Delay defeats claim for SBI increments and allowance — Patna High Court, 2026

Sakshi Bhatnagar

Reviewed by: Sakshi Bhatnagar

License Number: BR/2891A/2019

Last Reviewed On: 18-11-2026

Sakshi Bhatanagar is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing criminal law. She represents clients in criminal proceedings before the Patna High Court and subordinate courts, handling bail applications, criminal appeals, NDPS matters, and customs-related cases. Her practice focuses on criminal defense and litigation across multiple forums in Bihar.

The petitioners challenged State Bank of India for not paying old salary increments and godown watchman allowance, and for adjusting an ex-gratia amount. The Patna High Court held that the bank had already passed a speaking order in 2005 and the family approached the Court far too late. The Court refused to reopen the service benefits after about 20 years and treated the ex-gratia adjustment as valid. The writ petition was dismissed and nothing further is payable by the bank.

Case Background

The dispute began with the service of the petitioners’ late father, an employee of State Bank of India (SBI). He worked in different branches, including Barauni Fertilizer Township Branch and offices at Patna. He took voluntary retirement under the SBI VRS scheme with effect from 31.03.2001.

According to the petitioners, during his service and after his retirement, their father did not receive yearly increments from 1975 to 1998 and did not get godown watchman allowance from 14.07.1974 onwards. Despite his representations to the bank, these benefits were not paid.

Faced with non-payment, he filed C.W.J.C. No. 8959 of 2003 before the Patna High Court. He sought payment of yearly increments in his pay scale and the difference in allowance for his work as a godown watchman. On 28.02.2005, a Single Judge disposed of that writ petition and directed respondent no. 2 of SBI to decide his representation by a reasoned order within two months.

Pursuant to this direction, the employee filed a representation. The Assistant General Manager (Personnel and HRD), Local Head Office, Patna, passed a speaking order on 07.05.2005. By this order, two annual increments of Rs. 150 and Rs. 170, with effect from July 1999 and July 2000, were sanctioned. However, the bank rejected his claim for annual increments from 1975 to 1998, when he was posted at Barauni Fertilizer Township and at the Zonal Office, Patna.

While making payment of the sanctioned increments, SBI deducted Rs. 2059, claiming that this was excess ex-gratia earlier paid to him at the time of voluntary retirement. Thus, the bank treated Rs. 2059 as an adjustment.

The employee died on 19.09.2005. His widow (since deceased and referred to in the judgment as the “deceased petitioner”) continued to pursue the matter. She filed a representation on 28.12.2007 and reminders on 17.04.2008, 15.07.2008 and 25.05.2009, but the bank did not take any fresh decision.

She then filed M.J.C. No. 5053 of 2010, alleging contempt of the earlier order dated 28.02.2005 in C.W.J.C. No. 8959 of 2003. On 28.09.2011, the High Court disposed of the contempt petition, giving her liberty to take appropriate remedy as available in law.

After withdrawal of the contempt, she used the Right to Information Act to seek details of sanctioned annual increments from 1974 to 2001 and godown watchman allowance from 14.07.1974. SBI declined, saying the information sought was more than 35 years old and its rules did not allow retention of records older than 35 years.

Eventually, in 2012, the present writ petition, C.W.J.C. No. 21761 of 2012, was filed by the legal heirs of the deceased employee and his deceased widow, challenging the non-payment of increments and allowance and the deduction of Rs. 2059.

Initially, the writ petition only sought directions for payment. Later, by I.A. No. 02 of 2025, the petitioners also asked for quashing of the speaking order dated 07.05.2005. This interlocutory application was allowed on 20.11.2025, so the challenge to the 2005 order became part of the main writ.

What the Court Examined and Decided

Justice Ritesh Kumar of the Patna High Court heard the matter. The Court focused on three main aspects: the delayed challenge to the 2005 speaking order, the claim for watchman allowance and increments, and the adjustment of Rs. 2059.

