Husband’s divorce appeal rejected for lack of proof of cruelty and desertion — Patna High Court, 2026

Abhishek Kumar

Reviewed by: Abhishek Kumar

License Number: BR/1810/2019

Last Reviewed On: 17-11-2026

Abhishek Kumar is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in GST and Income Tax matters. He represents clients before the Patna High Court and other jurisdictions in tax disputes and regulatory compliance issues. His practice handles tax assessment proceedings, GST-related matters, and commercial disputes for businesses and individuals across Bihar and surrounding regions.

Husband challenged a Family Court decision refusing divorce on grounds of cruelty, adultery and desertion. Patna High Court found no error in the Family Court’s detailed appreciation of evidence. The appeal was dismissed at the preliminary stage itself. The marriage and earlier decree of no divorce continue as they are.

Case Background

This case arose from a matrimonial dispute between a husband and wife married on 09.03.2015 at Purnea according to Hindu rites and customs.

A male child was born from the marriage on 09.02.2016.

The husband filed Matrimonial Case No. 64 of 2017 before the Principal Judge, Family Court, Purnea. He sought a decree of divorce under Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, alleging that the wife had treated him and his parents with cruelty, had committed adultery, and had deserted the matrimonial home.

The wife denied these allegations. She stated that she had been subjected to dowry-related cruelty. She consistently maintained that she was ready to resume matrimonial life with her husband, provided she was kept safely and with dignity.

After recording evidence from both sides, the Family Court, by judgment and decree dated 08.09.2025, dismissed the husband’s divorce petition. The Court held that the allegations of cruelty, adultery and desertion were not proved.

The husband then filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 896 of 2025 before the Patna High Court under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984 challenging this dismissal.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The Patna High Court heard the appeal at the preliminary stage contemplated by Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. At this stage, the Court has to see whether there is any sufficient ground to admit the appeal for fuller hearing.

The Court referred to the Supreme Court’s decision in Mahender Pal Chabra and another v. Subhash Aggrawal, Civil Appeal No. 1426 of 2024, decided on 30.01.2024. The Supreme Court has clarified that an appeal can be dismissed without issuing notice if it does not merit admission. However, the High Court must apply its mind to the grounds raised and cannot pass a cryptic, non-speaking order.

Keeping this guidance in mind, the Patna High Court closely examined the Family Court’s findings and the main grounds raised by the husband.

Allegations about events before the marriage

The husband had alleged that the parties met through Facebook. According to him, the wife came to Patna in May 2014 for an interview, stayed in his room, and then compelled him to marry her by threats.

The Family Court, and then the High Court, focused on his cross-examination. He admitted that they had physical relations at the first meeting. He also admitted that the wife’s father sold his residential house and transferred about Rs. 11 lakh to the husband’s father. The husband’s father (PW-2) admitted that the marriage was a love marriage and that about Rs. 12 lakh was transferred after sale of the house.

Both witnesses admitted that the husband’s parents were not satisfied with the marriage and that the marriage took place in circumstances of pressure and fear. These admissions, in the view of the Family Court, weakened the attempt to show the wife’s conduct before marriage as cruelty. The High Court agreed that these were factual findings based on evidence and revealed no perversity.

Conduct during matrimonial life

The husband alleged that after marriage the wife frequently went to her parental home, wanted him to oust his parents, abused his family members and behaved cruelly.

However, in his own evidence as PW-4, the husband admitted important facts. He stated that the wife was working as Principal of Sanskar Kanya Vidyalaya and was pursuing an MBA with his consent. He also admitted that his parents had admitted the wife to the nursing home where the child was born.

These facts did not support his allegation that she had left the matrimonial home two months before delivery and refused to return unless his parents left. The Family Court found the cruelty story inconsistent with his own admissions. The High Court saw no reason to interfere.

Reliability of witnesses supporting the husband

PW-1 Ramanand Yadav’s testimony was found unreliable. He himself said he worked as driver of the husband’s father from 2011 to 2014, whereas the marriage took place in March 2015. Thus, he was not in the matrimonial home during the relevant period. He admitted having no personal knowledge of the relationship between the parties and that he was deposing at the instance of the husband’s father.

He also introduced new allegations, like a demand to transfer the house and an attempt to kill a deceased brother’s son, which had not been pleaded in the divorce petition. The Family Court therefore gave little weight to his evidence. The High Court accepted this assessment.

PW-2, the husband’s father, admitted that the wife lived properly in the matrimonial home for about sixteen months after marriage, i.e., till about July 2016. This again went against the picture of continuous cruelty. He also did not support, in the same manner, the allegation that the wife called him “lame”. Thus, the Family Court held that regular abusive behaviour towards the in-laws was not proved.

Physical assault allegation

The husband referred to an incident in October 2016, alleging that the wife threw water on him, pressed his neck and hit him with her leg.

The Family Court noticed that this incident was not clearly pleaded in the divorce petition as a repeated pattern of cruelty. It appeared as a single quarrel. The wife denied the incident.

