Case Background
This case arose from a long‑running dispute between a media company and two of its former employees about payment of back wages.
The original matter came before the Patna High Court as Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 9511 of 2008. That writ petition concerned, among other things, whether one of the employees was entitled to payment of back wages for a specific period between alleged retrenchment and later employment.
On 09.02.2024, a learned Single Judge of the Patna High Court passed an order in the writ petition. The detailed contents of that judgment are not reproduced in the present Letters Patent Appeal, but it is clear that the employer was aggrieved by that order.
The employer, M/s. Bennett Coleman and Co. Ltd. (Patna Establishment), filed an intra‑court appeal, registered as Letters Patent Appeal (L.P.A.) No. 590 of 2025, before a Division Bench of the Patna High Court. The respondents included the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Patna, the State of Bihar, and the two individual workmen.
While this L.P.A. was pending, a significant development took place. The two individual respondents, Shri Harendra Pratap Singh and Shri Sharad Ranjan Prasad, filed Civil Review No. 257 of 2024 before the same learned Single Judge who had decided the writ petition on 09.02.2024.
The present judgment dated 29.09.2026 records how the Division Bench dealt with the employer’s appeal in light of this pending review petition.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The Division Bench, comprising Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Kumar Verma, heard learned counsel for all parties in the Letters Patent Appeal.
The appeal challenged the single judge’s order dated 09.02.2024 in C.W.J.C. No. 9511 of 2008. Although the Division Bench did not go into the merits of that earlier judgment, it took note of an important procedural fact that emerged during the hearing of the appeal.
It was brought to the notice of the Division Bench that the two individual respondents (respondent nos. 2 and 3) had themselves filed Civil Review No. 257 of 2024 before the learned Single Judge. This review petition sought reconsideration of the same judgment dated 09.02.2024 which was the subject matter of the employer’s appeal.
The Division Bench then referred to an order dated 26.03.2025 passed in the review application by the learned Single Judge. This order sheds light on the core dispute between the parties.
The learned Single Judge recorded that the petitioner in the writ petition (and now review applicant) had filed O.A. 1820 of 2012 before the Principal Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal, New Delhi. In that context, the review petitioner had stated that he had been working as a Hindi Senior Journalist with Nav Bharat Times (NBT), then in the audio/visual medium with Doordarshan and All India Radio, and for a year with Dainik Jagran.
Against this background, the learned Single Judge identified the key issue in the writ petition: whether the petitioner was entitled to any payment of back wages for the period from 20.03.1995 till 09.06.1999, that is, from the date of retrenchment till the date of employment.
To properly decide this issue, the learned Single Judge directed the review petitioner to file an affidavit along with necessary documents showing his employment with Nav Bharat Times (NBT), Doordarshan, All India Radio and Dainik Jagran by way of a supplementary affidavit.
The order made it clear that the supplementary affidavit must contain details of the employment and the number of dates that the petitioner had worked with each of these organizations. The matter in the review was then ordered to be listed on 29.04.2025.
This order shows that the single judge was actively examining whether the workman had alternative employment or earnings during the period for which he claimed back wages. That question could directly affect how much, if anything, he was entitled to receive from the employer for that time.
After noting this, the Division Bench considered what should happen to the pending Letters Patent Appeal. The Bench observed that the review application was still pending before the learned Single Judge and that the issues involved in the review could have a direct bearing on the appeal.
If the Division Bench were to decide the appeal while the review was still being examined, there was a risk of conflicting or overlapping decisions on the same judgment. The outcome of the review could potentially change the very order that was under challenge in the appeal.
In these circumstances, the Division Bench concluded that it would not be appropriate to proceed further with the intra‑court appeal at this stage. Instead of keeping the appeal pending indefinitely, the Court chose to formally dispose of it but protected the employer’s legal rights for the future.
Accordingly, the Division Bench disposed of L.P.A. No. 590 of 2025. However, it expressly granted liberty to the appellant‑employer to challenge the order that may eventually be passed in Civil Review No. 257 of 2024, as well as any consequential orders, if so advised.
This means that once the learned Single Judge decides the review petition, and depending on the outcome, the employer will still have the right to approach the appropriate forum, including potentially filing a fresh appeal.
The Division Bench also clarified that all pending applications in the appeal would stand disposed of along with the appeal itself.
In simple terms, the Patna High Court did not decide who is finally right or wrong about back wages in this judgment. Instead, it recognised that the same issues are already being re‑examined in a review before the single judge, and it chose to wait for that process to be completed before any further appellate scrutiny.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is important mainly from a procedural point of view. It shows how the Patna High Court manages overlapping proceedings about the same judgment.
For employers and employees involved in labour disputes, it highlights that when a review petition is already pending before a single judge about the same order, the Division Bench may choose not to hear an appeal at the same time. This avoids conflicting decisions and unnecessary confusion.
For workers claiming back wages, the order of the learned Single Judge in the review proceedings is also significant. It shows that courts can closely look into whether the worker was earning from other jobs during the period for which back wages are claimed. The worker may be asked to file detailed affidavits and documents about other employment.
Practically, this judgment ensures that the review court first completes its job. After that, if any party is still dissatisfied, they are free to challenge the final outcome. This approach promotes judicial economy and consistency.
Legal Issues and Answers
Issue: Should the Division Bench decide the employer’s Letters Patent Appeal while a review petition against the same single judge judgment is still pending?
Answer: No. The Division Bench held that it would not be appropriate to proceed with the intra‑court appeal because the pending review and the issues involved there could directly affect the appeal.
Issue: What rights does the employer retain after disposal of the Letters Patent Appeal?
Answer: The employer is at liberty to challenge the order that may be passed in Civil Review No. 257 of 2024 and any consequential orders, if so advised.
Issue: What factual aspect is central to deciding the workman’s claim for back wages?
Answer: According to the single judge’s review order, the central question is whether the workman is entitled to back wages from 20.03.1995 to 09.06.1999, which requires detailed proof regarding his employment and work with Nav Bharat Times, Doordarshan, All India Radio and Dainik Jagran during that period.
Cases Cited by the Court
- The judgment does not refer to or rely upon any earlier decided cases.
Case Details
Case Number: Letters Patent Appeal No. 590 of 2025 in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 9511 of 2008; related Civil Review No. 257 of 2024 (pending before Single Judge)
Case Title: M/s. Bennett Coleman and Co. Ltd. (Patna Establishment) v. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Patna & Ors.
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Kumar Verma
Citation: 2026 (5) PLJR 143
Advocates:
- For the Appellant (employer): Mr. Sanjay Singh, Sr. Advocate; Mr. Sanjay Kumar Ojha, Advocate; Mr. Rudrank Shivam Singh, Advocate; Mr. Ved Prakash Chandan, Advocate; Mr. Govind Lal Pandit, Advocate
- For the State of Bihar: Mr. Bindhyachal Rai, AAG‑15
- For Respondent No. 2: Mr. Shashank Shekhar Sinha, Advocate
- For Respondent No. 3: Mr. Rajiv Kr. Singh, Sr. Advocate
Nature of the Case: Intra‑court appeal (Letters Patent Appeal) arising out of a writ petition in a labour/back wages dispute; appeal disposed of due to pendency of a civil review before the Single Judge.
Link: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MyM1OTAjMjAyNSMxI04=-ib1t6G5LpT0=
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



