Case Background
The dispute relates to a Khas Mahal land at Kadamkuan, Patna, being plot no. 52, Block-C, Halka no. 5, Thana no. 20A, admeasuring 5 katha 8 dhurs. The State of Bihar had settled this land in favour of one Sadashiv Prasad through a registered deed of perpetual lease dated 15.11.1942 (registered on 17.11.1942).
Under this lease, the lessee was given permanent rights “from generation to generation” with full rights of transfer of the land and all buildings and structures. No clause required prior permission of the State before transfer. After the death of Sadashiv Prasad and his wife Saraswati Devi in 1976, their heirs, including P.R. Prasad and his brothers, became owners and their names were mutated.
In 1980, the eldest daughter, Malti Devi, filed Title Suit No. 77 of 1980 before the Subordinate Judge, Patna, seeking partition of this Patna house and other ancestral properties at Buxar. She claimed 1/8th share. After her death, Ajit Kumar and his brothers were substituted as plaintiffs. During 1986–87, the ground floor of the Patna house was let out to M/s Atul Carrier for commercial use.
On enquiry, the authorities found the commercial use to be true. A proposal was mooted by the Collector for cancellation of the lease for breach of its terms, but a one-time relaxation was later given. Existing lessees were offered an option to take a fresh lease by paying penal rent and salami at market rate. P.R. Prasad wrote to the Collector on 18.09.2001 expressing willingness to enter into a fresh lease but objected to cancellation without notice or opportunity of hearing.
Respondent no. 3 (Ajit Kumar) then appeared before the Collector and accepted the proposal for fresh lease. Before matters could conclude, P.R. Prasad died in November 2001. Thereafter, his daughter, Ratee Prasad, for herself and on behalf of her mother, two uncles, two aunts and a cousin, executed a registered sale deed dated 27.12.2001 in favour of the present petitioner, on the strength of a power of attorney. Possession and all rights in the house/land were handed over to the petitioner.
Meanwhile, respondent no. 3 filed a petition before the Collector seeking a fresh lease in his favour. Case No. 4 of 2002 was registered. The petitioner applied to be made a party, but the Collector rejected his intervention on 20.11.2002. The petitioner challenged this in CWJC No. 244 of 2003. On 30.04.2003 the High Court set aside the Collector’s order and allowed the writ, resulting in the petitioner being impleaded in Case No. 4 of 2002.
On 28.02.2004 the Collector rejected the petitioner’s claim to be treated as lessee. Later, by order dated 02.08.2004 (communicated under Memo dated 31.07.2004), the Collector ordered resumption of the Khas Mahal land and directed that possession, along with any structures, be taken over by the Government, to be handed to the Circle Officer, Patna Sadar, within one month. The petitioner therefore filed CWJC No. 7445 of 2004 challenging the 28.02.2004 order, and CWJC No. 9593 of 2004 challenging the 02.08.2004 resumption order.
What the Court Examined and Decided
Justice Mohit Kumar Shah heard both writ petitions together because they involved the same land and connected orders. The core questions were: whether the petitioner’s purchase through the 27.12.2001 sale deed gave him valid rights under the original 1942 perpetual lease, and whether the Collector could treat the Mumbai-registered deed as invalid and resume possession by executive order.
The Collector’s 28.02.2004 order refused to recognize the petitioner as lessee on three main grounds:
- The heirs of late Sadashiv Prasad had transferred the leasehold interest to the petitioner without prior permission of the competent authority.
- Before transfer, the petitioner had not deposited an amount equal to 50% of the market value, allegedly required by government order.
- The transfer deed was executed and registered at Mumbai (Bombay), which was said to be not recognized by the Government of Bihar.
The petitioner attacked each ground. On the first ground, he relied on the clear language of the 15.11.1942 lease deed which granted perpetual, generational rights with “full rights of transfer” of the land and all buildings and structures. There was no clause requiring any prior permission from the State for sale or transfer. Therefore, the Collector could not impose such a requirement later through circulars.
