Tenant’s civil revision against eviction dismissed — Patna High Court, 2021

Urvashi Bharti

Reviewed by: Urvashi Bharti

License Number: BR/3533/2024

Last Reviewed On: 21-08-2026

Urvashi Bharti is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in banking regulations and arbitration matters. She represents clients in regulatory compliance issues, arbitration proceedings, and banking sector disputes before the Patna High Court and other forums. Her practice handles commercial arbitration, banking litigation, and dispute resolution for corporate clients and financial institutions.

The tenant challenged an eviction decree passed for the landlord’s personal need of a medical clinic. The Patna High Court refused to interfere. The Court accepted that the landlord and his doctor wife genuinely needed the shop for their practice. The eviction decree passed by the Katihar trial court therefore stands.

Case Background

The dispute concerns a double storied shop in Mangal Bazar, Katihar, measuring about 628 sq. ft. with 340 sq. ft. on the ground floor. The ground floor was being used as a shop and the first floor room as a godown by the tenant.

The original owner, opposite party no. 1, had purchased the premises by a registered sale deed dated 06.12.2005. Jamabandi and municipal holding were created in his name. Later, in a family arrangement dated 11.06.2008, the premises fell to the share of his son, opposite party no. 2, and mutation was carried out in his favour in State Government and Municipal Corporation records.

Opposite party no. 2 and his wife are medical practitioners. According to him, they required the Mangal Bazar premises to open a clinic, as it was centrally located and close to the hospital. On this basis, the landlord filed Title (Eviction) Suit No. 1 of 2011 under Section 11(1)(c) of the Bihar Building (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1982, claiming bona fide personal necessity.

The learned Sub-Judge-I, Katihar, after trial, decreed the suit on 01.10.2018 in favour of the landlord. The tenant then filed Civil Revision No. 172 of 2018 under Section 14(8) of the 1982 Act before the Patna High Court, challenging the eviction decree.

During the pendency of the revision, opposite party no. 1 (the original purchaser and father of opposite party no. 2) died on 31.08.2020. Applications were filed under Order XXII Rule 4 and Order XXII Rule 10A of the Code of Civil Procedure to deal with the consequence of his death.

The High Court recorded that opposite party no. 2, already on record, is a legal heir and successor of deceased opposite party no. 1, that the eviction suit was based on personal necessity of opposite party no. 2, and that he is the owner of the tenanted premises. Therefore, the right to sue survived on him alone; there was no need to substitute other legal heirs, and the revision did not abate. I.A. No. 2 of 2021 was disposed of accordingly.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The core dispute before the Patna High Court was whether the eviction decree based on personal necessity was justified, and whether any interference was possible in revisional jurisdiction under Section 14(8) of the Bihar Building (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1982.

The landlord’s case was that both he and his wife are doctors. He is an Assistant Professor at Katihar Medical College, holding MBBS (2001) and MD (2011) degrees, and is entitled to do private practice. He stated that he currently runs his clinic from different rented shops due to lack of a suitable owned premises, and that the suit premises, being in the middle of the town and near the hospital, is ideally suited for his practice and that of his radiologist wife.

He deposed as P.W. 7 that the entire premises is required for the clinic and that partial eviction would not meet his need. Other prosecution witnesses (P.Ws. 1–6) supported his version. Documentary evidence, including rent receipts, government rent receipts, power of attorney, a panchanama, the sale deed and original receipts, were produced and exhibited.

The tenant, in his written statement and evidence, took a different stand. He argued that the shop is in the middle of Mangal Bazar, an area full of noise, traffic and pollution, making it unsuitable for a medical clinic. He described the shop as 10 ft. wide and 24 ft. long, with a similar room above, and stated that several other tenants occupy shops on the ground floor.

The tenant also pointed out that the landlord has a large three-storied residential house at Barmasia with sufficient accommodation, which he said was better suited for a clinic. Many reputed doctors already have their clinics in that residential area near the main road. According to the tenant, the requirement projected for the Mangal Bazar shop was not bona fide or in good faith.

Further, the tenant alleged that the landlord owns multiple shops in Kunj Niketan Katra, where he could conveniently open a clinic. He claimed that the landlord’s real intention was to pressure tenants to increase rent, pointing out that the landlord had earlier filed House Control Case No. 2 of 2007 before the Rent Controller for enhancement of rent, which was raised to Rs. 1920/- per month and was then pending before the Collector, Katihar, after remand by the Commissioner, Purnea.

