Transfer of Pharmacist Restored within Division — Patna High Court, 2021

Shubham Shivansh

Reviewed by: Shubham Shivansh

License Number: D/7102/2022

Last Reviewed On: 19-08-2026

Shubham Shivansh is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in civil disputes, service law, and GST matters. He represents clients in property disputes, contractual disagreements, service-related grievances, and tax compliance matters before the Patna High Court and other jurisdictions. His practice handles civil litigation, employment-related disputes, and regulatory matters for individuals and businesses across Bihar.

In this case a government pharmacist challenged the cancellation of his transfer within Patna division. The Patna High Court examined who had legal power to transfer pharmacists. The Court held that the Regional Deputy Director could transfer him and the Director-in-Chief could not cancel that order on the grounds taken. The earlier transfer was restored and the writ petition was allowed.

Case Background

The petitioner was working as a Pharmacist at Jagdishpur in the district of Bhojpur, within Patna division.

By Memo No. 635 dated 26.06.2019, the Regional Deputy Director, Patna Division, Health Services, Patna transferred him to Danapur, which is also within the same division.

Several months later, by Letter No. 102(4) dated 23.01.2020, the Director-in-Chief, Health Services, Bihar, Patna cancelled this transfer order.

According to the impugned letter, the cancellation was made on the ground that the Regional Deputy Director had no jurisdiction to transfer the petitioner. The letter proceeded as if the earlier delegation of power to the Regional Deputy Director was not applicable.

Feeling aggrieved by this cancellation, the petitioner approached the Patna High Court in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 3680 of 2020. He sought quashing of the Director-in-Chief’s cancellation letter and enforcement of his transfer order dated 26.06.2019.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The main dispute before the Patna High Court was a narrow but important service matter: who had the legal authority to transfer a government Pharmacist within a division in the State of Bihar.

The petitioner’s case rested on earlier executive orders of the Health Department. He relied in particular on a Departmental Resolution contained in Memo No. 658(3) dated 05.10.2006 (referred to as Annexure-1). This resolution delegated power to the Regional Deputy Director to make inter-district transfers, within a division, of Class III employees.

The petitioner pointed out that he was a Pharmacist, which is treated as a Class III post, and both Jagdishpur (Ara) and Danapur are within Patna division. Therefore, under the 05.10.2006 resolution, the Regional Deputy Director was the competent authority to transfer him.

On this basis, he argued that his transfer from Jagdishpur to Danapur by Memo No. 635 dated 26.06.2019 was validly issued by the proper authority. If the Regional Deputy Director was competent to order the transfer, the question then arose: could the Director-in-Chief cancel that order on the ground of lack of jurisdiction?

The petitioner’s counsel submitted that the Director-in-Chief had no such authority to undo a validly issued transfer order of the Regional Deputy Director in these circumstances. According to the petitioner, the cancellation by Letter No. 102(4) dated 23.01.2020 was unsustainable in law.

On the other side, the State opposed the writ petition. The respondents argued that the petitioner, being a Pharmacist, was governed by the Bihar Pharmacist Cadre Rules, 2014. They submitted that under these Rules the appointing authority for Pharmacists is the Director-in-Chief (Health Services), Bihar.

Referring to Rule 22 of the 2014 Rules, the respondents contended that this statutory framework nullified or overrode the earlier executive order of 05.10.2006. On this logic, they argued that the Director-in-Chief was the only competent authority to effect transfers of Pharmacists. Therefore, according to the State, the Regional Deputy Director had no jurisdiction to transfer the petitioner on 26.06.2019, and the Director-in-Chief was right in cancelling that transfer order.

The Court heard counsels for both sides and closely examined the legal position. The key focus of the Court’s reasoning was whether the Bihar Pharmacist Cadre Rules, 2014 actually dealt with transfers, and if so, whether they displaced the earlier executive order delegating transfer power to the Regional Deputy Director.

The Court first noted that the petitioner’s posting and subsequent movement were undisputed. He was serving at Jagdishpur, Ara. He was then shifted to Danapur on 26.06.2019 by the Regional Deputy Director, Patna Division, acting under the executive order dated 05.10.2006. This transfer was within the same division, exactly the situation contemplated by the 2006 resolution.

The Court then turned to the 2014 Pharmacist Cadre Rules. It observed that these Rules are framed for governing the Pharmacist cadre, particularly in relation to appointment to the post of Pharmacist.

Importantly, the Court observed that under Rule 2 of the 2014 Rules there is no definition of “transfer”. From this absence, the Court drew an inference: the 2014 Rules do not deal with transfer of Pharmacists. They primarily concern appointment to the cadre and related matters, not postings or transfer power.

