Case Background
The dispute arose from an E-Tender Notice No. 05/SBD/2022-23 dated 18.05.2022 issued by the Bihar Police Building Construction Corporation. The tender was for construction of police station buildings in different districts of Bihar.
The petitioner, a private company, submitted its bid for Group No. 19. Under Clause 8 of the Notice Inviting Tender, the bid validity was fixed for 120 days. Later, by corrigenda dated 23.06.2022 and 28.06.2022, the last date for submission of bids was extended up to 21.07.2022 and the technical bid was to be opened on 22.07.2022. All other conditions of the tender remained unchanged.
According to the petitioner, the original bid validity expired on 17.09.2022. On 12.01.2023, much after this date, the respondent corporation sent an e-mail asking bidders to extend their bid validity up to 31.03.2023, with a clear warning that if they failed to do so, their tenders would not be considered.
The petitioner did not send any consent or declaration extending its bid validity. Despite this, on 13.04.2023 the technical bid for Group No. 19 was opened before the Technical Evaluation Committee. The petitioner’s technical bid was rejected in the evaluation.
During verification of the documents submitted with the bid, one of the experience certificates submitted by the petitioner was reported to be not genuine. Based on this allegation, Hawai Adda P.S. Case No. 96 of 2023 was registered under Sections 467, 468, 471, 420, 120-B and 511 of the Indian Penal Code.
Thereafter, the Chief Engineer of the Corporation passed Memo No. HQ2203 dated 22.06.2023, blacklisting the petitioner firm for an indefinite period under the Bihar Contractors Registration Rules, 2007. This was later modified by Memo No. HQ2288 dated 03.07.2023, fixing the blacklisting period at five years with retrospective effect from 21.07.2022.
The petitioner filed an appeal, which was rejected by the Appellate Authority by Memo No. HQ4601 dated 13.12.2023. In this order, the blacklisting was also extended to all other organisations, corporations, departments and institutions.
The petitioner had earlier approached the High Court in C.W.J.C. No. 18160 of 2024, challenging these orders. That writ petition was withdrawn on 07.05.2025 with liberty to approach another appropriate forum. The petitioner then submitted a representation dated 07.10.2025 before the Additional Chief Secretary, Department of Home, Government of Bihar. Ultimately, the present writ petition was filed challenging the blacklisting orders.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The Patna High Court, speaking through the Acting Chief Justice, focused on a narrow but crucial point: could the authorities legally rely on a bid that had expired and which, by their own communication, “would not be considered under any circumstances” without extension?
The petitioner’s main argument was that it had never agreed to extend its bid validity. The bid validity, as per the tender conditions, expired on 17.09.2022. The e-mail of 12.01.2023 requested extension till 31.03.2023, but the petitioner gave no consent. Therefore, in the petitioner’s view, its bid had ceased to exist for all practical purposes and could not be opened or evaluated on 13.04.2023.
On this basis, the petitioner argued that any allegation regarding the experience certificate, discovered only when the technical bid was opened after expiry of bid validity, could not legally support blacklisting. The petitioner also claimed that no show-cause notice or verification report was served before imposing the penalty, and that the Appellate Authority ignored these grounds.
The respondents opposed the writ petition. They contended that the impugned blacklisting orders were passed after giving due opportunity, on the basis that the petitioner had uploaded a forged experience certificate with its bid. They pointed out that an FIR had been lodged against the petitioner and its directors. According to them, the expiry of bid validity was irrelevant, because the wrong—submission of a forged document—was completed at the time of bid submission within the prescribed period.
The respondents further asserted that a show-cause notice dated 01.06.2023 was sent to the petitioner with all relevant documents, and no reply was received. The Appellate Authority, they said, had passed a reasoned order on 13.12.2023. The corporation claimed that its action was in line with Clause 41 of the NIT and Clause 11(क)(7) of the Bihar Contractor Registration Rules, 2007.
The Court framed a “limited issue”: whether, without the petitioner’s consent to extend bid validity, the respondents were justified in considering and evaluating its bid, and then blacklisting it, especially when their own e-mail had clearly stated that the tender would not be considered if validity was not extended.
To answer this, the Court examined Clause 15.2 of the Standard Bidding Document. This clause allows the employer, in exceptional circumstances and before expiry of the original time limit, to request bidders to extend the bid validity. It specifically states that a bidder may refuse the request without losing bid security, and that a bidder who agrees cannot modify the bid.
The Court noted that this clause makes extension of bid validity a matter of mutual agreement. The employer can only request; the bidder is free to say no. There is no unilateral power to extend bid validity without the bidder’s consent.
The Court then reproduced and examined the exact language of the e-mail dated 12.01.2023 sent by the respondents. In that communication, bidders were requested to extend their bid validity up to 31.03.2023 “so that your tender can be considered.” It also clearly stated that, in case of failure to extend, “your tender will not be considered under any circumstances,” and directed them to submit a declaration or affidavit by 21.01.2023.
The Court held that this language was “unequivocal.” The respondents themselves had made extension of bid validity a condition for consideration of the tender. It was also undisputed that the petitioner did not submit any declaration extending its bid validity. Hence, there was no consensual extension under Clause 15.2.
Once the petitioner refused (or, at least, did not accept) the request to extend, the consequence, as per the respondents’ own e-mail, was that its tender “would not be considered.” Despite this, the respondents later opened and evaluated the petitioner’s technical bid and used the documents submitted with that bid to initiate blacklisting. The Court found such conduct unsustainable.
The respondents tried to justify their action by saying that the alleged misconduct occurred at the time of uploading the forged certificate and that the later expiry of bid validity could not erase that misconduct. The Appellate Authority had also reasoned that the alleged act took place before the expiry of bid validity and that expiry could not wipe out its consequences.
