Dismissal of Nazir Set Aside, Back Wages Restored — Patna High Court, 2022

Abhishek Kumar

Reviewed by: Abhishek Kumar

License Number: BR/1810/2019

Last Reviewed On: 12-08-2026

Abhishek Kumar is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing in GST and Income Tax matters. He represents clients before the Patna High Court and other jurisdictions in tax disputes and regulatory compliance issues. His practice handles tax assessment proceedings, GST-related matters, and commercial disputes for businesses and individuals across Bihar and surrounding regions.

In this case, a court staff member challenged his dismissal from service. The Patna High Court upheld the Single Judge’s decision to cancel his dismissal. The Court held that negligence and bribery charges were not proved on evidence. The employee will get full back wages, including for the suspension period.

Case Background

The matter arose out of a departmental proceeding against a Nazir In-charge posted at the Civil Court, Sadar, Bhagalpur. He was responsible for executing writs issued by the civil court, including writs for delivery of possession in execution cases.

On 14.12.2003, he received a writ from the Court of Munsif-II, Bhagalpur, in Title Execution Case No. 17 of 1999. The writ required him to deliver possession of a shop in favour of the decree-holder.

Later, a complaint was made on behalf of the decree-holder accusing the Nazir of not executing the writ properly and of trying to defeat the decree for extraneous consideration. On this basis, the High Court administration initiated a departmental enquiry.

The Registrar, Civil Court, Bhagalpur, was appointed as Enquiry Officer. He found the Nazir negligent in duty, but did not find any evidence that he demanded, or caused others to demand, a bribe for executing the writ.

Despite the partial exoneration, the Disciplinary Authority held the Nazir guilty of negligence and ordered his dismissal from service. The Appellate Authority confirmed the dismissal.

The dismissed employee then filed Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 13158 of 2006 before a learned Single Judge of the Patna High Court. The Single Judge set aside the dismissal, held the findings of negligence to be perverse, and directed payment of full back wages in view of his superannuation.

Aggrieved, the High Court through its Registrar (Administration), along with the District Judge and the Enquiry Officer, filed Letters Patent Appeal No. 78 of 2021 before a Division Bench. There was a delay in filing the appeal, which the Bench condoned by allowing Interlocutory Application No. 2 of 2021.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The Division Bench heard the appeal filed by the High Court administration against the Single Judge’s order. The central question was whether the departmental finding of negligence and the extreme punishment of dismissal could stand, and whether the direction to pay full back wages was justified.

The bench first noted the exact allegations framed in the departmental charge-sheet. Charge No. 1 stated that, as Nazir In-charge, the employee negligently and carelessly failed to make proper arrangements of police force for delivering possession of the shop in favour of the decree-holder. It further alleged that this was done with intent to defeat the writ and that he submitted a false report for extraneous consideration.

Charge No. 2 alleged that, at his instance, three peons of the Civil Court, Sadar, Bhagalpur, demanded a bribe of Rs. 20,000/- from the decree-holder for effecting delivery of possession.

The Enquiry Officer concluded that negligence was proved, but the bribery charge was not. There was no evidence to show that he had asked the peons to demand money.

The Disciplinary Authority accepted that there was no proof of bribe demand but held the Nazir’s negligence to be grave, particularly because he was responsible for executing court writs. On this basis, he was dismissed from service. The Appellate Authority agreed.

Before the Single Judge, the employee argued that once the allegation of bribe or extraneous consideration was held not proved, there was no motive left to connect him with any deliberate attempt to avoid execution of the decree. He submitted that he had indeed taken steps to arrange police force and an Executive Magistrate.

He relied on the order dated 22.11.2003 passed by the learned Munsif-II, Bhagalpur, directing delivery of possession with a returnable date of 20.12.2003. He stated that he received authorization on 02.12.2003. A letter was sent on 09.12.2003 to the Superintendent of Police, Bhagalpur, requisitioning police force, and this was transmitted to the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Bhagalpur. By order dated 13.12.2003, an Executive Magistrate was deputed to assist in the process along with police force.

