certifying the family members of Reshma Devi.

It was only after all this that the petitioner was, for the first time, told to submit his application for compassionate appointment in the prescribed format. On 18.03.2017, he submitted the application in that format, which the office head recommended and forwarded to the competent authority.

However, by letter No.624 dated 22.12.2017 issued by the Deputy General Manager (respondent no.5), his application was rejected. A further representation dated 02.02.2018 was also rejected on 27.03.2018. These two rejection letters were challenged in this writ petition before the Patna High Court.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The petitioner attacked the rejection mainly on three points: the adoption was genuine and within law, there was no real delay from his side, and the authorities could not accept him as adopted son for dues but reject him for compassionate appointment.

On adoption, he argued that the real adoption took place in 1999 itself, when affidavits were sworn, and that his registered adoption deed of 2001 was merely a later formal record. He pointed out that he was born on 01.03.1985. Thus, on 18.02.1999 he was about 13 years 11 months old, and on 22.07.1999 he was about 14 years 4 months old—both ages below 15 years. This, he said, satisfied Section 10(iv) of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956, which requires that the person adopted should not have completed 15 years, unless a custom allows otherwise.

He further submitted that the same adoption documents and succession certificate had already been accepted by the respondents when they released the death-cum-retirement benefits of Reshma Devi to him. Having accepted him as adopted son and dependent for that purpose, the authorities, he argued, could not turn around and doubt his status only when it came to compassionate appointment. Doing so amounted to taking two opposite stands on the same facts.

On delay, the petitioner pointed to his approach in January 2010—well within five years of Reshma Devi’s death on 25.11.2007. According to him, the formal prescribed-form application of 18.03.2017 was only the last step forced upon him by the department’s repeated demands for new documents: first the succession certificate, then a family members’ certificate, and then an application in a specific format. He relied on the Executive Engineer’s letter No.52 dated 09.01.2016, which itself referred to his application for compassionate appointment and showed that his claim was pending long before the final rejection of 22.12.2017.

To counter an overly strict reading of the adoption rule, his counsel relied on the Division Bench judgment of the Patna High Court in Most. Shitali Devi and Anr. v. Union of India, C.W.J.C. No.7300 of 2001. In that case, the Court had recognised that in poorer and middle-class families, children are often raised by foster or adoptive parents without formal registered documents. The Division Bench warned that a rigid, hyper-technical approach to compassionate appointment could provide a “soul-less escape” to the administration and defeat the very purpose of such schemes, which is to help bereaved families survive.

The Bench in Shitali Devi also said that while fraud or misrepresentation must be checked, a genuine adoption and foster relationship not made merely to claim a job should generally be accepted for compassionate appointment.

The electricity company opposed the writ. It argued that as per Office Order No.396 dated 29.03.2017, an adopted child counts as dependent only if the adoption follows the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956. They said that because the registered deed of adoption was dated 12.01.2001, and the petitioner was born on 01.03.1985, he had already completed 15 years 10 months and 11 days by that date. Hence, in their view, the adoption violated Section 10(iv), and his claim for compassionate appointment was invalid.

The respondents further relied on Standing Order No.756 dated 18.02.1994. Under this, an application for compassionate appointment must be filed within five years of the employee’s death. They claimed that since the formal application in the prescribed format was made only in 2017, almost nine years after the death in 2007, it was time-barred.

They also emphasised that the succession certificate in Succession Case No.33/2010 authorised the petitioner only to receive monetary dues—GSS, GPF, gratuity and leave encashment. It did not, and could not, create any right to a job.

After hearing both sides, the Patna High Court framed the central question: whether rejection of the petitioner’s claim on these three grounds—violation of Section 10(iv), delay beyond five years, and limited scope of succession certificate—was legally sustainable.

The Court first examined Section 10 of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956 and reiterated that adoption under Hindu law is completed by the actual giving and taking of the child, usually with customary ceremonies. A later registered deed is a mode of recording a past adoption and raises a presumption under Section 16 that the adoption is validly made, but it is not itself the moment of adoption.

Looking at the record, the Court found that the maternal grandmother had sworn her affidavit of adoption on 18.02.1999 and the petitioner had sworn his supporting affidavit on 22.07.1999. Both showed that the adoption relationship had already been formed between them by those dates, when the petitioner was under 15 years old. The registered deed of 12.01.2001 was, therefore, a later formalisation of an adoption that had effectively taken place earlier within the age limit.

The Court held that the authorities committed an error by mechanically treating the date of the registered deed alone as the “adoption date” for computing age, and by ignoring the earlier affidavits which were part of the same set of adoption documents. This approach, the Court said, was contrary to the principle in Shitali Devi. Once there were materials showing a genuine pre-existing adoption and foster relationship, the authorities were bound to examine the entire factual matrix and determine if the relationship was bona fide or fabricated. Here, there was no finding that the affidavits or other documents were false. Yet the claim was rejected on a narrow technical reading of Section 10(iv).

