Case Background
The petitioner is a registered contractor of the Local Area Engineering Organisation (LAEO), Works Division, Munger, under the Government of Bihar.
He was given Agreement No. 44F-2/2012-13 dated 01.02.2013 for construction of a PCC road in Paswan Tola, Rai Tola and Mandal Tola at Hasanpur, Sadar, Munger. The agreed contract value was Rs. 5,50,205/- and the work was to be completed within three months.
According to the contractor, he completed the work within the stipulated time. During execution, he claimed that departmental authorities instructed him to widen the road and do additional work, which allegedly increased the total value of work to Rs. 7,88,144/-. On this basis he claimed an additional sum of Rs. 2,38,000/- as “excess work”.
The Measurement Book (M.B. No. 98 dated 05.02.2013) is said by the petitioner to record both the original and additional work. Despite this, payment was released only for the agreement value. After statutory deductions, he received Rs. 4,29,247/-. The claimed extra amount of Rs. 2,38,000/-, and his security deposit, were not paid.
Feeling aggrieved, the contractor made repeated representations to the department but did not receive the additional amount. He then approached the Patna High Court in CWJC No. 5436 of 2014 seeking direction for payment.
In that earlier writ case, the High Court dismissed his petition by order dated 07.08.2014. The Court held that the dispute involved contested facts and was not suitable for writ jurisdiction. It also specifically observed that there was nothing on record showing any work order from a competent authority for additional work and that mere endorsements on an application could not amount to such authorization. However, liberty was given to the contractor to seek remedy before a civil court or through arbitration as per the agreement.
Acting on this liberty, the contractor filed Reference Case No. 64 of 2015 before the Bihar Public Works Contracts Disputes Arbitration Tribunal, Patna. He sought payment of Rs. 2,38,000/- as alleged admitted dues for excess work, interest on that amount, and refund of his security deposit.
On 16.05.2019, the Tribunal dismissed the reference. It held that his claim had no merit and imposed costs of Rs. 10,000/- upon him. Against this award, the contractor filed the present Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 16240 of 2019 before the Patna High Court.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The core dispute before the Patna High Court was whether the arbitral award dated 16.05.2019, rejecting the contractor’s claim for extra payment, suffered from any legal defect that justified interference in writ jurisdiction.
The contractor’s counsel argued that he had executed additional work as instructed by departmental officials during construction of the PCC road. He relied heavily on entries in Measurement Book No. 98 dated 05.02.2013 and on departmental records, asserting that these showed execution and acceptance of the extra work.
According to him, the claim of Rs. 2,38,000/- was an admitted due arising from enhancement of the work value from Rs. 5,50,205/- to Rs. 7,88,144/-. He complained that only the original agreement value was paid, that too after deductions, while the extra work and security deposit remained unpaid. He contended that the Tribunal failed to appreciate these materials and ignored the admitted nature of his claim.
On this basis, he urged the High Court to set aside the award, direct the State to pay Rs. 2,38,000/- with statutory interest, and order refund of the security deposit.
On the other side, respondent Nos. 2 to 5 (departmental authorities) filed a detailed counter affidavit. Their counsel pointed out that the present writ petition challenged a reasoned award of the Bihar Public Works Contracts Disputes Arbitration Tribunal, which had considered all pleadings and evidence and dismissed the claim with costs.
The State’s position was that the claim for Rs. 2,38,000/- towards alleged excess work was “wholly unfounded”. They asserted that no competent authority had ever issued any direction or authorization for work beyond the original agreement. The contractor, they said, could not produce any work order, written instruction, or approval from a competent authority for extra work.
They further stated that no supplementary agreement or revised estimate had been sanctioned for excess work. In the absence of such authorisation, they argued, no additional amount was payable.
The respondents also highlighted that the contractor had been paid the full contractual amount under the original agreement, after statutory deductions such as Income Tax and Sales Tax. This payment was made on 31.03.2013. Importantly, he accepted this amount as full and final settlement without any protest at that time.
Only more than five months later, by representation dated 12.08.2013, did he raise a claim for alleged excess work. The department argued that this delayed claim, after unconditional acceptance of payment, was rightly rejected by the Tribunal.
They referred back to the earlier High Court order in CWJC No. 5436 of 2014, where the Court had already observed that there was nothing on record to show that any competent authority had issued a work order for additional work, and that endorsements on an application could not be treated as such authorisation.
They also relied on Supreme Court precedents. In particular, they cited New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Genus Power Infrastructure Ltd., (2015) 2 SCC 424, which held that if a contractor accepts payment in full and final settlement without protest, he cannot later raise fresh claims or invoke arbitration unless he proves that the settlement was vitiated in law. Similar principles were drawn from Union of India v. Master Construction Company, (2011) 12 SCC 349, and ONGC Mangalore Petrochemicals Ltd. v. ANS Constructions Ltd., (2018) 3 SCC 373.