The High Court accepted that submitting a forged or false document in a tender is a serious matter and that the employer can take action where permitted by the rules. However, it emphasised that this was not the real question here. The real question was whether, after promising that the tender would not be considered without extension and after the bidder did not extend, the authority could still treat the bid as valid, evaluate it, and then blacklist the bidder on that basis.
The Court answered this in the negative. It stressed that the reasoning of the Appellate Authority did not deal with the effect of the specific words “will not be considered under any circumstances” used in the 12.01.2023 e-mail. The Court clarified that it was not saying that expiry of bid validity always wipes out all consequences of past acts. Its conclusion was based squarely on the particular representation made by the respondents in this case and the legal effect of that representation.
In short, the authority could not demand extension as a condition to consider the bid and then, despite no extension being given, continue as though the bid validity had been extended. The tendering authority must act consistently with its own terms and representations, especially where the bidder has a recognised right to refuse extension.
The Court then recalled that blacklisting has serious civil consequences. It cited two Supreme Court decisions: Erusian Equipment & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of West Bengal & Anr., (1975) 1 SCC 70, where the Supreme Court stressed the need for fair play and opportunity before blacklisting; and Kulja Industries Ltd. v. Chief General Manager, Western Telecom Project, BSNL & Ors., (2014) 14 SCC 731, which held that blacklisting decisions by State bodies are subject to judicial review on grounds of fairness, reasonableness, rationality and proportionality.
Applying these principles, the Court held that, even if the allegation regarding the experience certificate was serious, the specific manner in which the respondents proceeded—by evaluating a bid they had declared would not be considered without extension—made the blacklisting legally unsound.
The Court also made it clear that it was not deciding whether the disputed experience certificate was actually genuine or forged. That issue is already the subject of the pending criminal case and would be decided there. The Court confined itself to deciding the legality of the administrative action of blacklisting based on an evaluation of a bid that had, by their own terms, expired.
In conclusion, the Court answered the framed issue in favour of the petitioner. It quashed Memo No. HQ2203 dated 22.06.2023, Memo No. HQ2288 dated 03.07.2023, and appellate Memo No. HQ4601 dated 13.12.2023. The writ petition was allowed. The Court expressly clarified that its observations were limited to the blacklisting and would not prejudice the ongoing criminal proceedings about the disputed document.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is important for contractors and suppliers dealing with government tenders in Bihar and elsewhere. It confirms that when an authority clearly tells a bidder that a tender will not be considered without extension of bid validity, it must follow its own word.
Authorities cannot ignore their own conditions and later use an already expired bid to impose heavy penalties like blacklisting. Such actions can be struck down in court. This helps protect contractors from arbitrary decisions and reminds government bodies to act fairly and consistently with their written communications.
The decision also underlines that blacklisting, which can shut a contractor out of government work for years, must be exercised carefully and is always open to judicial review. At the same time, the Court has left room for criminal law to take its own course where forgery is alleged.
Legal Issues and Answers
- Issue: Can a government corporation consider and evaluate a contractor’s bid, and then blacklist the contractor based on that evaluation, when the contractor never agreed to extend bid validity and the corporation had stated that without such extension the tender “will not be considered under any circumstances”?
Answer: No. The Patna High Court held that once the contractor did not consent to extend bid validity, and the authority had itself declared that the tender would not be considered without such extension, the bid could not lawfully be evaluated or used as the basis for blacklisting. - Issue: Does the seriousness of an allegation of a forged document override the authority’s own representation about non-consideration of the bid without extension?
Answer: No. While submission of a forged document is serious, the Court held that the power of blacklisting must be exercised consistently with tender terms and representations. In this case, proceeding on an expired, non-extended bid was legally impermissible, irrespective of the seriousness of the allegation, which remains to be examined in criminal proceedings.
Cases Cited by the Court
- Erusian Equipment & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of West Bengal & Anr., (1975) 1 SCC 70.
- Kulja Industries Ltd. v. Chief General Manager, Western Telecom Project, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. & Ors., (2014) 14 SCC 731.
Case Details
Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 5267 of 2026
Case Title: M/S Universal Agro Corporation Ltd. v. The Bihar Police Building Construction Corporation & Ors.
Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 107
Court: High Court of Judicature at Patna
Coram: Hon’ble the Acting Chief Justice Sudhir Singh and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Kumar Verma
Date of Judgment: 07.09.2026
Advocates for Petitioner: Mr. Kundan Kumar Sinha, Advocate
Advocates for Respondents: Mr. Prasoon Sinha, Advocate; Mr. Aditya Narayan Singh, Advocate; Mr. Kundan Kumar Sinha, Advocate; Mr. Kumar Anjaneya Shanu, Advocate
Respondent Authority: Bihar Police Building Construction Corporation
Nature of the Case: Writ petition challenging orders of blacklisting passed under the Bihar Contractors Registration Rules, 2007 in relation to a public works tender.
Impugned Orders: Memo No. HQ2203 dated 22.06.2023 (blacklisting for indefinite period); Memo No. HQ2288 dated 03.07.2023 (modifying blacklisting to five years from 21.07.2022); Memo No. HQ4601 dated 13.12.2023 (appellate order affirming blacklisting and extending it to other organisations).
Result: Writ petition allowed; all impugned memos quashed; clarification that criminal proceedings in Hawai Adda P.S. Case No. 96 of 2023 are unaffected.
Link to Judgment: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MTUjNTI2NyMyMDI2IzEjTg==-WDg0mF2FBEY=
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