The Court examined the wider context: disputes regarding the wife’s parents, her demand for separate accommodation, tensions after the death of the husband’s elder brother Amit on 02.08.2016 and disputes over LIC amount. Considering all this, the Family Court concluded that even if such a single incident occurred, it did not amount to matrimonial cruelty. The High Court found nothing perverse in this view.

Documentary evidence

The husband produced several documents relating to his parents’ health, his gastric problem, the father’s disability, the elder brother’s death, wife’s education and professional background, photographs, and a Rs. 20,000 credit in the wife’s account.

The Family Court held that none of these documents showed that any medical problem was caused by the wife’s conduct, or that they proved cruelty. The Patna High Court agreed that the documents did not assist the husband’s case.

Criminal cases and allegation of false implication

A major plank of the husband’s case was that the wife had falsely implicated him and his parents in criminal cases.

Regarding Mahila P.S. Case No. 67 of 2016, the husband relied on an attendance sheet and a computer-generated financial transaction to claim that he was on duty on 03.12.2016 and could not have committed the alleged acts.

The Family Court found these documents were not properly proved. No competent bank or official witness produced the original register. Therefore, their authenticity could not be accepted.

More importantly, the police investigation ended in charge-sheet No. 13 of 2017 for offences under Sections 341, 342, 448, 323, 498A and 504/34 IPC and Sections 3/4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act. The SDJM, Purnea took cognizance on 15.05.2017. The injury report showed swelling and tenderness caused by a hard and blunt substance.

In such circumstances, the Family Court held that, without conclusive proof, the criminal case could not be treated as false or fabricated simply because the husband said so. Before the High Court also, there was no material to show that cognizance had been quashed or that the allegations were held to be false. The High Court therefore accepted the Family Court’s reasoning.

The husband also relied on findings from a maintenance case, but the Family Court held that any contradictions mainly concerned the husband’s income, not the core allegations of assault or dowry-related cruelty. Similarly, an informatory petition filed by the husband’s father on 20.09.2016, claiming fear of false implication, did not prove that the later criminal case was false.

In K. Hat Sahayak P.S. Case No. 289 of 2017, charge-sheet was submitted under Sections 323 and 504 IPC and cognizance was taken on 15.10.2018. Proceedings under Section 107 CrPC were started against both sides. The Family Court and High Court both held that mere institution or pendency of criminal cases does not automatically prove that the allegations are false or that they amount to cruelty.

Newspaper publication allegation

The husband claimed that a news item in Dainik Jagran caused cruelty. Exhibit-32 showed a report about directions by the DIG to police officers in relation to an FIR.

The Family Court found no evidence that the wife had herself circulated this news item. Therefore, a reporter’s story could not be treated as an act of cruelty by the wife without proof of her role. The High Court found this reasoning sound.

Allegation of adultery

The husband accused the wife of adultery. Under Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, this means voluntary sexual intercourse with someone other than the spouse after marriage.

Under the relevant Family Court Rules, such a charge must contain particulars like the identity of the alleged partner, date, place and details. The petition contained no such particulars. The husband did not identify any person or specific incident.

In evidence, PW-4 (husband) did not give details of any particular act of adultery. PW-1 merely said the wife went wherever she wanted and wandered with someone, though he had no personal knowledge after leaving employment in 2014. PW-2 said she remained outside the house for the whole day when the husband was on duty, which was only an inference. PW-3 said she used to go out on scooty on one pretext or another.

On the other hand, the evidence of the husband and his parents themselves showed that the wife was working as Principal in Sanskar Girls School beside their house. The Family Court branded the adultery allegation as baseless and unsupported. It also noted that, despite making such a grave allegation affecting her character, the husband kept silent about adultery in his examination-in-chief.

The Court applied the principle that allegations of illicit relationship cannot be made recklessly or on suspicion. The High Court fully agreed with this conclusion.

Desertion not proved and statutory period not met

Desertion under Section 13(1)(ib) requires that one spouse abandons the other for a continuous period of at least two years immediately before filing the divorce case, and with an intention to end cohabitation without reasonable cause.

The husband’s own case was that the wife finally left the matrimonial home on 04.12.2016. The divorce petition was filed on 19.04.2017. Thus, even on his version, the mandatory two-year period had not passed. The petition itself admitted that they last resided together on 03.12.2016 at Purnea.

Further, the wife’s stand was that she left because of cruelty and dowry-related conduct, and that she was willing to return to the matrimonial home. The existence of pending criminal and maintenance proceedings, in which she and the child obtained relief, was also part of the surrounding circumstances.

On this material, the Family Court held that the ground of desertion was not made out. The Patna High Court held that this finding required no interference.

Overall assessment of cruelty and later conduct

The Family Court looked at the entire chronology. The husband filed for divorce within a few months of the wife leaving the matrimonial home. He did not file any case for restitution of conjugal rights.

At the same time, he levelled serious charges including adultery but failed to prove them. The wife, however, repeatedly expressed readiness to return to matrimonial life, if kept safely and with dignity.

The Patna High Court agreed that, seen as a whole, the husband had not proved any matrimonial offence justifying dissolution of marriage on grounds of cruelty or desertion.

