Case Background
The petitioner was appointed as a Junior Engineer in the Road Construction Department in 1991. He was posted in the Building Division, Supaul.
On 29.08.2006, a departmental proceeding was initiated against him through a charge memo. This enquiry ended with an order of dismissal from service on 31.01.2008.
The petitioner’s departmental appeal against dismissal failed. He then approached the Patna High Court in C.W.J.C. No. 13984 of 2008, challenging both the dismissal order and the appellate order.
On 27.06.2018, a Bench of the Patna High Court set aside the dismissal as well as the appellate order. The State of Bihar filed L.P.A. No. 371 of 2019 against this decision. The Letters Patent Appeal was dismissed, though liberty was given to the State to start a fresh proceeding from the stage of charge-sheet and evidence.
Following the High Court’s orders, the petitioner was reinstated in service. The period between dismissal and reinstatement was treated as duty, and he was paid full salary for that time.
Despite reinstatement, his claim for financial upgradation under the Assured Career Progression (ACP) and Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP) schemes was not considered. He sought 1st ACP from 18.04.2003, 2nd MACP from 18.04.2011 and 3rd MACP from 18.04.2021.
Since the department did not act, the petitioner filed C.W.J.C. No. 7947 of 2023 before the Patna High Court seeking ACP/MACP benefits.
What the Court Examined and Decided
While C.W.J.C. No. 7947 of 2023 was pending, the department continued the disciplinary proceedings. This culminated in a penalty order dated 25.04.2023.
Under this order, the petitioner’s pay was reduced to a lower stage in the time scale for two years with cumulative effect. This meant the impact of the penalty would continue even after the two-year period, by lowering his future pay progression.
Later, C.W.J.C. No. 7947 of 2023 was disposed of. The High Court directed the Engineer-in-Chief, Road Construction Department, to consider the petitioner’s case for 1st ACP, 2nd MACP and 3rd MACP and pass an appropriate order. The Court clearly held that non-availability of vigilance clearance could not be used as a ground to avoid considering ACP/MACP.
Acting on this direction, the petitioner submitted a detailed representation. However, the Engineer-in-Chief-cum-Additional Commissioner-cum-Special Secretary (Headquarter) rejected his claim by order dated 28.12.2023.
The rejection was based on two main grounds. First, that a certificate proceeding was pending for recovery of alleged public money of Rs. 14,53,827/-. Second, that the petitioner was under the punishment of reduction in pay for two years with cumulative effect.
Aggrieved by this order, the petitioner filed the present writ petition, C.W.J.C. No. 10597 of 2025, before the Patna High Court.
On behalf of the petitioner, it was argued that the very certificate proceeding cited against him had already been found illegal by the High Court. The District Certificate Officer’s order in Certificate Case No. 406 of 2019 had been challenged in Appeal No. 01 of 2022, which was dismissed by the District Collector.
Both these orders were later questioned before the High Court in C.W.J.C. No. 14400 of 2023. After consideration, the Court held that Certificate Case No. 406 of 2019 was barred by limitation and without jurisdiction.
The Court in that earlier writ had further found that the sum sought to be recovered did not fall within the meaning of “public demand” under Section 3(6) of the Bihar & Orissa Public Demands Recovery Act, 1914. As a result, both the order of the Certificate Officer and the appellate order were quashed and cancelled.
Relying on this, the petitioner argued in the present case that there was now no pending and valid certificate case and thus no bar to his ACP/MACP benefits.
The petitioner’s counsel also referred to letter no. 2910 dated 28.02.2022 issued by the Department of General Administration. This document clarified that if an employee becomes entitled to promotion or ACP benefits prior to the date from which punishment operates, that punishment cannot affect the benefits already accrued.
Applying this to his own case, the petitioner submitted that his 3rd MACP fell due on 18.04.2021, whereas the penalty order was passed much later, on 25.04.2023. Therefore, the punishment could not legally block his entitlement to the third MACP, or to earlier benefits from 2003 and 2011.
For the State, it was argued that the petitioner had not been granted ACP/MACP mainly because his vigilance clearance report was adverse. It was also contended that, at the relevant time, a certificate case was pending and hence the claim was rightly rejected.
Justice Harish Kumar examined the submissions and the record. He first noted that there was, in fact, no certificate case now in existence.
This was because the Patna High Court, in C.W.J.C. No. 14400 of 2023, had already quashed and cancelled both the order in Certificate Case No. 406 of 2019 and the appellate order. Therefore, the first ground used in the order dated 28.12.2023 no longer survived.