On the second ground, concerning deposit of 50% of market value, the petitioner argued that this requirement did not appear anywhere in the original lease. The lease was a perpetual one with full transfer rights. Any later departmental circular could not override the contractual rights granted in 1942.
On the third ground, concerning registration at Mumbai, the petitioner’s case was more technical. Section 30(2) of the Registration Act, 1908 (before amendment) allowed the Registrar of a district including a presidency town such as Mumbai to receive and register documents relating to property situated anywhere in India. Central Act 48 of 2001 (The Registration and Other Related Laws (Amendment) Act, 2001) omitted Section 30(2), but the date from which this omission took effect depended on when each State brought the amendment into force.
The Inspector General of Registration and Controller of Stamps, Maharashtra, by letter dated 04.04.2002, stated that the Government of Maharashtra had enforced the 2001 Amendment Act with effect from 01.01.2002. As a result, Section 30(2) continued to be valid in Mumbai till 31.12.2001. Since the petitioner’s sale deed was executed and registered at Mumbai on 27.12.2001, Section 30(2) was still operative there on that date.
The petitioner also pointed out that “registration” is a subject in the Concurrent List under the Constitution. Parliament amended the central law in 2001 but left it to States to notify its enforcement. Maharashtra chose 01.01.2002 as the date, so the Mumbai registrar had full legal power to register the deed on 27.12.2001.
As to Bihar, the State had earlier passed the Registration (Bihar Amendment) Act, 1991 (Bihar Act 6 of 1991), effective from 08.08.1991, amending Section 28 and omitting Section 30(2) in its application to Bihar. The amended Section 28 required documents relating to land in Bihar to be presented in the office of the Sub-Registrar within whose sub-district or district the whole of the property is situated.
The petitioner argued that this State amendment could not invalidate registrations lawfully carried out in other States under the central law. He relied heavily on the judgment of the Delhi High Court in Gati Cargo Management Services vs. SBL Industries Limited, which had upheld sale deeds of property located in Ranchi (earlier part of Bihar) registered at Mumbai by invoking Section 30(2). That judgment also discussed Article 254 of the Constitution and held that a State amendment could not have extra-territorial effect and could not make such registrations void.
The petitioner further showed that the Government of Bihar, by notifications dated 18.07.2002 and 22.08.2002, had accepted the validity of deeds registered outside Bihar. These notifications only required payment of differential stamp duty. The petitioner produced a certificate of the District Sub-Registrar, Patna dated 29.10.2007 showing that he had deposited Rs. 1,82,500/- as the differential amount, which had been duly accepted.
Respondent no. 3 and the State defended the Collector’s order. Respondent no. 3 argued that:
- The 1942 lease prohibited commercial use, yet the premises had been used as a godown by M/s Atul Carrier. The Collector, after enquiry and notice, had rightly treated this as breach and cancelled the lease.
- The sale deed dated 27.12.2001 was, according to him, only an agreement and not an absolute sale deed, and it was registered at Mumbai contrary to the amended Registration Act and Bihar law.
- After the 2001 central amendment omitting Section 30(2), any sale deed for land in Bihar had to be registered in Bihar alone.
- He relied on the Patna High Court decision in Abhay Shankar Sinha vs. State of Bihar, 2009 (4) PLJR 454.
The State’s counsel supported the Collector, contending that after 08.08.1991 any sale or lease relating to land in Bihar, but registered outside Bihar, was void. On this basis, the petitioner was described as an encroacher liable to eviction.
After examining the records, the Patna High Court rejected all three grounds used by the Collector.
On the first ground, the Court closely read the 1942 lease and noted its express language granting full rights of transfer from generation to generation. There was no requirement of prior permission of any government authority. Therefore, the Collector’s insistence on prior permission was contrary to the contract itself and unsustainable.