On behalf of the petitioners, their counsel argued that their late father was legally entitled to annual increments for 1975–1998 and godown watchman allowance from 14.07.1974 to 1998. They said the High Court’s earlier order in C.W.J.C. No. 8959 of 2003 had not been correctly implemented by the bank. According to them, only two increments for 1999 and 2000 were paid, leaving large arrears.

They also attacked the deduction of Rs. 2059 from the payment of these two increments. In their view, the deceased employee had no role in any excess ex-gratia payment and the bank had voluntarily paid ex-gratia after due consideration. Therefore, this recovery was termed “illegal”, and they relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (2015 SCC 334) to argue that such recovery from a retired employee or his family was not permissible.

Further, they challenged SBI’s stand that old service records had been destroyed. They pointed out that in its counter affidavit the bank had quoted specific dates of joining, confirmation, transfers, voluntary retirement application and retirement. The bank also produced a letter dated 03.12.1985 allegedly written by the employee, where he requested transfer from Barauni to Patna and offered to work as a peon and forego watchman allowance. Petitioners argued that without service records such precise information and documents could not have been retrieved and, therefore, the plea of non-availability of records was false.

They maintained that stoppage of increments is a major punishment that can only follow a proper departmental enquiry. The bank did not hold any disciplinary proceeding against their father, and no order of punishment was ever passed. Therefore, increments could not have been lawfully withheld.

The petitioners also argued that the Reserve Bank of India’s preservation rules, cited by SBI to justify destruction of records after eight years, were meant for co-operative banks and did not authorise SBI to destroy an employee’s service book so soon, especially when their mother’s representation dated 11.12.2007 was pending.

Regarding godown watchman allowance, they claimed the bank had admitted that their father served as godown watchman from 14.07.1974 to 03.12.1985 and that allowance was fixed from time to time and payable monthly with salary. Yet, SBI refused to pay the allowance from 14.07.1974 to 1988, despite his continuous duty.

The bank, in reply, relied heavily on the speaking order of 07.05.2005. SBI argued that this order was passed in full compliance with the High Court’s 2005 direction in C.W.J.C. No. 8959 of 2003. According to SBI, the late employee never challenged this order in time. Only after many years, and after the death of both the employee and his widow, did the sons file this writ and add a challenge to the 2005 order through I.A. No. 02 of 2025.

Regarding watchman allowance, SBI said the employee had himself requested transfer to Patna and, in his written application dated 03.12.1985 to the Regional Manager, Region-II, Patna, he clearly stated that he would not claim godown watchman allowance if transferred to a Patna office and would work as a messenger. Based on this request he was transferred from Barauni to Bihta branch as messenger-cum-coolie with effect from 03.12.1986, later to Zonal Office, Patna, and then to Local Head Office, Patna.

SBI further asserted that during his posting at Barauni he frequently remained absent without permission. The bank had contemplated disciplinary action for unauthorised absence, and the employee’s request letter was made in this background. According to SBI, because of his own request, he could not later claim watchman allowance for that period.

On the ex-gratia issue, SBI maintained that Rs. 2059 was not “recovered” in the sense of taking money back from the family, but simply “adjusted” against the additional increments sanctioned later. The bank claimed this amount represented excess ex-gratia wrongly paid at the time of voluntary retirement.

The Court then turned to the core legal question: whether such a stale claim, and such a belated challenge to the 2005 speaking order, could be entertained in writ jurisdiction.

Justice Ritesh Kumar referred to two Supreme Court decisions on delay and laches:

First, State of Himachal Pradesh and Another v. Jasmeet Singh and Another, 2026 SCC Online SC 1648. Paragraphs 12–16 of that decision were quoted to show how the Supreme Court treated claims made more than twelve years after the cause of action as lacking bona fides, and how courts should not allow execution proceedings or later actions to go beyond what was earlier decided.

