PDS licence cancellation quashed for violating Rule 28 — Patna High Court, 2026

Shipra Sinha

Reviewed by: Shipra Sinha

License Number: BR/1674/2021

Last Reviewed On: 17-11-2026

Shipra Sinha is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing family law and civil disputes. She represents clients in matrimonial matters, inheritance disputes, property-related family conflicts, and civil litigation before the Patna High Court and subordinate courts. Her practice handles family law proceedings and civil matters for individuals and families across Bihar.

In this case, a ration dealer challenged the suspension and later cancellation of her PDS licence by the authorities in Muzaffarpur. The Patna High Court held that the officials had not followed the Bihar Targeted PDS (Control) Order, 2016. The Court set aside both the suspension and cancellation orders and directed immediate restoration of the shop. The authorities are still free to act again, but only strictly in accordance with law.

Case Background

The petitioner was a licence holder running a Public Distribution System (PDS) shop in Sakra block, Muzaffarpur district.

On 02.11.2024, a joint enquiry was carried out in her shop by the Block Supply Officers of Sakra and Gayghat. Their report alleged eleven different irregularities against her.

On the basis of this enquiry report, the Sub-Divisional Officer, East Muzaffarpur, directed that a First Information Report (FIR) be lodged. The same day, an FIR was registered at Sakra Police Station under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act against the petitioner.

After the FIR, the licensing authority suspended the petitioner’s PDS licence by Memo No. 1244 dated 22.11.2024. This suspension order referred to Rule 28 of the Bihar Targeted PDS (Control) Order, 2016.

A show cause notice was then issued to the petitioner, calling for her reply to the allegations relating to irregularities in the shop. The petitioner submitted her written reply on 24.12.2024, denying the charges and giving her explanation.

Despite this, the Sub-Divisional Magistrate-cum-Licensing Officer, East Muzaffarpur, passed Memo No. 98 dated 29.01.2026 cancelling her licence. According to the petitioner, this was done without properly considering her reply and without following Rule 28.

Meanwhile, in the criminal case arising from the FIR, the petitioner obtained bail from the Patna High Court in Cr. Misc. No. 72698 of 2025 on 08.12.2025.

Aggrieved by the prolonged suspension and eventual cancellation of her licence, she approached the Patna High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution in CWJC No. 10941 of 2026. She sought quashing of both the suspension and cancellation orders, restoration of her licence and shop, and compensation for mental and financial loss.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The Patna High Court, through Hon’ble Mr. Justice Girijish Kumar, heard both sides. The core question was whether the authorities had acted in violation of Rule 28 of the Bihar Targeted PDS (Control) Order, 2016 while suspending and cancelling the licence.

The Court first reproduced Rule 28, which deals with “Actions to be taken against a licensee after a FIR lodged.” Under this rule, if an FIR is lodged under the Essential Commodities Act or any other criminal case and the licence holder is sent to jail or becomes a fugitive, the licensing authority must suspend the licence immediately. Thereafter, after issuing a show cause notice in accordance with the Civil Procedure Code and giving sufficient opportunity of hearing, “a lawful action shall be taken within 180 days, as far as possible.”

The petitioner’s main arguments were:

First, her licence was cancelled only because an FIR had been registered. At no time was she arrested or sent to jail, nor was she declared a fugitive. She later obtained bail from the High Court. Therefore, the basic conditions under Rule 28 for suspension and further action were not fulfilled.

Second, the authorities had not complied with the safeguards built into Rule 28. According to her, before cancellation, they did not properly consider her reply to the show cause notice and did not follow the required procedure. She also pointed out that her licence remained under suspension from 22.11.2024 till the cancellation on 29.01.2026, i.e. for more than one year, even though Rule 28 requires that lawful action be taken within 180 days from suspension.

Third, she relied on earlier Patna High Court judgments in Ranjit Singh v. State of Bihar and Md. Nurshad @ Md. Noorshad Alam v. State of Bihar, where similar actions of cancellation were held illegal under Rule 28 and licences were ordered to be restored.

She also relied on the Division Bench judgment in CWJC No. 21179 of 2021 (order dated 22.02.2022). There, the Court held that mere pendency of a criminal case cannot be a ground for cancelling a PDS licence because the Bihar Targeted PDS (Control) Order, 2016 contains a special provision—Rule 28—for dealing with such situations. The Division Bench also stressed that licences should not remain in “animated suspension” for long, because PDS shops in a locality cannot be left vacant for extended periods.