The Court next considered whether the punishment order could defeat the petitioner’s ACP/MACP claims. It observed that the petitioner had acquired his entitlement to these benefits much before the penalty order was passed.
Specifically, the 1st ACP was claimed from 18.04.2003, the 2nd MACP from 18.04.2011, and the 3rd MACP from 18.04.2021. Each of these dates preceded 25.04.2023, the date on which the reduction in pay was ordered.
The Court held that these entitlements amounted to vested rights. A vested right, it explained, cannot be taken away unless the later order is specifically made retrospective either by clear words or necessary implication.
Since there was nothing to show that the penalty order was retrospective in nature, it could not affect benefits which had already accrued before 25.04.2023.
On this reasoning, the Court found that the second objection relied upon by the departmental authorities was also unsustainable. The penalty could not cause any “eclipse” over the petitioner’s entitlement to ACP/MACP.
The issue of vigilance clearance had already been addressed in the earlier writ, where the Court had stated that lack of vigilance clearance could not be used to refuse consideration of ACP/MACP. The present order follows that line, focusing on the legality of the grounds actually cited in the rejection order.
In conclusion, the Court held that the rejection order dated 28.12.2023 was liable to be set aside. It directed respondent no. 2, the Engineer-in-Chief-cum-Additional Commissioner-cum-Special Secretary (Headquarter), Road Construction Department, to reconsider the petitioner’s claim.
The authority was specifically directed to extend the benefit of 1st ACP from 18.04.2003, 2nd MACP from 18.04.2011 and 3rd MACP from 18.04.2021. The Court further instructed that all consequential benefits be ensured in accordance with law.
The entire exercise is to be completed preferably within 12 weeks from the date the order is received or produced before the authority. To this extent, the writ petition was allowed.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is important for government employees in Bihar who have faced long disciplinary battles and reinstatement.
First, it confirms that once a certificate proceeding is quashed as illegal, the department cannot continue to rely on it to deny service benefits. Authorities must keep their records updated and cannot hold a dead case over an employee’s head.
Second, the Patna High Court has clearly recognised that ACP/MACP benefits, once due on a particular date, create a vested right. A later punishment cannot automatically wipe out those rights unless the order clearly says it will work backward in time.
For employees, especially junior engineers and other staff in the Road Construction Department and similar departments, this order shows that financial progression benefits cannot be blocked on vague grounds like pending recovery or general vigilance objections when those grounds do not legally exist.
For departments, it serves as a reminder that denial of ACP/MACP must be based on sound legal reasons. Otherwise, courts are willing to intervene and protect the rights of employees.
Legal Issues and Answers
- Issue: Could the department deny ACP/MACP benefits on the basis of a certificate case that had been initiated for recovery of alleged public money?
Answer: No. The Court held that since the certificate case and the appellate order had already been quashed in C.W.J.C. No. 14400 of 2023, there was no existing certificate case. That ground could not be used to deny benefits. - Issue: Could a punishment order dated 25.04.2023, reducing pay for two years with cumulative effect, prevent grant of ACP/MACP benefits that had fallen due earlier (in 2003, 2011 and 2021)?
Answer: No. The Court held that the petitioner had acquired a vested right to ACP/MACP before the punishment. Such vested rights cannot be taken away unless the punishment order is made retrospective, which it was not. - Issue: What relief was the petitioner entitled to regarding ACP/MACP benefits?
Answer: The Court set aside the order dated 28.12.2023 and directed respondent no. 2 to grant 1st ACP with effect from 18.04.2003, 2nd MACP with effect from 18.04.2011 and 3rd MACP with effect from 18.04.2021, along with consequential benefits, within 12 weeks.
Cases Cited by the Court
- The judgment refers to earlier proceedings involving the parties: C.W.J.C. No. 13984 of 2008, L.P.A. No. 371 of 2019, C.W.J.C. No. 7947 of 2023 and C.W.J.C. No. 14400 of 2023. No external case law citations are mentioned.
Case Details
Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 10597 of 2025
Case Title: Manoj Kumar Ranjan v. The State of Bihar & Ors.
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Harish Kumar
Advocates: Mr. Rupak Kumar, Advocate for the petitioner; Ms. Jahanara, Advocate for the respondents
Nature of the Case: Writ petition under civil writ jurisdiction challenging rejection of ACP/MACP benefits and seeking consequential service benefits
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