According to the employee, on 20.12.2003 the parties marked their attendance before the Munsif Court and the matter was adjourned to 17.01.2004. However, on the basis of an earlier communication dated 14.12.2003, it was reported that neither the decree-holder nor his representative were present on the spot and that police force was also not available, though the Executive Magistrate was present. In such a situation, delivery of possession could not be carried out.

The Single Judge found that the letters requisitioning police force and the deputation of the Executive Magistrate, coupled with the Executive Magistrate’s own endorsement that possession could not be delivered for want of police force, clearly showed that there was no criminal negligence on the part of the Nazir.

On this material, the Single Judge concluded that the finding of negligence was perverse and unsupported by evidence. Since the charge of demanding bribe had already failed, there was no basis to assume that he had acted negligently for some extraneous reason. The learned Judge therefore set aside the orders of the Disciplinary and Appellate Authorities and directed that full back wages be paid, placing reliance on Deepali Gundu Surwase vs. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya & Ors., (2013) 10 SCC 324.

In the Letters Patent Appeal, counsel for the appellants raised several objections. He argued that Charge No. 1 was independent of Charge No. 2 and did not fall merely because the bribery allegation failed. According to him, Charge No. 1 contained two distinct parts: first, negligence in not arranging police force, and second, submitting a false report to deflect the course of justice.

To support this, he referred to the report submitted by the Nazir after the failed attempt at execution. In that report, the Nazir wrote that no police force was present, and that the decree-holder and his clerk were not there. He also mentioned that he had learnt the decree-holder had gone to Patna for medical treatment. Further, he had inquired at the spot and was told that no shop of one “Bibi Nargis” existed and that the shop had been run for forty to fifty years by the sons of another person. This, according to the appellant, was an unwarranted endorsement on the execution writ.

The appellants contended that, under Section 49 of the Civil Courts Rules concerning process service, only necessary endorsements should be made, and that there was no need to issue a separate elaborate report. They submitted that this conduct showed an intention to create a false record about identification of the property and thus justified the finding of misconduct.

The appellants further argued that the Single Judge wrongly applied labour law principles regarding full back wages. They relied on Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code, which requires the competent authority, on reinstatement, to consider what pay and allowances are to be given for the period of absence and whether that period will count as duty. They also argued that courts now generally require proof that an employee was not gainfully employed elsewhere before awarding full back wages, and no such pleading or evidence existed in this case.

On the other side, counsel for the employee highlighted the communications requisitioning police force and deputing the Executive Magistrate. He pointed out that the Magistrate did attend the spot on the scheduled date, which would not have been possible if the Nazir had not performed his part. He stressed that the enquiry report itself recognized the absence of any bribery attempt. Without any motive or extraneous consideration, it was illogical to hold that the Nazir deliberately failed to execute the decree.

He accepted that there might have been some lapse in not informing the decree-holder and judgment-debtor before going for execution, but argued that such lapse did not amount to criminal negligence. As to the alleged “false report”, he submitted that the charge-sheet did not clearly frame a separate charge of submitting a false report about property identification. Reading an “invisible” charge into Charge No. 1 would be unfair and contrary to service law principles.

The Division Bench examined the rival submissions and the record. It agreed with the Single Judge that there was nothing to dispute the fact that the Nazir had made arrangements for police force and an Executive Magistrate on the date fixed for delivery of possession.

The Bench observed that the additional comments in the Nazir’s report about difficulty in identifying the property were unwarranted, but they could reasonably be read only as part of explaining why possession was not delivered that day. To treat those comments as a deliberate attempt to create false evidence or to cast doubt on the civil court decree would be “too much”. If such a serious allegation had truly been intended, it should have been framed as a clear, separate charge so that the employee could defend himself.