Plea of irretrievable breakdown and mediation efforts

The husband relied on the concept of irretrievable breakdown of marriage, citing cases such as K. Srinivas Rao v. D.A. Deepa.

The High Court noted that irretrievable breakdown is not itself a statutory ground under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act for a Family Court to grant divorce. The Family Court had already found, on facts, that the parties had lived together after marriage, a child was born, and the wife was still willing to resume matrimonial life. On these facts, the cited case law was distinguishable.

The High Court also recorded the later mediation steps in this appeal. On 29.01.2026, the case was sent to the Patna High Court Mediation Centre. Initially, a report suggested non-appearance of the wife, but on checking, it appeared that no notice had been sent to her at Kolkata. The matter was therefore remitted for fresh mediation and notice.

The wife then communicated that she and the minor child were staying in Kolkata and that she could not afford the travel and stay at Patna. She said she would try to participate if the husband bore the expenses and that video conferencing could also be considered.

On 09.07.2026, the Court directed the husband to deposit a draft of Rs. 15,000 in favour of the wife before the “Special Mediation Centre for the Nation 2.0” to cover such expenses. On 31.08.2026, his counsel stated that he had not deposited the money and was not willing to do so.

The High Court clarified that this conduct was not treated as an independent matrimonial offence. It was noticed only to show that the record did not support any claim that the wife had refused to join mediation.

Final conclusion of the Patna High Court

After considering all aspects, the High Court held that the Family Court had carefully examined each allegation and the evidence. It had considered admissions by the husband and his father, the weak nature of PW-1’s evidence, the stage and nature of the criminal cases, the newspaper item, and the legal requirements for adultery and desertion.

The High Court found no case of ignored material evidence, wrong legal test, or an impossible conclusion on the record. Therefore, the appeal did not even raise a prima facie case for interference.

Using its limited power under Order XLI Rule 11 CPC, the Patna High Court dismissed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 896 of 2025 at the threshold and affirmed the Family Court’s judgment and decree dated 08.09.2025. No costs were awarded, and the Registry was directed to communicate the order to the wife within a week.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is important for husbands or wives thinking of filing for divorce on grounds like cruelty, adultery or desertion.

The Patna High Court shows that serious allegations must be backed by clear pleadings and strong evidence. Suspicion, general statements and unproven documents are not enough.

The Court also clarifies that starting criminal or maintenance cases does not automatically amount to cruelty, especially when police have filed charge-sheets and courts have taken cognizance.

The decision further reminds litigants that desertion has a fixed time requirement of two years. Filing for divorce before this period is over will fail on that ground.

Finally, the judgment underlines that if one spouse is ready to continue the marriage and the other rushes to seek divorce without proving any matrimonial offence, the Court will not grant divorce merely on the basis of “irretrievable breakdown”.

Legal Issues and Answers


  • Issue: Did the husband prove that the wife treated him and his parents with cruelty, including by filing false criminal cases and circulating defamatory news?

    Answer: No. The Family Court found, and the Patna High Court agreed, that the allegations were either unsupported, inconsistent with the husband’s own admissions, or not conclusively established as false.

  • Issue: Did the husband establish that the wife committed adultery after marriage?

    Answer: No. The petition lacked necessary particulars, and the evidence did not show any specific act of sexual intercourse with another person. The allegation was held to be baseless.

  • Issue: Was the ground of desertion under Section 13(1)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act made out?

    Answer: No. On the husband’s own case, the wife left on 04.12.2016 and the petition was filed on 19.04.2017, so the statutory two-year period was not satisfied. The wife’s willingness to resume matrimonial life also negated desertion.

  • Issue: Could the marriage be dissolved on the ground of irretrievable breakdown alone?

    Answer: No. Irretrievable breakdown is not an independent statutory ground under Section 13, and on the facts, the wife continued to express readiness to live with the husband.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • The Patna High Court relied on Mahender Pal Chabra and another v. Subhash Aggrawal, Civil Appeal No. 1426 of 2024, decided on 30.01.2024, regarding the scope of dismissal of appeals under Order XLI Rule 11 CPC.
  • The husband had cited decisions including K. Srinivas Rao v. D.A. Deepa for irretrievable breakdown, but the Family Court and High Court distinguished these on facts.

Case Details

Case Number: Miscellaneous Appeal No. 896 of 2025

Case Title: Sandeep Sinha @ Sandip Sinha v. Deepika Verma

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar Singh and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ansul

Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 142

Date of Patna High Court Judgment: 15.09.2026

Impugned Judgment: Judgment and decree dated 08.09.2025 of the Principal Judge, Family Court, Purnea in Matrimonial Case No. 64 of 2017

Advocates: Mr. Anjani Kumar Jha, Advocate for the appellant-husband; name of counsel for respondent-wife not recorded in the judgment.

Nature of Case: Miscellaneous Appeal under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984 against dismissal of a divorce petition under Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

Court: High Court of Judicature at Patna

Link to Judgment: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MiM4OTYjMjAyNSMxI04=-OQ7ggWvLxCw=

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News