After hearing both sides, the Patna High Court first noted that this was the contractor’s second round of litigation. The earlier writ had already examined the same basic issue of alleged excess work under Agreement No. 44F-2/2012-13. The Coordinate Bench had then specifically held that there was no proof of any work order by a competent authority for extra work and that endorsements on an application were insufficient to direct payment.
The present Court observed that when the contractor later went to the Arbitration Tribunal, he relied on essentially the same material—those endorsements on his application. The Tribunal, following the earlier High Court observations, held that these endorsements were not valid authorisation for extra work.
The High Court agreed with this approach. It held that, in the absence of any new or independent material showing a proper work order, revised estimate, or supplementary agreement, the Tribunal could not be blamed for refusing the claim. The contractor had not shown any document establishing that a competent authority had sanctioned the alleged extra work in the manner required under the contract and department rules.
The Court stressed that a contractor cannot demand payment for work allegedly done beyond the contract unless that work is duly authorised. Mere assertions or unilateral claims without such authorisation do not create a binding liability on the State.
The Court then turned to the issue of full and final payment. It noted that the contractor had admittedly accepted the contractual payment without any protest or objection. The finding that payment was in full and final settlement of contractual dues was not disputed. There was also no material to show that he accepted the payment under coercion, duress, or undue influence.
In these circumstances, the Tribunal was, in the Court’s view, correct in relying upon the Supreme Court judgments mentioned earlier. Those decisions clearly state that once a contractor accepts final payment without protest, the contract is ordinarily treated as closed. Any further claim can survive only if the contractor specifically pleads and proves that his consent was not free.
Finally, the Patna High Court examined the scope of its own powers in writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution. It reiterated that the High Court is not an appellate court over arbitral awards. It cannot re-argue the entire case on facts. Interference is limited to situations of patent illegality, perversity, jurisdictional error, or violation of natural justice.
In this case, the Tribunal had considered the pleadings, documents, the earlier High Court order, and relevant legal principles before arriving at its findings. Those findings were based on the record and were neither arbitrary nor perverse. The petitioner had not shown any jurisdictional error or patent illegality in the award.
On this reasoning, the Court concluded that the arbitral award dated 16.05.2019 did not suffer from any defect that would justify interference. The writ petition was held to be without merit and was dismissed. Any interlocutory applications were also disposed of.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is significant for contractors working on government projects in Bihar and elsewhere. It underlines that extra work must be properly authorised through written orders, revised estimates, or supplementary agreements from a competent authority. Informal instructions or verbal directions are not enough.
The decision also shows that once a contractor accepts payment labelled as full and final settlement without protest, it becomes very difficult later to claim additional amounts. Courts and tribunals will look for clear evidence of coercion or illegality before reopening such settlements.
For those thinking of filing writ petitions against arbitral awards, the ruling clarifies that the Patna High Court will interfere only if there is clear illegality or perversity in the award, not merely because another view is possible. This encourages parties to present their full case before the Tribunal itself and not treat the High Court as a second forum on facts.
Legal Issues and Answers
- Issue: Was the contractor entitled to additional payment of Rs. 2,38,000/- for alleged excess work on the road project, and did the Arbitration Tribunal wrongly reject his claim?
Answer: No. The Court held there was no valid authorization by a competent authority for any extra work, no supplementary agreement or revised estimate, and the contractor had already accepted full and final payment without protest. The Tribunal’s rejection of the claim was upheld. - Issue: Did the arbitral award suffer from any patent illegality or jurisdictional error warranting interference in writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution?
Answer: No. The Court found that the Tribunal had considered all relevant materials and applied settled legal principles. Its findings were neither arbitrary nor perverse, and there was no jurisdictional error, so the writ petition was dismissed.
Cases Cited by the Court
- New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Genus Power Infrastructure Ltd., (2015) 2 SCC 424.
- Union of India v. Master Construction Company, (2011) 12 SCC 349.
- ONGC Mangalore Petrochemicals Ltd. v. ANS Constructions Ltd., (2018) 3 SCC 373.
Case Details
Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 16240 of 2019
Case Title: Amit Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar & Ors.
Court: High Court of Judicature at Patna
Coram: Hon’ble Justice Smt. G. Anupama Chakravarthy
Date of Judgment: 03.07.2026
Advocates: Mr. Uma Shankar Sharma for the petitioner; M/s Vinay Kirti Singh, GA 2 and Venkatesh Kirti, AC to GA 2 for the respondents
Respondents: State of Bihar through the Chief Secretary; Principal Secretary, Planning and Development Department; Executive Engineer, LAEO Works Division, Munger; Estimating Officer, LAEO Works Division, Munger; Junior Engineer, LAEO Works Division, Munger
Nature of Case: Writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution challenging an arbitral award of the Bihar Public Works Contracts Disputes Arbitration Tribunal in Reference Case No. 64 of 2015
Link to Judgment: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MTUjMTYyNDAjMjAxOSMxI04=-hTefH6xornY=
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar, you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.