On the second ground, the Court again relied on the lease terms. There was no clause saying that 50% of the market value must be deposited before transfer. Imposing such a condition later, without contractual or statutory support, was “nonest and contrary to law.”
On the third ground, the Court undertook a detailed statutory analysis. It reproduced Section 30(2) as it then stood and Section 28 as amended by Bihar Act 6 of 1991. It then noted the Maharashtra letter dated 04.04.2002 confirming that the 2001 central amendment came into force there only from 01.01.2002. Hence, on 27.12.2001, Section 30(2) was still in force in Mumbai, making the registration of the sale deed legally valid.
The Court also observed that original Section 28 of the Registration Act began with “Save as in this Part otherwise provided”, meaning it was subject to other provisions, including Section 30. Section 30(1) allowed “any Registrar” to register documents that could be registered by any Sub-Registrar subordinate to him. The phrase “any Registrar” was interpreted to include all registrars, not just those within Bihar.
The Court held that to the extent Bihar’s 1991 amendment to Section 28 conflicted with the central law (Sections 28 and 30 as then applicable in Maharashtra), it was repugnant under Article 254 of the Constitution and could not override registrations lawfully carried out under the central law in another State. Following the Delhi High Court’s ruling in Gati Cargo, the Patna High Court held that the Mumbai registration could not be treated as invalid merely because the property was in Bihar.
The Court also rejected respondent no. 3’s assertion that the 27.12.2001 document was only an agreement. On examining the document, the Court found it to be a registered sale deed. The earlier decision in Abhay Shankar Sinha was distinguished on facts because that case involved acquisition of interest in land “without any authority of law or permission of the competent authority”, whereas here the 1942 lease itself permitted transfer without permission.
Turning to the second writ petition, the Court addressed the Collector’s order dated 02.08.2004 directing resumption of possession of the Khas Mahal land and structures. Since the foundational 28.02.2004 order had been quashed, the resumption order naturally “had no legs to stand.”
Additionally, the Court relied on its earlier judgment in Uday Sinha and others vs. State of Bihar & others (CWJC No. 9720 of 2001, decided 24.03.2021). In that case, similar orders by the Collector, Patna cancelling Khas Mahal leases and ordering resumption were quashed. The Court had held that leasehold rights, especially perpetual leases, create vested legal rights and that resumption of possession can only be done through due process of law by approaching a civil court, not by unilateral executive orders. It had also referred to decisions such as Shri Sanjay Singh vs. Patna Municipal Corporation, Khas Mahal Citizen Welfare Society vs. State of Bihar, Gait Public Library & Institute vs. State of Bihar, and Supreme Court judgments like Express Newspapers (P) Ltd. vs. Union of India.
Applying that settled law, the Court held that the Collector’s 02.08.2004 order, which cancelled the lease and ordered taking possession without civil court proceedings, was contrary to law and liable to be quashed.
In the result, the Patna High Court allowed both writ petitions. It quashed the Collector’s orders dated 28.02.2004 and 02.08.2004. However, it granted liberty to the Collector, Patna to proceed further in accordance with law, if so advised. This means that any future attempt to cancel the lease or recover possession must strictly follow proper legal procedure and respect the rights flowing from the 1942 perpetual lease and the valid 2001 sale deed.
Why This Judgment Matters
This decision is important for anyone dealing with Khas Mahal properties and long-standing government leases in Bihar. The Patna High Court has made it clear that:
- Perpetual Khas Mahal leases with clear transfer rights cannot be cut down by later circulars or unilateral decisions of officers.
- If a lease allows transfer without permission, the Collector cannot insist on prior approval or additional payments not found in the lease itself.
- Sale deeds for Bihar property registered in other States, like Maharashtra, can be valid if registered at a time when the central law allowed such registration and if the other State had not yet enforced the amendment removing that power.
- Government cannot simply issue an order to cancel leases and take back possession. Even the State must go to civil court and follow due process to evict a lessee or his transferee.
