Assistant Professor selection claim rejected over residency requirement — Patna High Court, 2021

Sakshi Bhatnagar

Reviewed by: Sakshi Bhatnagar

License Number: BR/2891A/2019

Last Reviewed On: 17-08-2026

Sakshi Bhatanagar is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing criminal law. She represents clients in criminal proceedings before the Patna High Court and subordinate courts, handling bail applications, criminal appeals, NDPS matters, and customs-related cases. Her practice focuses on criminal defense and litigation across multiple forums in Bihar.

The petitioner challenged Bihar Public Service Commission’s refusal to call him for interview for the post of Assistant Professor in Medicine under advertisement no. 15/2017. The Patna High Court held that he did not have three years’ Senior Residency in a Medical College recognized by the Medical Council of India. His experience before the institute’s recognition could not be counted. The writ petition was dismissed and the selection process continues without him.

Case Background

The petitioner is a government doctor holding MBBS and MD degrees and serving as a Medical Officer in the Government of Bihar since 2000.

In 2009, the State invited applications from Medical Officers for preparation of a panel of Senior Residents/Tutors on tenure posts. The petitioner applied through the Civil Surgeon-cum-Chief Medical Officer, Bhojpur, opting for several government medical colleges at Patna, Muzaffarpur, Darbhanga and Gaya.

However, by a common notification dated 10.05.2011, he was posted instead at Vardhman Institute of Medical Sciences (VIMS), Pawapuri, Nalanda. He joined there as Senior Resident on 29.11.2011 and continued till 15.08.2015.

Meanwhile, Bihar Public Service Commission (BPSC) issued advertisement no. 15/2017 for recruitment of Assistant Professors in different faculties of Medical Science in various government medical colleges. The petitioner applied for the post of Assistant Professor in the Department of Medicine.

When BPSC published the list of ineligible candidates, the petitioner’s name appeared with the remark that his Senior Residency was “less than three years in recognized Medical College”. Feeling aggrieved, he approached the Patna High Court under its writ jurisdiction.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The main relief sought was a direction to the respondents to issue an interview letter (admit card) to the petitioner, and a declaration that his academic qualification and Senior Residency experience met the conditions of advertisement no. 15/2017. He also wanted the Court to hold that BPSC’s remark regarding his Senior Residency being less than three years in a recognized Medical College was incorrect.

The petitioner’s case was that he had four years’ experience as Senior Resident. He argued that because he was posted to VIMS, Pawapuri, Nalanda by the State Government, his entire tenure there from 17.05.2011 to 15.08.2015 should be counted, even though the institute did not have Medical Council of India (MCI) recognition for the entire period.

To support this, his counsel relied on a letter dated 17.01.2018 written by the Special Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar to the Secretary, BPSC. In this letter, the department requested that the petitioner’s experience at VIMS from 17.05.2011 to 15.08.2015 be taken into account and that he be treated as eligible for interview for the post of Assistant Professor. The petitioner argued that since he had been posted there by the State itself, any lack of recognition of the institute should not go against him.

On the other side, BPSC opposed the petition. Its counsel explained that advertisements no. 07/2017 to 31/2017, including advertisement no. 15/2017, were issued on the basis of a requisition from the Health Department dated 26.02.2016 for 1171 posts of Assistant Professors in various medical colleges and hospitals under the department. These advertisements followed the Bihar Health Service Recruitment Rules, 2008 and the revised Rules, 2013. The last date for submission of applications was 31.05.2017.

BPSC set out the essential qualifications and experience mentioned in advertisement no. 15/2017. For Assistant Professors, the candidate must have a postgraduate degree in the specified subject and three years’ teaching experience as Senior Resident/Tutor in that subject after post-graduation, from Medical Colleges and Hospitals recognized by the MCI. Officers of the State Health Service could apply if they had already served as Resident/Senior Resident/Tutor for at least three years in teaching institutions recognized by MCI. It was also required that MBBS, PG and super speciality degrees be from MCI-recognized institutions.

BPSC also informed the Court about a corrigendum. Due to a clerical mistake, the advertisement had repeated a sentence granting five years’ age relaxation for members of the Bihar State Health Service Cadre. This relaxation, under notification dated 28.11.2013, applied to Senior Resident/Tutor posts, not to Assistant Professors. After noticing the error, BPSC deleted that sentence by publishing a corrigendum in newspapers and on its website on 03.05.2017.

BPSC further clarified that 31.05.2017, the last date for application, was the cut-off date by which all candidates had to meet the eligibility criteria, as per letter dated 15.07.2016 of the Health Department.

An Expert Committee constituted by the Health Department examined all applications under the recruitment rules of 2008 and 2013. Regarding the petitioner, the Committee noted two periods of Senior Residency claimed by him.

First, the petitioner had worked as Senior Resident at IGIMS, Patna from 04.08.2003 to 31.10.2006. During that period, IGIMS, Patna was not a recognized medical college by MCI, so this experience was not counted for eligibility.

Second, he had worked at VIMS, Pawapuri, Nalanda, from 17.05.2011 to 15.08.2015. The Committee noted that MCI had recognized VIMS only in 2013. Referring to a certificate issued by the Principal, VIMS, Pawapuri (letter no. 486 dated 16.05.2017), the Committee treated his Senior Residency there as valid only from 02.07.2013 to 15.08.2015, that is, from the date MCI granted permission for establishment of the college. This period was less than three years, so the Committee found him ineligible.

