Stone mining lease dispute partly allowed, deposit refunded with interest — Patna High Court, 2026

Abhishek Kumar

Reviewed by: Abhishek Kumar

License Number: BR/1810/2019

Last Reviewed On: 18-11-2026

Abhishek Kumar is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in GST and Income Tax matters. He represents clients before the Patna High Court and other jurisdictions in tax disputes and regulatory compliance issues. His practice handles tax assessment proceedings, GST-related matters, and commercial disputes for businesses and individuals across Bihar and surrounding regions.

The Patna High Court heard the State’s appeal in a stone mining lease dispute from Sheikhpura district. The Court set aside the earlier Single Judge order that had forced the State to continue with the old lease. It held that both the bidder and the State were responsible for delay. The State must now refund the forfeited deposit with 12% interest and issue fresh tender, where the firm can participate again.

Case Background

The dispute began with a tender for mining leases over nine stone blocks in Sheikhpura district. A notice inviting tender was issued by the District Magistrate, Sheikhpura, and the respondent firm emerged as the highest bidder for Stone Block No.27 at Mauza-Hazratpur Mandro Chandi, area 5 hectares.

A letter of intent was issued in favour of the firm on 21.09.2017. The block was to be settled in its favour for five years from the date of execution of the lease deed. Under the tender conditions and rules, the firm had to deposit 10% of the deed amount as security, submit the lease deed in Form-B within 120 days from the LOI, obtain an approved mining plan, secure environmental clearance and make all other payments as per LOI.

However, environmental clearance could not be granted because the District Survey Report (DSR) for the district was not complete. In particular, it did not contain the geo-coordinates (latitude and longitude) of Stone Block No.27, which were necessary for environmental clearance.

On 23.01.2023, the District Magistrate, Sheikhpura approved the “emolument” of the letter of intent and simultaneously ordered forfeiture of the earnest money. The order recorded a delay of five years and three months on the part of the firm in executing the lease deed, and on that basis cancelled the LOI.

The firm filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Mines, Bihar (Appeal No.01 of 2022). By order dated 14.07.2023, the Commissioner dismissed the appeal and affirmed the District Magistrate’s order.

Aggrieved, the firm filed C.W.J.C. No.11678 of 2023 before a Single Judge of the Patna High Court. On 02.05.2026, the writ Court allowed the petition. The Single Judge directed the authorities to finalize the DSR of mining lease with the writ-petitioner, extend the time of lease, issue work order and complete final settlement of the lease contract within six weeks.

The State of Bihar and its officers then filed the present Letters Patent Appeal (L.P.A. No.865 of 2024) under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent, challenging the Single Judge’s judgment. During pendency, there was also an interim prayer by the writ-petitioner to restrain a fresh auction of Stone Block No.27. The Division Bench decided to hear and dispose of the main appeal itself.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The Division Bench, speaking through Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bibek Chaudhuri, first recorded the undisputed factual chain. The auction took place on 18.03.2017; the letter of intent was issued on 21.09.2017. The legal framework governing the lease included the Bihar Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1972 and later the Bihar Minerals (Concession, Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation & Storage) Rules, 2019.

Under Rule 28 of the 2019 Rules, once a mineral concession is granted, the formal lease deed must be executed by the Collector in Form “B” within 180 days of the order sanctioning the lease. If the person in whose favour the concession is granted fails to submit the required documents within that period, the sanction is deemed revoked and the application fee and security deposit stand forfeited. The proviso states that no lease shall be executed until the mining plan and environmental clearance are submitted. A further proviso empowers the Collector to permit execution even after 180 days if satisfied that the lessee is not responsible for the delay.

Rule 25(1) of the 1972 Rules similarly provides that the lease must be executed within 120 days, failing which revocation and forfeiture follow automatically as a deeming provision.

The respondent’s counsel argued that under the Supreme Court’s directions in State of Bihar v. Pawan Kumar (Civil Appeal Nos.3661–3662 of 2020) and the 2020 sand mining guidelines, the DSR has to be prepared before auction or grant of LOI. Clause 4.1.1(a) clearly states that DSR for sand mining must be in place before auction or e-auction or grant of mining lease/LOI. Clauses 4.1.1(o) and (p) describe the process, including site visits and public consultation.

He submitted that in Sheikhpura, the DSR was incomplete and did not mention the geo-coordinates of the firm’s stone block. As a result, the firm could not obtain environmental clearance within time despite approaching authorities. Therefore, he argued, the delay was not attributable to the firm and the Collector should have used the second proviso to Rule 28 to extend time, instead of cancelling the LOI and forfeiting the huge deposit.

The firm’s counsel also referred to an order of the Commissioner of Mines dated 14.07.2023, which listed several key dates: auction, LOI, submission of mining plan, approach to SEIAA (State Environment Impact Assessment Authority), public hearing, and subsequent steps seeking DSR and geo-coordinates. He emphasised the finding recorded there that, without correct DSR and mining plan data, SEIAA could not grant clearance.