On the aspect of back wages, the Bench held that once the termination was found to be “wholly unjustified”, the natural consequence was to treat the entire period of non-employment as if the employee had been in service. The employer had not placed any material or even raised a discussion about the employee’s gainful employment elsewhere during that period. In this background, the Single Judge’s direction for full back wages, including for the period of suspension, could not be faulted.

Ultimately, the Division Bench found no reason to interfere with the Single Judge’s findings. It dismissed the Letters Patent Appeal, without any order as to costs, and clarified that the employee would be entitled to full wages even for the suspension period pending departmental proceedings.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment of the Patna High Court is important for government and court employees facing departmental enquiries, especially where they are accused of negligence in executing court orders.

First, it shows that departmental findings must be supported by clear evidence. If a serious allegation like bribery is not proved, the authorities cannot indirectly punish an employee by labelling routine lapses as criminal negligence without solid proof.

Second, the Court stressed that charges must be clearly framed. An employee cannot be punished for an “invisible” or implied charge that was never expressly put to him during enquiry. If the department thinks a report is false or misleading, that must be a specific charge.

Third, on back wages, the judgment underlines that where dismissal is found to be wholly unjustified and unsupported by evidence, reinstatement or restitution with full back wages is the normal rule, unless the employer shows that the employee was gainfully employed elsewhere.

For ordinary litigants, especially decree-holders waiting for execution, the ruling also clarifies that occasional failure to execute a writ on the first date does not automatically mean that the staff is acting dishonestly. Each case has to be judged on real evidence, not assumptions.

Legal Issues and Answers


  • Issue: Whether the finding of negligence and submission of a false report by the Nazir in executing the writ of delivery of possession was sustainable on the evidence on record.

    Answer: No. The Patna High Court held that the finding was perverse and based on no cogent evidence, especially in view of documents showing requisition of police force and presence of an Executive Magistrate, and the absence of any proof of extraneous consideration.

  • Issue: Whether the learned Single Judge was justified in setting aside the dismissal and granting full back wages till superannuation.

    Answer: Yes. Once the termination was found to be wholly unjustified, the Court endorsed the Single Judge’s direction to treat the entire period, including suspension, as time in service and to pay full back wages, there being no material from the employer about gainful employment elsewhere.

  • Issue: Whether Charge No. 1 could be split to include an additional, unstated allegation of deliberately creating a false record about property identification.

    Answer: No. The Court held that such an interpretation would amount to introducing a new, “invisible” charge that was never formally put to the employee and therefore could not form the basis of punishment.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • B.C. Chaturvedi vs. Union of India & Ors., (1995) 6 SCC 749
  • Union of India vs. H.C. Goel, AIR 1964 Supreme Court 364
  • Lalit Popli vs. Canara Bank & Ors., (2003) 3 SCC 583
  • M.V. Bijlani vs. Union of India & Ors., (2006) 5 SCC 88
  • Union of India & Ors. vs. P. Gunasekaran, (2015) 2 SCC 610
  • Deepali Gundu Surwase vs. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya & Ors., (2013) 10 SCC 324

Case Details

Case Number: Letters Patent Appeal No. 78 of 2021 in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 13158 of 2006

Case Title: Hon’ble High Court of Judicature at Patna & Ors. vs. Ajit Kumar Mishra & Anr.

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ashutosh Kumar and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Anjani Kumar Sharan

Date of Judgment: 16-05-2022

Citation: 2022 (3) PLJR 196

Advocates: Mr. Piyush Lall, Advocate for the appellants; Mr. J.S. Arora, Senior Advocate for respondent no. 1; Mr. Saroj Kumar Sharma, AC to AAG-3 for the State (respondent no. 2)

Nature of the Case: Letters Patent Appeal against the order of a Single Judge allowing a writ petition challenging dismissal from service in a departmental proceeding.

Link to Judgment: Click here to read the full judgment of the Patna High Court

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News