For ordinary citizens, this judgment gives reassurance that once a valid lease and sale deed exist, officials cannot label them encroachers overnight through administrative orders. Any dispute over breach of lease conditions or title must be decided by the proper court, after hearing all parties.
Legal Issues and Answers
-
Issue: Could the Collector treat the 27.12.2001 sale deed, registered at Mumbai for a Khas Mahal land in Patna, as invalid and deny the purchaser’s rights as lessee?
Answer: No. The Court held that on 27.12.2001 Section 30(2) of the Registration Act was still in force in Maharashtra, so the Mumbai registration was legal and valid. Bihar’s amendment could not make such a deed void, and the State itself had recognized out-of-State registrations on payment of differential stamp duty. -
Issue: Did the original 1942 Khas Mahal lease require prior permission of the State or deposit of 50% of market value before transfer to the petitioner?
Answer: No. The lease expressly granted perpetual, generational rights with full power of transfer. There was no clause mandating prior permission or such deposits. The Collector’s reliance on later circulars to impose these conditions was contrary to the lease and unsustainable. -
Issue: Could the Collector, by executive order dated 02.08.2004, cancel the lease and unilaterally resume possession of the land and structures?
Answer: No. Following earlier judgments, the Court held that cancellation of lease and resumption of possession must be done through due process by approaching the competent civil court. The resumption order was therefore quashed.
Cases Cited by the Court
- Gati Cargo Management Services vs. SBL Industries Limited, 2014 SCC OnLine Del 3297 (Delhi High Court).
- Abhay Shankar Sinha vs. State of Bihar & Ors., 2009 (4) PLJR 454 (Patna High Court) – distinguished.
- Uday Sinha and others vs. State of Bihar & others, CWJC No. 9720 of 2001, judgment dated 24.03.2021 (Patna High Court).
- Shri Sanjay Singh vs. Patna Municipal Corporation, 2021 (1) BLJ 5 (Patna High Court).
- Khas Mahal Citizen Welfare Society vs. State of Bihar & Ors., 2016 (1) PLJR 277 (Patna High Court); affirmed in 2017 (3) PLJR 662 and 2019 (1) PLJR 628 (SC).
- Gait Public Library & Institute vs. State of Bihar & Ors., 1995 (1) PLJR 585 (Patna High Court).
- Supreme Court decisions referred to in the extracted passages, including Express Newspapers (P) Ltd. vs. Union of India, (1986) 1 SCC 133; Lallu Yeshwant Singh vs. Rao Jagdish Singh, AIR 1968 SC 620; Krishna Ram Mahale vs. Shobha Venkat Rao, AIR 1989 SC 2097; and State of U.P. vs. Maharaja Dharmander Prasad Singh, AIR 1989 SC 997.
Case Details
Case Numbers: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 7445 of 2004; Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 9593 of 2004.
Case Title: Ashok Kumar vs. The State of Bihar & Ors.
Citation: 2022 (4) PLJR 871.
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Mohit Kumar Shah.
Date of Judgment: 19.09.2022.
Advocates:
- For the petitioner (CWJC No. 7445 of 2004): Mr. Ajit Kumar Sinha, Senior Advocate; Ms. Nivedita Nirvikar, Senior Advocate.
- For respondent no. 3: Mr. Natraj Verma, Advocate.
- For the State (both cases): Mr. Shankar Kumar Thakur, AC to GP-27.
- For the petitioner (CWJC No. 9593 of 2004): Ms. Nivedita Nirvikar, Senior Advocate.
Nature of the Case: Writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging orders of the Collector, Patna, refusing to recognize the petitioner as lessee of Khas Mahal land and directing cancellation of lease and resumption of possession.
Link to Judgment: Patna High Court Judgment in CWJC No. 7445 of 2004 & CWJC No. 9593 of 2004
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