On delay, the Court noted several key facts. The petitioner had approached the authorities in January 2010, within five years of the death. Letter No.52 dated 09.01.2016 itself showed that his request for compassionate appointment was already under consideration. The subsequent insistence on a family members’ certificate and finally on a prescribed-form application came from the department. In these circumstances, the Court held, the delay in filing the final format application could not be blamed on the petitioner. It was caused by the shifting and successive demands of the respondents themselves.

The Court stated an important principle: a claimant should not suffer for delay caused by the very authority before whom his claim is pending. Therefore, rejecting the claim on the basis of Standing Order No.756’s five-year limit was unsustainable in this case.

On the third ground, relating to the succession certificate, the Court accepted the petitioner’s contention that the respondents could not “approbate and reprobate” on the same documents. The same succession certificate and adoption records had been accepted when death-cum-retirement benefits were released to the petitioner as adopted son and dependent. It was not open to the authorities to treat him as adopted son for monetary dues but deny the same status for compassionate appointment, which also flows from the employee’s death in harness. Two inconsistent stands on the same relationship could not be allowed.

The Court then recalled the underlying object of compassionate appointment: to provide a job to a dependent of a government servant who dies in harness or retires on medical grounds, leaving the family in sudden financial distress. The scheme is meant to save the family from destitution and help them tide over an emergency, not to be frustrated by technicalities.

Considering all these aspects, the Court held that the rejection order dated 22.12.2017 and the follow-up order dated 27.03.2018 were unsustainable and quashed them. It directed the respondents to reconsider the petitioner’s claim for compassionate appointment, treating him as the legally adopted son and dependent of Late Reshma Devi, in the light of the Court’s observations. The reconsideration must be done without relying on the technical objections already rejected by the Court and must result in a reasoned and speaking order within three months from the date of receipt or production of a copy of the judgment.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is important for families where children are raised by grandparents or other relatives without early formal documents. The Patna High Court recognised that adoption, especially in poorer households, may begin as a living relationship and be recorded later.

The Court made it clear that authorities cannot ignore early evidence of adoption and focus only on a later registration date to deny benefits. It also protected applicants from being punished for delays caused by departmental procedures and repeated demands for new documents.

For dependents of employees who die in harness, especially in Bihar’s power sector and similar government-linked bodies, this case signals that their genuine relationships and timely approaches must be fairly considered. Technical objections cannot be used to defeat the humanitarian purpose of compassionate appointment.

Legal Issues and Answers

  • Issue: Can the claim for compassionate appointment of an adopted son be rejected solely because the registered deed of adoption was executed after he turned 15, ignoring earlier adoption-related documents?
    Answer: No. The Court held that adoption is completed by giving and taking, and earlier affidavits from 1999 showed a genuine adoption when the petitioner was below 15. Treating only the 2001 deed as decisive and ignoring the earlier documents was erroneous and contrary to the law and the principle in Most. Shitali Devi.
  • Issue: Was the petitioner’s application barred by the five-year limit in Standing Order No.756 due to filing the prescribed-form application after nine years of the employee’s death?
    Answer: No. The Court found that the petitioner had approached the authorities in January 2010, within five years. Later delay was caused by the respondents’ own shifting requirements, so the petitioner could not be blamed. The ground of delay was held unsustainable.
  • Issue: Could the respondents accept the petitioner as adopted son for releasing monetary dues on the basis of the succession certificate but deny him the same status for compassionate appointment?
    Answer: No. The Court held that the authorities cannot take inconsistent stands on the same set of documents. Having accepted the adoption for death-cum-retirement benefits, they could not reject the same relationship for compassionate appointment.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • Most. Shitali Devi and Anr. v. Union of India, C.W.J.C. No.7300 of 2001 (Patna High Court).

Case Details

Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.9496 of 2018

Case Title: Vijay Kumar Sah v. The State of Bihar & Ors.

Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 234

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Kumar Manish

Date of Judgment: 08.09.2026

Advocates:

  • For the petitioner: Mr. Manindra Kishore Singh, Advocate
  • For the State (Respondent No.1): Mr. Y.P. Sinha, AAG-7
  • For respondent Nos.2 to 7: Mr. Sanjeev Kumar, Advocate; Mr. Ravi Kumar, Advocate
  • For NBPDCL: Mr. Aman Kumar, Advocate

Nature of the case: Writ petition (civil) challenging rejection of claim for compassionate appointment.

Link: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MTUjOTQ5NiMyMDE4IzEjTg==-2WbACs30stE=

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News