Dispute over Raxaul vegetable market shops resolved — Patna High Court, 2026

Shubham Shivansh

Reviewed by: Shubham Shivansh

License Number: D/7102/2022

Last Reviewed On: 29-09-2026

Shubham Shivansh is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in civil disputes, service law, and GST matters. He represents clients in property disputes, contractual disagreements, service-related grievances, and tax compliance matters before the Patna High Court and other jurisdictions. His practice handles civil litigation, employment-related disputes, and regulatory matters for individuals and businesses across Bihar.

Two sets of shop claimants at Raxaul Sabzi Bazar challenged Nagar Parishad decisions. The Patna High Court upheld eviction of one set of occupants and protected the contractual allottee. The illegal occupants have four weeks to vacate the shops. After that, the Nagar Parishad must hand over shop no. 37 to the recognised allottee and refund excess rent.

Case Background

The dispute concerns shop shed nos. 37 and 38 at Sabzi Bazar, Raxaul, under Nagar Parishad, Raxaul in East Champaran district.

One side consists of Prem Chandra Prasad and his family. They say their father and grandfather had been doing business for a long time on Nagar Parishad land. When the Nagar Parishad decided to construct shops, Prem Chandra claims to have deposited Rs. 10,000 as cost of a shop on 12.12.1996 and received a money receipt. However, no formal allotment order was ever issued in their favour.

Over the years, Prem Chandra and his family continued doing business from sheds near shop nos. 37 and 38. They relied on the 1996 deposit and later correspondence to claim that these two shops should be allotted to them. They also say they submitted agreement papers on stamp papers dated 02.02.2017 but no registered lease was executed.

They earlier approached the Patna High Court in CWJC No. 440 of 2020. On 31.07.2023, the Court directed them to file a proper representation before Nagar Parishad, Raxaul, and directed the Nagar Parishad to decide that representation within three months.

Pursuant to this direction, they filed a representation. The Nagar Parishad heard the matter and, by order dated 19.12.2023, held their occupation of shed nos. 37 and 38 to be illegal and directed them to vacate within seven days. On 21.12.2023, notices bearing nos. 469 and 470 were issued asking them to vacate the sheds.

Feeling aggrieved, Prem Chandra and his father filed CWJC No. 4644 of 2024 challenging this order and the eviction notices. They also sought a direction to allot the shops to them and to open locks which they alleged had been put on the shops without court orders.

The other side is Surendra Prasad. He had applied for allotment of a shop at Sabzi Bazar, Raxaul for his livelihood. After applications were invited and the procedure followed, shop no. 37 was formally settled in his favour. An agreement dated 14.05.2013 was executed between him and the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Raxaul.

This agreement clearly covered shop no. 37 for the period from 01.09.2012 to 31.08.2027, with monthly rent of Rs. 350. Surendra Prasad, however, was never given vacant possession. According to him, the shop continued in illegal occupation of Prem Chandra Prasad.

Despite not having possession, Surendra continued to deposit rent of Rs. 350 per month as per the agreement. When the Nagar Parishad still did not give him the shop, he approached the Patna High Court in CWJC No. 3142 of 2026 seeking a writ of mandamus to hand over vacant possession of shop no. 37.

What the Court Examined and Decided

Hon’ble Mr. Justice Partha Sarthy heard both writ petitions together, as they concerned the same shops (nos. 37 and 38 at Sabzi Bazar, Raxaul) and overlapped on facts and parties.

In the petition filed by Prem Chandra Prasad and his father (CWJC No. 4644 of 2024), the Court noted their main claims:

First, they relied on a deposit of Rs. 10,000 allegedly made on 12.12.1996 towards the cost of a shop and the money receipt issued by the Nagar Parishad. They argued that this deposit entitled them to allotment of shop nos. 37 and 38.

Second, they stated that they had long been in physical possession of shed nos. 37 and 38 and were doing business from there. They claimed they had submitted agreement papers on stamp papers (no. 4854 and 4855 dated 02.02.2017) for lease in their names, but the Nagar Parishad failed to execute the lease despite its own board resolution.

Third, they challenged the Nagar Parishad’s order dated 19.12.2023, passed after the earlier High Court order in CWJC No. 440 of 2020, as being illegal. They also challenged the eviction notices dated 21.12.2023 and sought protection from dispossession.

On the other hand, in Surendra Prasad’s petition (CWJC No. 3142 of 2026), the claim was built around a formal, written agreement. The Court recorded that Surendra had applied for allotment of a shop at Sabzi Bazar, Raxaul. After inviting applications and following the due procedure, Nagar Parishad, Raxaul allotted shop no. 37 to him.

An agreement dated 14.05.2013 was signed between the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, and Surendra Prasad. This agreement was effective from 01.09.2012 to 31.08.2027 and fixed monthly rent at Rs. 350. These facts were not only asserted by Surendra but also admitted by the Nagar Parishad in its counter affidavit, specifically in paragraph 3(h).

The Court also took note that the Nagar Parishad did not dispute Surendra Prasad’s assertion that he had regularly deposited monthly rent of Rs. 350 throughout this period, even though the shop remained under the occupation of Prem Chandra.

Regarding the petition by Prem Chandra and his father, the Court examined the stand of Nagar Parishad given in its counter affidavit in CWJC No. 4644 of 2024. It recorded that:

The representation filed in compliance with the earlier High Court order was taken up by the Nagar Parishad on 19.12.2023. They were given time to produce documents supporting their claim to the shops. Despite repeated adjournments, they did not appear before the authority or produce any such documents.

On the materials available, the Nagar Parishad came to the conclusion that the occupation of shed nos. 37 and 38 by Prem Chandra and Ramdev Sah was illegal. Accordingly, it directed them to vacate the sheds within seven days and issued eviction notices pursuant to this order.