Given this, the Court concluded that the source of power to transfer Pharmacists continues to be the earlier executive order contained in Annexure-1 dated 05.10.2006. That executive order specifically delegated power to the Regional Deputy Director to transfer Class III employees, including Pharmacists, within a division.

The Court then addressed the State’s reliance on Rule 22 of the 2014 Rules. The respondents had claimed that Rule 22 nullified the 2006 order and made the Director-in-Chief the only competent authority for transfer.

The Court rejected this contention. It held that the 2014 Rules, including Rule 22, do not override the executive order of 05.10.2006 in relation to transfer of Pharmacists. The reason was straightforward: the Rules themselves concern appointment, not transfers. Since transfers were outside the field covered by the Rules, the earlier executive delegation on transfer remained intact.

On this reasoning, the Court held that the contention of the respondents that the Director-in-Chief (Health Services), Bihar, is the sole competent authority to transfer Pharmacists from one place to another place was “not tenable”.

Once it was held that the 2006 executive order still governed transfers of Pharmacists within a division, the logical result followed. The Regional Deputy Director, Patna Division, was indeed the competent authority to issue the transfer order dated 26.06.2019 shifting the petitioner from Jagdishpur to Danapur.

If the Regional Deputy Director had such authority, the Director-in-Chief could not later cancel the transfer on the ground that the Regional Deputy Director lacked jurisdiction. The foundation of the cancellation order itself was therefore unsustainable.

Accordingly, the Court found that the petitioner had made out a case. It set aside the impugned order dated 23.01.2020 (Annexure-7) passed by the Director-in-Chief (Health Services), Bihar.

The Court further directed that the transfer order dated 26.06.2019 issued by the Regional Deputy Director should be given effect to in accordance with law at the earliest. In other words, the petitioner’s transfer to Danapur stood restored.

With these findings, the Patna High Court allowed the writ petition.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is significant for government health employees, especially Pharmacists working under the Bihar Health Department.

First, it clarifies that where statutory service rules do not deal with transfers, earlier executive orders delegating transfer power continue to apply. For Pharmacists, the Bihar Pharmacist Cadre Rules, 2014 deal with appointment, not transfers. So, the Health Department’s 2006 resolution on transfer of Class III employees remains effective.

Second, it reaffirms that higher authorities cannot cancel orders of subordinate authorities on a wrong assumption that the subordinate lacked jurisdiction. Where the law clearly gives a power to a particular authority, that power cannot be brushed aside casually.

Third, for affected employees, the case shows that improper cancellation of a valid transfer order can be challenged before the High Court under its writ jurisdiction. The Court can restore the earlier order if it finds that the cancellation lacked legal basis.

Overall, the decision protects employees against arbitrary interference with their postings where the transfer has been made by the authority legally empowered to do so.

Legal Issues and Answers

  • Issue: Who is the competent authority to transfer a Pharmacist within a division in Bihar – the Director-in-Chief (Health Services) or the Regional Deputy Director?
    Answer: The Patna High Court held that, since the Bihar Pharmacist Cadre Rules, 2014 do not deal with transfers, the executive order dated 05.10.2006 continues to govern. Under that order, the Regional Deputy Director is the competent authority to transfer Class III employees like Pharmacists within a division.
  • Issue: Was the Director-in-Chief justified in cancelling the petitioner’s transfer order dated 26.06.2019 on the ground that the Regional Deputy Director had no jurisdiction?
    Answer: No. The Court found that the Regional Deputy Director had lawful power to make the transfer under the 2006 executive order. The cancellation order dated 23.01.2020 was therefore without authority of law and was set aside.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • No earlier judgments or case law are cited or relied upon in the text of this decision.

Case Details

Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 3680 of 2020

Case Title: Ravindra Kumar v. The State of Bihar & Ors.

Citation: 2022(4) PLJR 312

Court: High Court of Judicature at Patna

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice P. B. Bajanthri

Date of Judgment: 25.11.2021

Advocates for Petitioner: Mr. Ranjeet Kumar, Advocate; Mr. Ayush Kumar, Advocate; Mr. Yogesh Kumar, Advocate; Mr. Mohit Srivastava, Advocate

Advocates for Respondents: Mr. S.D. Yadav, AAG-IX; Mr. Nagendra Kumar, AC to AAG-IX

Nature of the Case: Writ petition (service matter regarding cancellation of transfer order of a Pharmacist)

Link to Full Judgment: Patna High Court Judgment in CWJC No. 3680 of 2020

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar, you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News