On the other hand, the State’s counsel did not directly justify the manner in which the licence was suspended and cancelled. Instead, he raised a preliminary objection. He argued that the writ petition was not maintainable as the petitioner had an effective alternative remedy of appeal under Rule 32 of the Control Order, 2016, and should have used that instead of filing a writ in the High Court.

The Court therefore first examined whether the writ petition was maintainable despite the alternative remedy.

Drawing from the Supreme Court decision in Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited v. Rekha & Ors. (2026 INSC 847), which in turn referred to Radha Krishan Industries v. State of H.P., the Court noted the settled principles: the High Court has wide powers under Article 226. Normally, it may refuse writ relief where an effective alternate remedy exists, but there are clear exceptions. A writ can be entertained where (a) fundamental rights are at stake, (b) principles of natural justice are violated, (c) the order is wholly without jurisdiction, or (d) the vires of legislation is challenged.

These principles had been reaffirmed by a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court in T.N. Cements Corporation Ltd. v. Unicon Engineers, which clarified that even with alternative remedies, the writ court can step in particularly when there is violation of natural justice or fundamental rights, or when the order is without jurisdiction.

Applying these principles, the Patna High Court held that the present case fell within the exception. An alternate remedy by itself does not bar the High Court, and given the nature of the alleged violations of Rule 28 and natural justice, it was a fit case to exercise writ jurisdiction. Thus, the preliminary objection of the State was rejected.

Turning to the merits, the Court observed that the petitioner’s licence had been cancelled without appreciating that she had not been sent to jail nor declared a fugitive. In fact, she had secured bail. Despite this, the authority acted as if the mere lodging of an FIR was enough to suspend and cancel the licence.

The Court emphasised that Rule 28 clearly states that suspension is triggered only when the licensee is sent to jail or becomes a fugitive, and even then, a show cause notice and sufficient opportunity of hearing must follow. Only after such process can a lawful action be taken within 180 days.

Here, the Sub-Divisional Officer, East Muzaffarpur, failed to act as per Rule 28. The authorities did not adequately consider the petitioner’s reply. Further, they allowed more than one year to pass after suspension before cancelling the licence, breaching the 180-day outer limit “as far as possible.” The Court noted that mere registration of an FIR does not empower the authorities to either suspend or cancel a PDS licence.

The Court then examined the contents of the show cause notice itself. It found that the notice issued to the petitioner did not mention any proposed action or possible penalty. It merely repeated allegations and formed the basis for suspension and later cancellation.

Because the notice failed to inform the petitioner that cancellation of licence was being contemplated, the Court held that the notice was invalid. Despite this, the Sub-Divisional Officer had suspended the licence purely on the basis of the inspection report of the Block Supply Officer, which was contrary not only to Rule 28 but also Rule 27(ii) of the Control Order, 2016 and to the Full Bench decision in CWJC No. 21202 of 2021.

The Full Bench had clearly held that when a notice is issued under Order 27(ii) of the BTPDS Control Order, it is mandatory to mention that cancellation of licence is proposed. Without that, the notice cannot be treated as a valid opportunity to the licence holder to state their case.

The Court also relied on Supreme Court decisions concerning the content of show cause notices. In Gorkha Security Services v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2014) 9 SCC 105, the Supreme Court held that a valid notice must state both (i) the grounds or material necessitating action and (ii) the particular penalty or action proposed. This is essential to meet the principles of natural justice, and is especially important where harsh consequences like blacklisting are involved.

Similarly, in UMC Technologies Private Limited v. Food Corporation of India (2021) 2 SCC 551, the Supreme Court held that an affected person must be informed of the specific grounds and the proposed action so that they can effectively defend themselves. An order going beyond the scope of the notice or lacking these specifics is impermissible.

Applying these authorities, the Patna High Court found that the show cause notice to the petitioner was defective. It did not tell her that cancellation was being considered and thus did not give her a real chance to defend her licence.

The Court further took support from the Division Bench ruling in CWJC No. 21179 of 2021, reiterating that mere pendency of a criminal case cannot justify cancellation and that the outer 180‑day limit is meant to prevent long, indefinite suspensions. PDS shops must not remain vacant and the process of filling vacancies should be continuous.

