Habeas corpus plea by foreign refugee dismissed — Patna High Court, 2021

Sakshi Bhatnagar

Reviewed by: Sakshi Bhatnagar

License Number: BR/2891A/2019

Last Reviewed On: 20-08-2026

Sakshi Bhatanagar is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing criminal law. She represents clients in criminal proceedings before the Patna High Court and subordinate courts, handling bail applications, criminal appeals, NDPS matters, and customs-related cases. Her practice focuses on criminal defense and litigation across multiple forums in Bihar.

In this case, a foreign national with a UNHCR refugee card challenged his custody and the criminal case against him. The Patna High Court held that his detention was under valid court orders and refused to release him through habeas corpus. The Court also declined to quash the FIR. His criminal trial before the Magistrate will continue.

Case Background

The petitioner is a citizen of the Islamic Republic of Iran. He was staying in India on the basis of a refugee certificate issued by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), New Delhi.

On 28.12.2019 at about 10:00 PM, he was intercepted by immigration authorities at Raxaul while he was going to Nepal via Raxaul. A written information was then given by an immigration officer, posted as AFRRO at the Integrated Check Post, Raxaul, to the Station House Officer of Raxaul Police Station in the district of East Champaran.

In that written report, the informant alleged that the petitioner was living in India illegally and that he had come to Raxaul from Bodh Gaya using the Indo-Nepal bus service.

On the basis of this report, Raxaul P.S. Case No. 478 of 2019 was registered on 29.12.2019 for offences under Section 447 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 14(B) of the Foreigners Act, 1946. The petitioner was arrested, produced before the jurisdictional Magistrate and remanded to judicial custody. Since then he has remained in custody in Central Jail, Motihari.

In 2021, he approached the Patna High Court by filing Criminal Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 606 of 2021. He filed this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking habeas corpus and other reliefs.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The petitioner put forward three main prayers in his writ application.

First, he asked for a writ of habeas corpus or other suitable direction for his immediate release from Central Jail, Motihari into the custody of UNHCR, New Delhi. He argued that he was a UNHCR refugee certificate holder since 2018 and therefore should not be kept in jail.

Second, he sought a writ in the nature of certiorari to quash Raxaul P.S. Case No. 478 of 2019. This FIR dated 29.12.2019 had been registered for the offences under Section 447 IPC and Section 14(B) of the Foreigners Act, 1946. According to him, because he had a refugee certificate issued by UNHCR, no such criminal case could be made out against him.

Third, he sought any other appropriate relief that the Court might deem fit.

To support these prayers, learned counsel for the petitioner argued that he was staying in India lawfully. It was submitted that he had a valid passport of the Islamic Republic of Iran, which was valid up to 22.06.2023. It was also stated that he had entered India on the strength of a valid visa.

The petitioner claimed that the allegation of illegal stay made by the informant was false and misleading. He further asserted that Section 14(B) of the Foreigners Act, 1946 was not applicable to him.

Importantly, his counsel told the Court that at the time of registration of the FIR, he was in possession of a valid refugee certificate from UNHCR, New Delhi. This certificate, according to him, was valid up to 13.06.2020. He claimed that he had produced this document before the immigration officer who gave the written report, but that officer allegedly concealed this fact and proceeded to take him into custody.

On this basis, the petitioner attacked his continued detention. He contended that his custody in Central Jail, Motihari, pursuant to the remand orders passed by the jurisdictional Magistrate since 29.12.2019, was wholly illegal and without jurisdiction. He therefore insisted that a writ of habeas corpus was maintainable and should be granted.

On behalf of the Union of India, the learned Additional Solicitor General of India, assisted by counsel, opposed the writ petition. He submitted that no case for issuing a writ of habeas corpus was made out.

The Union’s counsel informed the Court that the investigation in Raxaul P.S. Case No. 478 of 2019 had already been completed. The police had submitted the charge-sheet and the jurisdictional Magistrate had taken cognizance of the offences. The case was now pending trial in the Magistrate’s court.

It was further argued that if the petitioner was aggrieved by the order taking cognizance, he ought to have challenged that specific order before the appropriate forum. At this stage, it could not be said that his detention was without jurisdiction, because he was in custody by virtue of valid judicial orders.

The Union’s counsel pointed out that the Supreme Court has repeatedly held that a writ of habeas corpus is not maintainable where a person is in custody pursuant to orders passed by a court of competent jurisdiction. He also relied on a Full Bench judgment of the Patna High Court in Shikha Kumari v. State of Bihar through Principal Secretary, Home (Police) Deptt. & Ors., reported in 2020 (2) PLJR 15, which had clearly laid down this principle.

The learned counsel for the State of Bihar supported these submissions.

The Division Bench, after hearing both sides and perusing the record, first examined the nature of the criminal case against the petitioner. The Court observed that the allegations in the FIR did disclose a cognizable offence. During investigation, the police had found these allegations to be true.

Accordingly, a final report (charge-sheet) under Section 173(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure had been submitted before the Magistrate. On perusal of this police report, the Magistrate had taken cognizance of the offences alleged. Therefore, the matter was already at the stage of trial before the Magistrate.

In this situation, the High Court held that in a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, it could not examine the petitioner’s defence to set aside the FIR or to hold that his detention was illegal. Those issues had to be dealt with in the criminal court process.

To support this conclusion, the Court relied heavily on previous judgments.

First, it referred to Saurabh Kumar vs. Jailor, Koneila Jail & Anr., (2014) 13 SCC 436. In that case, the Supreme Court had dealt with a person who was in judicial custody under orders of a Judicial Magistrate and had filed a writ of habeas corpus directly in the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court held that since he was an accused facing prosecution and was in custody pursuant to a valid remand order, a writ of habeas corpus was “totally misplaced”. The proper remedy was to seek bail before the competent court, not habeas corpus.