On the legal side, he invoked the Supreme Court decision in Goa State Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. Krishna Nath A. (2019) 20 SCC 38, where the Court stressed that no party should derive unfair advantage from delay in litigation, and that restitution aims to restore parties to their rightful position. He also cited The Director of Mines and Geology v. BMM Ispat Ltd. (2026 INSC 627) on the principle that royalty becomes payable at the time minerals are dispatched and may vary if the law changes later.

On the other hand, the learned Advocate General for the State placed a detailed chronology from government records. He argued that although the LOI was issued on 21.09.2017, the firm only took its first concrete step for environmental clearance on 10.08.2018—almost eleven months later. This was well beyond the 120 or 180-day window provided in the rules. Therefore, he contended, the statutory consequence of automatic revocation and forfeiture applied.

He further relied on paragraph 33 of the Single Judge’s judgment, where the writ Court itself acknowledged that there was “delay and laches on part of the petitioner”, even though the State also erred by not issuing geo-coordinates in the DSR. According to the State, once the Single Judge accepted that the petitioner was at fault, it was improper to grant equitable relief under Article 226 of the Constitution, especially in the face of clear statutory provisions.

The Advocate General also questioned the direction issued by the Single Judge to SEIAA, even though SEIAA was not a party to the writ petition. He submitted that a non-party statutory authority could not be bound by such orders.

After hearing both sides, the Division Bench turned to the broader question: to what extent can the High Court exercise writ jurisdiction in government contracts and tenders? The Bench relied heavily on the recent three-Judge Bench decision of the Supreme Court in Subodh Kumar Singh Rathore v. Chief Executive Officer (2024) 15 SCC 461. Extracting paragraphs 33–43 from the headnotes, the Bench summarised how the law had evolved:

Courts once treated contract disputes with the State as purely private law matters, unsuitable for writs. Over time, this approach was found to enable arbitrary and unfair conduct by the State. The Supreme Court therefore opened the door to judicial review even in contractual settings, especially where public law elements like fairness, non-arbitrariness, and equality were at stake.

Cases such as Mahabir Auto Stores v. Indian Oil Corporation and A.B.L. International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation affirmed that State action in contracts can be tested on grounds of reasonableness, fair play and non-discrimination. However, courts generally do not rewrite contract terms or interfere in purely consensual aspects like price, technical specifications, or method of execution. The focus is on preventing abuse of power by public authorities.

Applying these principles, the Division Bench examined the conduct of both parties. It noted that the firm did not explain why it remained inactive for almost eleven months after receiving the LOI before approaching authorities for environmental clearance. This alone meant that the statutory time period for execution had lapsed long before the firm acted. At the same time, the State also delayed and failed to supply a complete DSR with geo-coordinates, which in turn delayed the processing of environmental clearance by SEIAA.

The Court observed that nearly nine years had passed since the LOI was issued. In this backdrop, it held that both sides were guilty of “contributory negligence” in failing to ensure timely execution of the lease deed. Because the firm could not start mining, the State also lost royalty and revenue which could have been earned if the lease was operational.

Regarding the argument that the State would not lose money because royalty is paid at current rates at the time of extraction, the Court disagreed. It pointed out that royalty rates and revenue structures had changed over nine to ten years. The royalty fixed in 2017 would not match today’s rates. Thus the prolonged non-operation did cause financial loss, and this aspect had not been properly considered by the Single Judge.

On the question of forfeiture, however, the Court took a balanced view. Recognising that the State had also failed in its duty to provide necessary documents like a proper DSR, the Bench held that the State could not retain the entire security deposit as if the delay were solely the firm’s fault. It therefore set aside that part of the Collector’s order, as affirmed by the Commissioner, which had forfeited the initial bid amount of Rs.2,90,00,000.

Instead, the Court directed that this amount be refunded to the writ-petitioner with interest at 12% per annum from the date of deposit till payment. This refund must be made before the State initiates a new tender process for Stone Block No.27.

The Bench also clarified that when a new tender is floated, the writ-petitioner must be allowed to participate, and its past conduct in this case cannot be used as a ground to reject its bid. If it becomes the lowest or successful bidder (L-1), it will be entitled to a fresh letter of intent like any other bidder.

At the same time, the Division Bench found it necessary to address systemic issues leading to repeated disputes in mining leases. It noted that in this and other similar cases, leases were getting revoked because different government departments failed to provide key documents—particularly DSR and environmental clearances—within statutory timelines. To prevent such recurring problems, the Court framed detailed guidelines directed at the State government.