After hearing both sides and considering the pleadings and documents, the Patna High Court found no illegality in this order of 19.12.2023. The Court observed that there was no allotment order in favour of Prem Chandra or his brother.

The only basis of their claim was the alleged deposit of Rs. 10,000 back in 1996 and continued possession of the sheds. That, in the Court’s view, could not override the clear contractual allotment and documented agreement in favour of Surendra Prasad.

Therefore, CWJC No. 4644 of 2024, filed by Prem Chandra and his father, was held to be devoid of merit and was dismissed.

At the same time, the Court gave them a short breathing period. It granted four weeks’ time to vacate shed nos. 37 and 38 voluntarily. If they failed to do so, the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Raxaul (respondent no. 2 in that case) was authorised to get the premises vacated with the assistance of force, if required.

To ensure the order is effectively implemented, the Court directed the District Magistrate, East Champaran, and the Superintendent of Police, East Champaran, to provide all necessary assistance to the Executive Officer for vacating the premises. It further ordered that any cost incurred for this process could be recovered from the petitioners of CWJC No. 4644 of 2024 under the Bihar and Orissa Public Demands Recovery Act, 1914.

Turning to Surendra Prasad’s writ petition (CWJC No. 3142 of 2026), the Court focused on two admitted facts:

One, the existence of the valid agreement dated 14.05.2013 for shop no. 37 in his favour, covering the period 01.09.2012 to 31.08.2027 at a monthly rent of Rs. 350, as admitted by the Nagar Parishad itself.

Two, the undisputed fact that Surendra had been regularly depositing rent of Rs. 350 per month since 01.09.2012, even though he never got physical possession due to occupation by Prem Chandra.

In this backdrop, the Court granted Surendra effective relief. It directed that once shop/shed no. 37 is vacated by respondent no. 5 (Prem Chandra), the Nagar Parishad must immediately hand over possession to Surendra Prasad. He is entitled to occupy the shop as per the agreement dated 14.05.2013 till 31.08.2027.

Recognising that Surendra had been paying rent without receiving the benefit of possession, the Court also protected him financially. It ordered that the rent of Rs. 350 per month deposited by him from 01.09.2012 up to the date of handing over vacant possession must be refunded by Nagar Parishad within three months.

The Court clarified that the refund should be calculated only for complete months, and no amount would be payable for part of any month.

With these directions, CWJC No. 3142 of 2026 filed by Surendra Prasad was allowed. Both writ petitions were thus finally disposed of by the common judgment dated 19.06.2026.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is important for small traders and shopkeepers who deal with municipal bodies for shop allotments in markets.

First, the Patna High Court has clearly held that mere long possession and an old deposit without a formal allotment order do not give a legal right to a municipal shop. The Court treated continued occupation without allotment as illegal.

Second, the Court has shown that a person with a proper written agreement from the Nagar Parishad, and who pays rent regularly, will be protected. Surendra Prasad did not have possession for years, but because his agreement and rent payments were admitted, the Court compelled the Nagar Parishad to honour its commitment.

Third, the Court has backed the Nagar Parishad’s right to evict unauthorised occupants and has given concrete directions to the District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police to assist. Recovery of eviction costs as public demand is also a strong signal that unauthorised occupation of municipal property can become expensive.

For traders in Bihar, especially those in Nagar Parishad markets, the message is clear: insist on proper allotment orders and agreements, keep rent receipts safe, and do not rely only on old deposits or informal arrangements.

Legal Issues and Answers

  • Issue: Can long-time occupants of municipal shop sheds, relying on an old deposit and alleged expectation of allotment, resist eviction when there is no formal allotment order in their favour?
    Answer: No. The Court upheld the Nagar Parishad’s order declaring their occupation illegal and permitted eviction with police assistance.
  • Issue: What are the rights of a person who has a valid written agreement with the Nagar Parishad for a shop but has never been given possession, despite regularly paying rent?
    Answer: Such a person is entitled to immediate possession of the shop as per the agreement and to refund of rent for the period during which possession was not given.
  • Issue: Can the cost of enforcing eviction from Nagar Parishad shops be recovered from illegal occupants as public demand?
    Answer: Yes. The Court authorised recovery of such costs under the Bihar and Orissa Public Demands Recovery Act, 1914.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • No earlier judgments or case law have been cited or relied upon in the text of this judgment.

Case Details

Case Numbers: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 3142 of 2026; Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 4644 of 2024

Case Titles: Surendra Prasad v. The State of Bihar & Ors; Prem Chandra Prasad & Anr v. The State of Bihar & Ors

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Partha Sarthy

Citation: 2026 (4) PLJR 401

Advocates in CWJC No. 3142 of 2026: For the petitioner: Mr. Subodh Prasad, Advocate. For the State: Mr. Rajesh Kr. Sinha, AC to GP-23. For Respondent no. 3: Mr. Devi Das Srivastava, Advocate. For Respondent no. 5: Mr. Md. Shahnawaz Ali, Advocate.

Advocates in CWJC No. 4644 of 2024: For the petitioners: Mr. Md. Shahnawaz Ali, Advocate. For the State: Mr. Sudhir Kumar Upadhayay, AC to GP-7. For the Zila Parishad: Mr. Devi Das Srivastava, Advocate.

Nature of the Cases: Writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, challenging municipal eviction notices and seeking enforcement of shop allotment agreement.

Date of Judgment: 19.06.2026

C.A.V. Date: 12.05.2026

Link: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MTUjMzE0MiMyMDI2IzEjTg==-c–am1–hM34vRA6E=

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News