In light of all this, the Court concluded that both the suspension order dated 22.11.2024 and the cancellation order contained in Letter No. 98 dated 29.01.2026 were arbitrary, illegal and in complete violation of Rule 28 of the Control Order, 2016, as well as contrary to binding decisions of the High Court and Supreme Court.

Accordingly, the Court quashed and set aside both orders. It directed the concerned respondent authority to restore the petitioner’s PDS licence with immediate effect and to supply all commodities for distribution as per law.

The writ petition was allowed with these directions. The Court clarified that the Sub-Divisional Officer, East Muzaffarpur, would remain free to take appropriate steps in accordance with law, implying that any fresh action must strictly follow the Control Order and principles of natural justice.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is important for PDS dealers across Bihar. It reinforces that authorities cannot suspend or cancel a ration shop licence simply because an FIR has been registered.

The Court has made it clear that Rule 28 of the Bihar Targeted PDS (Control) Order, 2016 is not a formality. It sets clear conditions: the dealer must have been sent to jail or become a fugitive, a proper show cause notice must be served, and action should be concluded within 180 days.

For ration dealers, this means their licence cannot be kept hanging for years under suspension based only on an enquiry report or pending criminal case. For beneficiaries, it helps ensure that PDS shops remain functional and are not left vacant due to arbitrary administrative actions.

The judgment also sends a clear message to officials that notices must clearly state what penalty is being considered. Vague show cause notices will not stand in court.

Legal Issues and Answers


  • Issue: Could the Patna High Court entertain the writ petition even though an appeal remedy existed under Rule 32 of the Control Order, 2016?

    Answer: Yes. Applying Supreme Court decisions, the Court held that availability of an alternate remedy does not bar writ jurisdiction, especially where there is violation of Rule 28 and principles of natural justice.

  • Issue: Was the suspension and cancellation of the petitioner’s PDS licence in accordance with Rule 28 of the Bihar Targeted PDS (Control) Order, 2016?

    Answer: No. The petitioner was neither jailed nor declared a fugitive; the show cause notice lacked any proposed action; and final action was taken after more than 180 days. The Court found the orders arbitrary, illegal and violative of Rule 28.

  • Issue: Was the show cause notice valid when it did not specify that cancellation of licence was proposed?

    Answer: No. In view of the Full Bench ruling in CWJC No. 21202 of 2021 and Supreme Court judgments in Gorkha Security Services and UMC Technologies, such a notice is invalid and does not provide a reasonable opportunity of hearing.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited v. Rekha & Ors., 2026 INSC 847
  • Radha Krishan Industries v. State of H.P.
  • T.N. Cements Corporation Ltd. v. Unicon Engineers, (2025) 4 SCC 1
  • CWJC No. 21179 of 2021, Division Bench of Patna High Court, order dated 22.02.2022
  • CWJC No. 21202 of 2021 and analogous cases, Full Bench of Patna High Court
  • Gorkha Security Services v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Others, (2014) 9 SCC 105
  • UMC Technologies Private Limited v. Food Corporation of India & Another, (2021) 2 SCC 551
  • Ranjit Singh v. State of Bihar & Ors., CWJC No. 8314 of 2020, Patna High Court, judgment dated 04.02.2021 (relied on by petitioner)
  • Md. Nurshad @ Md. Noorshad Alam v. State of Bihar & Ors., CWJC No. 1942 of 2023, Patna High Court, judgment dated 21.08.2023 (relied on by petitioner)

Case Details

Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 10941 of 2026

Case Title: Shabnam Kumari v. State of Bihar & Ors.

Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 116

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Girijish Kumar

Date of Judgment: 10.09.2026

Advocates:

  • For the Petitioner: Mr. Ashok Kumar Karna, Advocate
  • For the Respondents (State): Mr. Manoj Kumar Ambastha, SC-26; Mr. Santosh Kumar Mishra, AC to SC-26; Mr. Divit Vinod, AC to SC-26

Respondent Authorities: State of Bihar through Principal Secretary, Department of Food and Consumer Protection; District Magistrate, Muzaffarpur; Sub-Divisional Officer-cum-Licensing Officer, East Muzaffarpur; Block Supply Officer, Sakra; Block Supply Officer, Gayghat.

Nature of the Case: Writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging suspension and cancellation of PDS licence and seeking restoration and compensation.

Link to Judgment: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MTUjMTA5NDEjMjAyNiMxI04=-AI6OFMLPOWM=

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News