BPSC’s counsel also addressed the Health Department’s letter dated 17.01.2018, which had tried to support the petitioner. He stated that BPSC replied by letter dated 18.01.2018, pointing out that the departmental instruction to count his experience at VIMS from 17.05.2011 was contrary to Rule 7(iii) of the Recruitment Rules. That Rule required three years’ teaching experience as Senior Resident/Tutor in a Medical College recognized by MCI. Therefore, they could not follow the Department’s request.

The counsel for the Medical Council of India (now National Medical Commission) placed on record that the Central Government had issued a letter of permission on 02.07.2013 under Section 10A of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, allowing establishment of VIMS, Pawapuri, Nalanda with an intake of 100 MBBS students annually from the academic year 2013–14. According to the MCI/NMC, the petitioner’s teaching experience could be counted only from 02.07.2013, not earlier.

BPSC further referred to an earlier Division Bench judgment of the Patna High Court in CWJC No. 7297 of 2017, Dr. (Mrs.) Anupama Singh vs. The State of Bihar & Others, decided on 15.05.2017. There, Clause 7(iii)(a) of the 2008 Recruitment Rules had been challenged as being contrary to the MCI’s Minimum Qualifications Regulations, 1998. The Division Bench, after referring to its earlier decision in Md. Ali Muzaffar & Ors. vs. The State of Bihar & Ors., 2012 (3) PLJR 419 and the Supreme Court decision in Sudhir N. & Ors. vs. State of Kerala & Ors., (2015) 6 SCC 685, upheld the Rule. It held that the State could prescribe a higher qualification than the minimum set by MCI and that requiring three years’ teaching experience after post-graduation was a higher qualification and valid.

Relying on this background, BPSC argued that the Rules and the advertisement clearly demanded three years’ experience as Senior Resident/Tutor in an MCI-recognized Medical College and Hospital, and the petitioner simply did not meet this essential qualification.

After hearing all sides and examining the record, the Single Judge analysed Clause 3(a) of advertisement no. 15/2017 and Rule 7(iii)(a) of the 2008 Recruitment Rules. Both provisions required three years’ teaching experience as Senior Resident/Tutor in the specified subject, after post-graduation, from a Medical College and hospital recognized by MCI.

The Court noted that the petitioner had indeed worked as Senior Resident at VIMS from 17.05.2011 to 15.08.2015. However, VIMS, Pawapuri, Nalanda was recognized by MCI/NMC only with effect from 02.07.2013. Consequently, only the period between 02.07.2013 and 15.08.2015 could be counted as valid Senior Residency in a recognized Medical College.

This period was admittedly less than three years. Therefore, the Court held that the petitioner did not fulfil the essential qualification laid down in the advertisement and the Recruitment Rules. It agreed with the Expert Committee and BPSC that he had been rightly treated as ineligible and not called for interview.

Holding that there was no merit in the writ petition, the Court dismissed it.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment sends a clear message to doctors and other professionals applying for government teaching posts. For eligibility, what matters is not just the number of years worked, but where and when that work was done.

Only experience gained in institutions recognized by the Medical Council of India (now National Medical Commission) counts towards the three-year Senior Residency requirement for Assistant Professor posts under the Bihar rules. Time spent before an institute is recognized will not be considered, even if the doctor was posted there by the State Government.

The judgment also shows that recruitment bodies like BPSC are bound by the recruitment rules and the advertisement. Even if a government department later tries to relax or reinterpret the requirement for a particular candidate, BPSC cannot go beyond what the Rules permit.

For candidates, this decision underlines the importance of checking both the recognition status of the institution and the exact wording of the eligibility conditions, including any requirement that experience must be post‑PG and in MCI-recognized colleges.

Legal Issues and Answers

  • Issue: Can teaching experience as Senior Resident in a medical institute be counted for eligibility as Assistant Professor when, for part of that period, the institute was not recognized by the Medical Council of India?
    Answer: No. The Patna High Court held that under advertisement no. 15/2017 and Rule 7(iii)(a) of the 2008 Recruitment Rules, only experience gained after MCI recognition of the Medical College can be counted. The petitioner’s experience was counted only from 02.07.2013, reducing his valid experience to less than three years and making him ineligible.
  • Issue: Was BPSC justified in rejecting the petitioner’s candidature and not calling him for interview for the post of Assistant Professor in Medicine?
    Answer: Yes. As the petitioner lacked the essential qualification of three years’ Senior Residency in an MCI-recognized Medical College, the Court held that BPSC rightly treated him as ineligible and refused to issue an interview letter.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • Md. Ali Muzaffar & Ors. vs. The State of Bihar & Ors., 2012 (3) P.L.J.R. 419
  • Dr. (Mrs.) Anupama Singh vs. The State of Bihar & Others, CWJC No. 7297 of 2017, judgment dated 15.05.2017 (Patna High Court)
  • Sudhir N. & Ors. vs. State of Kerala & Ors., (2015) 6 SCC 685

Case Details

Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 604 of 2018

Case Title: Dr. Tej Narayan Raj vs. The State of Bihar & Others

Citation: 2022(4) PLJR 339

Court: High Court of Judicature at Patna

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Mohit Kumar Shah

Date of Judgment: 24-12-2021

For the Petitioner: Mr. Prakash Chandra Jha, Advocate

For the Bihar Public Service Commission: Mr. Sanjay Pandey, Advocate

For the State of Bihar: Mr. Vasant Vikas, AC to GP-12

For the National Medical Commission (earlier MCI): Mr. Kumar Brijnandan, Advocate

For the Intervener: Mr. Sunil Thakur, Advocate

Nature of the Case: Writ petition under civil writ jurisdiction challenging rejection of candidature for Assistant Professor post and seeking direction to be called for interview.

Link to Judgment: Patna High Court Judgment in CWJC No. 604 of 2018

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News