Second, State of Uttar Pradesh and Others v. Arvind Kumar Srivastava and Others, 2015 (1) SCC 347. The Patna High Court extracted paragraphs 20, 21, 22.2 and 23. In that case, the Supreme Court explained the doctrine of laches and acquiescence, emphasising that people who sleep over their rights, and wake up only when others succeed in similar litigation, are “fence-sitters” and cannot automatically claim similar benefits after long delay.

Drawing from these judgments, the Patna High Court observed that SBI had passed a reasoned order on 07.05.2005. This order remained unchallenged for about 20 years, until 2025, when the sons of the deceased employee, after the death of both parents, finally moved an interlocutory application to assail it.

The Court noted that the employee himself did not challenge the 2005 order in his lifetime. Even the deceased widow did not directly attack the speaking order when she filed representations or the contempt case. Therefore, the Court considered the present challenge as highly belated.

On this basis, Justice Ritesh Kumar held that the interlocutory application challenging the 2005 order was fit to be dismissed due to delay in approaching the Court. Since the entire claim for increments and allowance was tied to upsetting that 2005 order, the writ petition itself could not survive.

On the question of Rs. 2059, the Court rejected the petitioners’ reliance on Rafiq Masih. It recorded the bank’s position that this was not a case of recovery from salary or pension after many years but a case of adjustment of excess ex-gratia at the time of processing the increments. In the Court’s “considered opinion”, this amounted to adjustment, not recovery, and therefore the Rafiq Masih principle did not apply.

In conclusion, the Court held that there was no merit in the writ petition. It dismissed the writ as well as all pending applications.

Why This Judgment Matters

This decision sends a clear message to bank employees, ex-employees and their families: if they feel that salary, allowances or retirement benefits have been wrongly denied, they must challenge such decisions promptly.

Here, even though the family believed that increments and a watchman allowance were wrongly withheld for many years, the key bank order was passed in 2005. Because it was left unchallenged for about two decades, the Patna High Court refused to reopen the issue.

The judgment shows that courts will not normally interfere with very old service matters, particularly when the concerned employee had opportunities earlier but chose not to contest. The longer the delay, the weaker the case becomes, regardless of the merits.

It also clarifies that where a bank adjusts an excess amount while finalising benefits, that adjustment may not be treated as “recovery” attracting the protection laid down in cases like Rafiq Masih. Beneficiaries who want to challenge such adjustments must do so in time and with clear evidence.

Legal Issues and Answers


  • Issue: Can the heirs of a deceased bank employee, after nearly 20 years, challenge a 2005 speaking order denying past increments and godown watchman allowance?

    Answer: No. The Patna High Court held that the challenge was hopelessly delayed and barred by the principles of delay and laches, as explained by the Supreme Court.

  • Issue: Was the adjustment of Rs. 2059, treated by the bank as excess ex-gratia, an illegal “recovery” barred by the Supreme Court’s decision in Rafiq Masih?

    Answer: No. The Court held that this was an adjustment of excess payment at the time of voluntary retirement benefits, not a later recovery from salary or pension, so the Rafiq Masih ruling did not apply.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. Jasmeet Singh & Anr., 2026 SCC Online SC 1648.
  • State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. v. Arvind Kumar Srivastava & Ors., 2015 (1) SCC 347.
  • The petitioners also relied on State of Punjab & Ors. v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) & Ors., 2015 SCC 334, but the Court held it inapplicable.

Case Details

Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 21761 of 2012

Case Title: Sri Ashok Kumar Pandey & Ors. v. State Bank of India & Ors.

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ritesh Kumar

Date of Judgment: 31.08.2026

Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 203

Advocates:

  • For the petitioners: Mr. Ram Janam Prasad, Advocate
  • For the State Bank of India: Mr. Kaushalesh Choudhary, Advocate

Nature of the Case: Writ petition under civil writ jurisdiction seeking directions for payment of annual increments, godown watchman allowance and refund of adjusted ex-gratia, along with challenge to a 2005 speaking order of SBI.

Link to Judgment: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/vieworder/MTUjMjE3NjEjMjAxMiMxOCNO-5qtRxGPaAQ0=


If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News