Case Background
The petitioner was a government servant working as a Drug Inspector on deputation under the Superintendent, Patna Medical College and Hospital, Patna. Allegations were made that he had committed illegalities and irregularities in the purchase of medicines, chemicals, reagents, machines and equipment for the financial years 2008-09 and 2009-10.
On these allegations, Vigilance Case No. 061 of 2013 was registered for offences punishable under Sections 406, 409, 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, read with Section 13(1)(D) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The Government of Bihar granted sanction for his criminal prosecution on 22.05.2014 on the request of the Vigilance Investigation Bureau.
Separately from the criminal case, a departmental proceeding was started against him. This was done by Resolution No. 1104(15) dated 07.10.2016 of the Health Department, Government of Bihar, under Rule 17 of the Bihar Government Servants (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 2005, commonly called the BGS(CCA) Rules.
The Enquiring Authority appointed in the departmental proceeding submitted his report on 14.02.2020, holding that the charges framed against the petitioner were proved. A copy of this enquiry report was sent to the petitioner through departmental Memo No. 408(15) dated 27.03.2020, asking him to file his reply within 15 days.
Before any final order could be passed in the disciplinary proceeding, the petitioner moved the Patna High Court by filing this writ application on 08.12.2020. He asked for more time to reply to the enquiry report after the end of the COVID-19 lockdown and also requested that a complete copy of the enquiry report be supplied, as his copy did not contain pages 7 to 13.
While the writ case was still pending, the Health Department issued Resolution No. 516(15) dated 26.03.2021, imposing the punishment of dismissal from service. The petitioner then sought and obtained permission to amend the writ petition through I.A. No. 01 of 2021 to directly challenge this dismissal resolution as well.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The Patna High Court, presided over by Hon’ble Mr. Justice Chakradhari Sharan Singh, heard the matter on 08.12.2021. The Court heard arguments from the petitioner’s counsel and from the learned AAG-9 appearing for the State of Bihar.
The main grievance of the petitioner was simple. He said that the enquiry report provided to him was not complete because pages 7 to 13 were missing. Without these pages, he could not properly understand or respond to the findings of the Enquiring Authority. He also pointed out that the COVID-19 lockdown had made it difficult to prepare and submit an effective reply within the original time granted.
The State of Bihar filed a counter affidavit in March 2021. It did not directly deny the specific claim that the copy of the enquiry report supplied to the petitioner was incomplete. Instead, it stated that since the petitioner did not submit his representation on the enquiry report, the Disciplinary Authority had no option but to proceed further. After obtaining the necessary concurrence of the Bihar Public Service Commission (BPSC), the department decided to impose the major punishment of dismissal from service.
A supplementary counter affidavit was also filed on behalf of the State. In that document, the State asserted that due procedure was followed and that major punishment of dismissal from service under Rule 14(xi) of the BGS(CCA) Rules had been imposed on the petitioner.
The Court noted that there was a clear and specific plea in the writ petition that the enquiry report supplied to the petitioner was incomplete. Importantly, there was no specific denial of this plea in either the counter affidavit or the supplementary counter affidavit. Because of this, the Court took the issue very seriously.
On 02.11.2021, the Court passed an order calling upon the State Drug Controller to appear personally. He was asked to clarify whether the full report of the Enquiring Authority had been sent to the petitioner through email on 27.03.2020, especially in view of the petitioner’s claim that pages 7 to 13 were missing.
In response to this order, the State Drug Controller, Bihar, Mr. Ravindra Kumar, appeared before the Court on 03.11.2021 with the original records of the departmental proceeding. He made a crucial admission before the Court: pages 7 to 13 of the enquiry report were not sent to the petitioner when the report was emailed to him for his comments.
This admission settled the factual question. There was no longer any dispute that the petitioner had received only a truncated enquiry report. The Court then turned to the legal consequence of this failure.
The Court observed that when an employee is facing a departmental proceeding, he must be given a fair opportunity to defend himself. For this, he must receive a complete copy of the enquiry report that records the findings against him. Only then can he file an effective representation before the Disciplinary Authority.