The guidelines require that DSRs be prepared and issued along with the tender notice; that the DSR must include block-wise geo-coordinates and all relevant information; that LOIs be issued within 15 days of auction; that successful bidders submit mining plans within 15 days of receiving LOI; that mining plans be approved within 15 days; and that applications to SEIAA for environmental clearance be filed within 7 days thereafter. Once environmental clearance is received, the lease deed must be executed within the statutory time. The Court further held that failure by State departments to provide necessary information and documents will be treated as non-performance of promise, rendering the State liable to pay damages.

Having concluded that the lease stood revoked due to contributory negligence and that the Single Judge’s directions effectively compelled the State to revive an expired arrangement and bind even non-party authorities, the Division Bench set aside the Single Judge’s judgment in full. The Letters Patent Appeal was allowed.

Why This Judgment Matters

This Patna High Court judgment is important for stone and sand miners, contractors, and government officers across Bihar. It shows that when timelines for executing mining leases are not followed, the courts will not easily force the government to continue with an old, lapsed arrangement—especially after many years.

At the same time, the State cannot use its own delay or incomplete paperwork to punish bidders by seizing large deposits. Where both sides are at fault, the Court can order refund of money with interest, as it has done here.

The judgment also lays down concrete, time-bound steps for preparing DSRs, issuing letters of intent, approving mining plans, and moving for environmental clearances. If State departments fail to do their part under these guidelines, the Court has warned that the State may have to pay damages for non-performance.

For ordinary bidders and small mining operators, this decision clarifies that they must act quickly after receiving a letter of intent and keep pressing authorities for required documents. Delayed action can lead to automatic loss of lease rights under the rules. For officials, it underlines that sloppy handling of DSRs and clearances can now expose the State to financial liability.

Legal Issues and Answers


  • Issue: Can the High Court, in writ jurisdiction, compel the State to continue with a mining lease when statutory time-limits for execution have long expired and both sides have delayed?

    Answer: No. The Division Bench held that the lease stood revoked under the statutory rules due to non-execution within time and contributory negligence of both parties; therefore, the Single Judge’s directions to finalize DSR, extend lease time, and complete settlement were unsustainable.

  • Issue: Was the State justified in forfeiting the bidder’s security deposit of Rs.2.90 crore after cancelling the letter of intent?

    Answer: Not entirely. While the bidder delayed in seeking environmental clearance, the State also failed to supply necessary DSR and geo-coordinates. Recognising this shared fault, the Court set aside the forfeiture and directed refund of the deposit with 12% interest.

  • Issue: What duties do State authorities have regarding DSR and environmental clearance in mining tenders?

    Answer: The Court held that DSR must be prepared and issued with the tender, containing full geo-coordinates and details for each block. Authorities must also adhere to strict timelines for issuing LOI, approving mining plans, and assisting bidders in obtaining environmental clearance, failing which the State may be liable for damages.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • State of Bihar and Ors. v. Pawan Kumar and Ors. etc., Civil Appeal Nos.3661–3662 of 2020, decided on 10.11.2021 (2020 sand mining guidelines and DSR requirements).
  • The Director of Mines and Geology v. M/s BMM Ispat Ltd. & Anr., 2026 INSC 627 (royalty payable on dispatch and impact of statutory change).
  • Goa State Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. Krishna Nath A. (Dead) through Legal Representatives & Ors., (2019) 20 SCC 38 (principle of restitution and disgorgement of advantage from delay).
  • Subodh Kumar Singh Rathore v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors., (2024) 15 SCC 461 (scope of judicial review in government contracts and tenders).
  • Mahabir Auto Stores v. Indian Oil Corporation, (1990) 3 SCC 752 (State’s contractual actions subject to judicial review on fairness grounds).
  • A.B.L. International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd., (2004) 3 SCC 553 (writ maintainability in contractual disputes with State).

Case Details

Case Number: Letters Patent Appeal No.865 of 2024 in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.11678 of 2023

Case Title: The State of Bihar & Ors. v. M/s. Balaji Enterprises

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bibek Chaudhuri and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rana Vikram Singh

Citation: 2026 (6) PLJR 243

Advocates:

  • For the Appellants (State of Bihar and officers): Mr. S.D. Sanjay, Advocate General; Mr. Prakash Chandra Agrawal, GA-5; Ms. Surbhi Agrawal, JC to GA-5.
  • For the Respondent (M/s. Balaji Enterprises): Mr. Suraj Samdarshi, Advocate; Mr. Avinash Shekhar, Advocate; Ms. Simran Kumari, Advocate; Ms. Abhilasha Jha, Advocate.

Nature of the Case: Letters Patent Appeal against Single Judge writ order relating to cancellation of mining lease LOI, forfeiture of deposit, and directions concerning DSR and environmental clearance.

Date of Division Bench Judgment: 01.10.2026

Link to Judgment: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MyM4NjUjMjAyNCMxI04=-zwJaNwi91m4=


If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News