The tenant denied that opposite party no. 2 is a practising doctor, claiming he is an Assistant Professor in Preventive and Social Medicine and that both he and his wife are in service and therefore cannot do private practice. According to the tenant, the plea of personal necessity was only a pretext to evict him so the premises could be let out at a higher rent.

The tenant examined 19 witnesses and produced documents such as patta records, a rent agreement, rent receipts and the application to the Rent Controller.

On this material, the trial court framed eight issues, of which three were central: (i) whether there was a landlord-tenant relationship; (ii) whether the personal necessity of the landlord was bona fide and in good faith; and (iii) whether partial eviction would satisfy the landlord’s need.

After appreciating the oral and documentary evidence, the trial court held that the landlord-tenant relationship was established. It further found that opposite party no. 2 is a medical practitioner, that he genuinely required the suit premises for a clinic along with his wife, and that in the absence of the premises he had been compelled to take another shop on rent for his practice. It also found that the premises, being by the side of the main road, was ideally suited for a medical clinic and that the requirement was in good faith and bona fide.

On the question of partial eviction, the trial court noted that the landlord had pleaded and proved that he needed the whole premises and that his need could not be met if only a part was vacated.

In the High Court, the tenant’s counsel relied on the decision in Shakuntala Devi v. Sajjan Kumar Bajoria, 2013 (3) PLJR 395, to argue that the landlord’s plea of personal necessity was a ploy, and that where a landlord has other premises and gives no proper reason for preferring the suit premises, the court should not mechanically accept the claim of bona fide requirement.

The landlord’s counsel, on the other hand, relied on several authorities. He cited the Patna High Court judgment in Shri Vinod Kumar Gupta & Anr. v. Smt. Pushpa Devi & Anr., 2005 (3) PLJR 719, which clarifies that once the landlord proves bona fide need, the burden shifts to the tenant to raise and prove a plea of partial eviction. The landlord’s counsel also referred to Supreme Court decisions in Akhileshwar Kumar & Ors. v. Mustaqim & Ors., 2003 (1) PLJR 271, and Savitri Sahay v. Sachidanand Prasad, 2003 (1) PLJR 171, to argue that a court cannot thrust its own choice of premises upon a landlord and that Explanation II to Section 11(1)(c) allows the landlord to choose which tenanted premises he prefers, even if he has more than one.

Further reliance was placed on Md. Ehsam Rasul v. Munni Devi, 2016 (4) PLJR 20, which, following the Supreme Court Constitution Bench decision in Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Dilbahar Singh, 2014 (9) SCALE 657 : 2015 (1) PLJR (SC) 187, underlines the limited scope of revisional jurisdiction under rent control statutes. A revisional court cannot act as a second appellate court or re-appreciate evidence as if hearing a first appeal.

Justice S. Kumar considered these arguments and the trial court record. He noted that the trial court had conducted an elaborate scrutiny and due appreciation of the evidence before concluding that the landlord’s requirement was bona fide and in good faith.

The High Court held that the tenant’s argument, that the landlord’s residential house at Barmasia or other shops in Katra were more suitable, could not by itself defeat the landlord’s plea of personal necessity. It is not for the tenant to dictate on which premises the landlord should run his clinic, especially when the evidence showed that the landlord was already running his medical clinic from rented premises due to lack of possession of the suit shop.

The Court also observed that the case law relied on by the tenant (Shakuntala Devi) was not applicable to the facts of this case. Here, there was no pleading or evidence that any other shops of the landlord were vacant or had become vacant and were equally suitable for running the clinic. Thus the factual foundation for applying that precedent was missing.

Given these findings, and keeping in mind the limited scope of interference in revision under Section 14(8) of the Bihar Building (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, the Patna High Court found no error or infirmity in the trial court’s order. It therefore refused to interfere with the eviction decree.

Accordingly, the civil revision filed by the tenant was dismissed, and the eviction decree in favour of the landlord was affirmed.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is significant for tenants and landlords in Bihar, especially those involved in rent and eviction disputes under the Bihar Building (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1982.

First, the Patna High Court reiterates that when a landlord proves genuine personal need—here, a doctor needing a clinic—the tenant cannot insist that the landlord should use some other property or location which the tenant considers “better”. The landlord’s choice of premises, if bona fide, will usually be respected.