The Court held that any decision based on an enquiry report, where the delinquent employee was not given the complete report, cannot be sustained. In this case, the disciplinary authority had passed the dismissal order dated 26.03.2021 based on an enquiry report which, in its complete form, was never shared with the petitioner.
The Court then examined Rule 18(3) of the BGS(CCA) Rules. This rule makes it mandatory for the Disciplinary Authority to forward a copy of the enquiry report to the government servant facing the proceedings. The Court found that sending only part of the report was a clear violation of this rule. It was also a breach of basic principles of natural justice, which require that a person must know the case against him and be given a fair chance to answer it.
The Court emphasised that supplying a truncated copy of the enquiry report amounts to non-compliance of Rule 18(3). Because of this non-compliance, the punishment order based on such a defective process could not stand in law.
Consequently, the Court quashed the resolution dated 26.03.2021 by which the petitioner had been dismissed from service. The Court directed that, as a result of this quashing, the petitioner must be reinstated forthwith.
However, the Court did not stop the department from continuing with the disciplinary process. It gave clear directions to ensure that the proceeding would now run in a lawful manner. The Disciplinary Authority was directed to supply a complete copy of the enquiry report to the petitioner within one month from the date of the judgment. After receiving the complete report, the petitioner was to be given 15 days’ time to submit his written representation, as required by Rule 18(3) of the BGS(CCA) Rules.
The Court further directed that, after receiving and considering the petitioner’s representation on the report of the Enquiring Authority, the Disciplinary Authority must proceed in accordance with law. This means the department can still take a final decision, but only after fully complying with the procedural safeguards and giving the petitioner a proper chance to be heard.
Finally, the Court allowed the writ application with these observations and directions, and ordered that the original records produced by the State Drug Controller be returned to the learned AAG-9.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment of the Patna High Court is important for all government employees facing departmental enquiries in Bihar. It clearly holds that before any major punishment like dismissal is imposed, the employee must receive a full copy of the enquiry report.
If pages are missing or the report is incomplete, any punishment based on such a report can be struck down as a violation of natural justice and Rule 18(3) of the BGS(CCA) Rules. The Court has treated this requirement as mandatory, not optional.
The case also shows that even during difficult times like the COVID-19 lockdown, basic procedural rights of employees cannot be ignored. Authorities must still ensure that enquiry reports and other crucial documents are properly served.
For employees, this judgment gives a clear ground for challenge where they have been punished without receiving the entire enquiry report. For departments, it is a reminder to strictly follow the rules, provide complete documents, and give a reasonable opportunity for representation before taking a final decision.
Legal Issues and Answers
- Issue: Can a government servant be dismissed from service on the basis of an enquiry report that was not fully supplied to him before punishment?
Answer: No. The Patna High Court held that dismissal based on an enquiry report, where the complete report was not supplied to the delinquent employee, is unsustainable as it violates principles of natural justice and Rule 18(3) of the BGS(CCA) Rules. - Issue: What is the effect of not complying with Rule 18(3) of the BGS(CCA) Rules regarding supply of enquiry report?
Answer: Non-compliance with Rule 18(3), such as supplying only a truncated copy of the enquiry report, vitiates the disciplinary order. The punishment order is liable to be quashed, and the employee must be reinstated, though the disciplinary authority may proceed afresh after proper compliance.
Cases Cited by the Court
- The judgment text does not mention or rely upon any decided cases by name. No specific precedents are cited.
Case Details
Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 9135 of 2020
Case Title: Ashok Kumar Yadav v. The State of Bihar & Ors.
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Chakradhari Sharan Singh
Citation: 2022 (4) PLJR 139
Advocates:
For the petitioner: Mr. Shekhar Singh, Advocate
For the respondents (State of Bihar): Mr. S.D. Yadav, AAG-9
Nature of the case: Writ petition (civil) challenging disciplinary proceedings and dismissal order in service matter
Link to judgment: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MTUjOTEzNSMyMDIwIzEjTg==-J–am1–Z8PAzDb7Y=
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar, you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