The Patna High Court quoted the key passage where the Supreme Court said that such custody cannot be termed “unlawful” and that habeas corpus is not a substitute for bail proceedings.

Second, the Court discussed State of Maharashtra & Ors. vs. Tasneem Rizwan Siddiquee, (2018) 9 SCC 745. In that case, the Supreme Court again considered whether a writ of habeas corpus could be maintained in respect of a person in police custody pursuant to a remand order. Referring to Saurabh Kumar and another case, Manubhai Ratilal Patel vs. State of Gujarat & Ors., (2013) 1 SCC 314, the Supreme Court held that where a person is in custody under a subsisting remand order of the Magistrate, there is no “continued illegal detention” and habeas corpus does not lie unless the remand order itself is challenged.

Third, the High Court relied on Serious Fraud Investigation Office vs. Rahul Modi & Anr., (2019) 5 SCC 266. In that case, the Supreme Court set aside a Delhi High Court order which had released accused persons on a habeas corpus petition even though they were in judicial custody under remand orders of competent courts. The Supreme Court held that directing remand is a judicial function. The legality of such remand orders cannot be examined in a habeas corpus petition; they must be challenged through proper appellate or revisional proceedings.

After referring to these precedents, the Patna High Court referred to the Full Bench judgment in Shikha Kumari. There, the Full Bench had categorically held that a writ of habeas corpus is not maintainable if detention is by virtue of judicial orders passed by a Magistrate or a court of competent jurisdiction. It also held that an order of remand cannot be set aside in a habeas corpus petition.

The Bench found that the petitioner’s case was squarely covered by these rulings. Here, the petitioner was in custody on the basis of remand orders passed by the jurisdictional Magistrate in a criminal case where investigation was complete, charge-sheet had been filed and cognizance had been taken.

Critically, the petitioner had not challenged the Magistrate’s orders of remand or cognizance in any appellate or revisional forum. Instead, he had directly filed a writ petition seeking habeas corpus and quashing of the FIR.

The Court therefore concluded that his detention could not be termed “illegal” for the purpose of habeas corpus. It also reiterated that the High Court, in writ jurisdiction, cannot look into his defence or the correctness of the allegations in the FIR when the matter is already before the trial court.

On these grounds, the Court held that no case had been made out for issuance of a writ of habeas corpus or for quashing of the criminal case. The writ application was dismissed.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment sends an important message to foreign nationals, refugees, and other accused persons who are in custody under court orders.

The Patna High Court has made it clear that if someone is in jail because a Magistrate has remanded them in a criminal case, they cannot use a habeas corpus petition to get immediate release from the High Court. Their detention will not be treated as illegal simply because they dispute the allegations.

Instead, such a person must follow the usual criminal law process: apply for bail, challenge the order of cognizance or remand before the appropriate court, and defend themselves at trial.

The judgment also shows that holding a UNHCR refugee card or a foreign passport does not automatically shield a person from criminal proceedings under Indian law, especially once the matter has reached the stage of charge-sheet and cognizance. Any such defences have to be taken before the trial court, not through habeas corpus.

Legal Issues and Answers

  • Issue: Can a foreign national, facing a criminal case and in custody under remand orders of a Magistrate, seek release through a writ of habeas corpus under Article 226?
    Answer: No. The Patna High Court held that where detention is pursuant to judicial orders of a court of competent jurisdiction, a writ of habeas corpus is not maintainable.
  • Issue: Can the High Court, in a habeas corpus writ, quash an FIR and treat the detention as illegal when investigation is complete, charge-sheet has been filed and cognizance taken?
    Answer: No. Once the Magistrate has taken cognizance and the case is pending trial, the High Court cannot examine the accused’s defence in habeas corpus to set aside the FIR or declare the custody illegal.
  • Issue: Does possession of a UNHCR refugee certificate automatically nullify criminal proceedings under Section 14(B) of the Foreigners Act or Section 447 IPC?
    Answer: The Court did not accept this contention in writ jurisdiction. It held that such defences must be raised before the trial court and do not make the judicial custody illegal for the purpose of habeas corpus.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • Saurabh Kumar vs. Jailor, Koneila Jail & Anr., (2014) 13 SCC 436
  • State of Maharashtra & Ors. vs. Tasneem Rizwan Siddiquee, (2018) 9 SCC 745
  • Manubhai Ratilal Patel vs. State of Gujarat & Ors., (2013) 1 SCC 314 (referred through Supreme Court precedent)
  • Serious Fraud Investigation Office vs. Rahul Modi & Anr., (2019) 5 SCC 266
  • Shikha Kumari v. State of Bihar through Principal Secretary, Home (Police) Deptt. & Ors., 2020 (2) PLJR 15 (Full Bench, Patna High Court)

Case Details

Case Number: Criminal Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 606 of 2021

Case Title: Hamed Akbari vs. The Union of India & Ors.

Citation: 2022 (4) PLJR 89

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ashwani Kumar Singh and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajeev Ranjan Prasad

Judgment Date: 07-12-2021

Advocates:

  • For the petitioner: Mr. Nafisuzzoha, Advocate
  • For the Union of India: Dr. Krishna Nandan Singh, Additional Solicitor General of India; assisted by Mr. Manoj Kumar Singh, CGC; and Mr. Sriram Krishna, JC to ASG
  • For the State of Bihar: Mr. Prabhu Narayan Sharma, AC

Nature of the Case: Criminal writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking writ of habeas corpus and quashing of FIR.

Link to Judgment: Patna High Court Official Judgment Link

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News