Second, the Court underscores that in a civil revision under Section 14(8), it will not re-hear the case or re-weigh evidence like an appeal. If the trial court has carefully considered the evidence and applied the correct legal principles, the High Court will not interfere even if another view is theoretically possible.

Third, the judgment shows that mere allegations of a landlord’s motive to get higher rent will not succeed unless backed by clear factual pleadings and evidence, such as proof that other similar premises of the landlord are vacant and equally suitable.

For shop tenants, this decision is a reminder that if the landlord’s personal necessity is proved, and especially where the landlord is already forced to carry on his business from rented premises, the chances of resisting eviction are low in revision.

Legal Issues and Answers

  • Issue: Whether the landlord’s requirement of the suit shop for opening a medical clinic with his wife was bona fide and in good faith under Section 11(1)(c) of the Bihar Building (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1982.
    Answer: Yes. Both the trial court and the Patna High Court held that the landlord is a medical practitioner, already practising from rented premises, and genuinely requires the suit premises, which is suitably located, for his clinic along with his wife.
  • Issue: Whether the High Court should interfere with the eviction decree in its revisional jurisdiction under Section 14(8) of the Bihar Building (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1982.
    Answer: No. The High Court found that the trial court had properly appreciated the evidence and applied the law. There was no error or perversity warranting interference, and the scope of revision does not permit re-appreciation of evidence as in an appeal.
  • Issue: Whether alternative premises allegedly available to the landlord in Barmasia or Kunj Niketan Katra, or the possibility of partial eviction, defeated the claim of personal necessity.
    Answer: No. It is not for the tenant to dictate the landlord’s choice of premises. There was no pleading or evidence that other shops were vacant and equally suitable, and the landlord had proved that he required the whole suit premises. The tenant did not discharge the burden regarding partial eviction.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • Shri Vinod Kumar Gupta & Anr. v. Smt. Pushpa Devi & Anr., 2005 (3) PLJR 719 – on burden regarding partial eviction.
  • M/s Bata India Ltd. v. Dr. Md. Qamruzzama, MANU/BH/0328/1992 : 1993 (1) PLJR 87 – Division Bench on onus to seek partial eviction.
  • Food Corporation of India & Ors. v. Vishun Properties & Enterprises & Ors., 1995 B.B.C.J. 711 – plea for partial eviction must be pleaded and proved.
  • Shakuntala Devi v. Sajjan Kumar Bajoria, Civil Revision No. 226 of 2011, 2013 (3) PLJR 395 – relied on by tenant; held inapplicable on facts.
  • Akhileshwar Kumar & Ors. v. Mustaqim & Ors., 2003 (1) PLJR 271 – landlord’s bona fide need and limitation on revisional interference.
  • Savitri Sahay v. Sachidanand Prasad, 2003 (1) PLJR 171 – Explanation II to Section 11(1)(c); landlord’s choice of preferred premises.
  • Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Dilbahar Singh, MANU/SC/0738/2014 : 2014 (9) SCALE 657 : 2015 (1) PLJR (SC) 187 – Constitution Bench on limits of revisional jurisdiction under rent control laws.
  • Md. Ehsam Rasul v. Munni Devi, Civil Revision No. 169 of 2013, 2016 (4) PLJR 20 – Patna High Court applying Dilbahar Singh to Section 14(8) revisions.

Case Details

Case Number: Civil Revision No. 172 of 2018

Case Title: Dilip Kumar Agrawal v. Kamakhya Prasad & Anr.

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Kumar

Date of Judgment: 17-02-2021

Citation: 2022(4) PLJR 290

Advocates:

  • For the Petitioner (tenant): Mr. Bimlendu Mishra, Advocate
  • For the Opposite Party (landlord): Mr. Pramod Kumar Sinha, Advocate; Mr. Gyan Prakash Ojha, Advocate; Mr. Uday Shankar Pandey, Advocate; Mr. Chetan Kumar, Advocate

Nature of the Case: Civil revision under Section 14(8) of the Bihar Building (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1982, challenging an eviction decree passed in a Title (Eviction) Suit on the ground of bona fide personal necessity of the landlord.

Link to Full Judgment: Patna High Court Judgment in C.R. No. 172 of 2018


If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News