Case Background
The petitioner is a medical doctor who applied for the post of General Medical Officer under the Bihar Health Services.
The Bihar Technical Service Commission issued Advertisement No. 17 of 2021 for appointment of General Medical Officers. There were 2632 vacant posts. The petitioner applied under the Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category.
On 23.08.2021, the Commission recommended her name for appointment. Acting on this recommendation, the Health Department, Government of Bihar, issued a letter of appointment dated 02.09.2021.
In this appointment notification, the petitioner’s name appeared at serial number 425. She was posted as a General Medical Officer at the Additional Primary Health Centre, Dhabauli, Block Bidupur, District Vaishali.
However, within a short time of these recommendations, objections started coming in from other candidates regarding the correctness of the result under Advertisement No. 17 of 2021.
On 30.11.2021, the Deputy Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar, issued Memo No. 16326/Health. By this order, the appointment of the petitioner and five other candidates was cancelled.
The cancellation was made without any prior show cause notice or personal hearing to the petitioner. Feeling aggrieved, she filed the present writ petition before the Patna High Court.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The petitioner asked the Court to quash Memo No. 16326/Health dated 30.11.2021, by which she was “dismissed from service” from the post of General Medical Officer. She also sought a direction for reinstatement with all consequential benefits.
Her main grievance was that the order was passed ex parte, without giving her any opportunity to be heard. According to her, this violated principles of natural justice and rules of service law.
On the other side, the Bihar Technical Service Commission and the State of Bihar gave a different picture of what had happened after the initial recommendation and appointment.
The Commission explained that after it issued recommendations on 23.08.2021, it received several objections the very next day, i.e., 24.08.2021. These objections pointed out errors in preparation of the result.
Candidates complained that their merit score was actually above the declared cut-off marks in their respective categories, yet their names did not appear in the final result. In other words, there were higher-scoring candidates who had been left out.
On examining the records, the Commission found that this was indeed true. The names and marks of a number of candidates who should have figured in the final result were missing.
Realising the seriousness of the error, the Commission wrote to the Health Department on 26.08.2021, asking it to stop further action on appointments and not to issue appointment letters.
According to the Commission, a clerical error had occurred. The marks obtained by several candidates had not been properly included while preparing the merit list. This error led to an incorrect cut-off being declared and some candidates being recommended who were not actually within the proper cut-off when the error was corrected.
The Commission then rectified the clerical mistake. Once the corrected marks were taken into account, the cut-off marks for different categories changed.
Specifically for the EWS category, to which the petitioner belongs, the original cut-off was 35.093. After rectification, the cut-off for EWS increased to 35.926.
The petitioner had obtained 35.4612 marks. Under the earlier, erroneous cut-off of 35.093, she was within the zone of selection and was recommended and appointed.
But once the correct, higher cut-off of 35.926 was applied, her marks fell below the revised cut-off. She could no longer be recommended or appointed in the corrected list.
In view of this, the respondents cancelled her appointment through the order dated 30.11.2021.
The State of Bihar further pointed out that the appointment notification dated 02.09.2021 itself contained clear conditions. Clauses 2 and 8 of this notification made it explicit that the appointment was provisional.
Those clauses stated that the recommendation was being made on a prima facie acceptance of the correctness of the details. They also provided that if any adverse report was received or any clerical error came to light, the recommendation or appointment could be cancelled without any prior intimation.
This meant that the petitioner’s appointment was not final. It was subject to correction of errors and further verification.
The Court carefully considered these facts. It noted that a number of objections had been received from candidates who claimed that their merit points were above the declared cut-off marks but they had not been recommended.
To deal with these objections, a Committee was constituted, and the Commission examined the objections. During this process, it was found that 24 candidates who were not recommended actually had higher marks than the declared cut-off marks in different categories.
Because of this discrepancy, the Commission decided to revise and rectify the final result of Advertisement No. 17 of 2021. This rectification exercise led to revision of cut-off marks in several categories, including EWS.
For the petitioner’s EWS category, the cut-off rose from 35.093 to 35.926. The petitioner’s score was 35.4612. As a result, in the revised, corrected list, she could not be recommended or appointed.
The Court then examined the terms of the appointment letter issued on 02.09.2021. It emphasised that the letter clearly stated that the recommendation was provisional and based only on initial acceptance of the stated details.
Importantly, it was also mentioned that if any adverse report surfaced, or if it turned out that any clerical error had occurred, the recommendation or appointment could be cancelled without any prior notice.
The Court considered that this clause was known to the petitioner and formed part of the appointment conditions. Therefore, she could not claim an absolute right to continue when the very basis of her selection changed due to correction of an error.
In light of these facts, the Court concluded that her appointment had never attained a final, unconditional status. It remained provisional and liable to be cancelled if errors were discovered.
Once the Commission detected the error, corrected the results, and revised the cut-off marks, the petitioner simply did not meet the new, accurate cut-off for her category.
Therefore, cancelling her appointment was a direct consequence of the correction process. The Court held that this cancellation was justified.
On the complaint of violation of natural justice, the Court’s reasoning was that the appointment letter itself allowed cancellation without prior intimation in case of clerical error. Since the petitioner’s appointment was conditional from the beginning, the cancellation, following correction of the merit list, did not amount to arbitrary removal in the sense of a completed, vested right being taken away without hearing.
Finally, the Court found no error in the order dated 30.11.2021 issued by the Deputy Secretary, Health Department. It held that there was no merit in the writ application.
Accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is important for candidates selected through competitive recruitment, especially in Bihar Health Services and similar government recruitments.
It clarifies that where an appointment letter clearly states that it is provisional and subject to correction of clerical errors, a candidate cannot claim an absolute right to the post if the merit list is corrected.
If, after rectification, the candidate’s marks fall below the revised cut-off, the government can cancel the appointment without prior notice, provided such a condition exists in the appointment order.
For aspirants, this highlights the need to closely read the terms of appointment letters. It also shows that courts may uphold cancellation of provisional appointments when the underlying selection list is lawfully corrected to include more meritorious candidates.
Legal Issues and Answers
Issue: Whether the Health Department could cancel the petitioner’s appointment as General Medical Officer without prior notice after revising the merit list following discovery of clerical errors.
Answer: Yes. The Patna High Court held that the appointment was provisional, subject to correction of clerical errors, and that after revision of the cut-off marks the petitioner no longer qualified, so the cancellation order dated 30.11.2021 was valid.
Issue: Whether the cancellation order violated principles of natural justice for not giving the petitioner an opportunity of hearing.
Answer: No. Since the appointment letter itself permitted cancellation without prior intimation in case of clerical error or adverse report, and the cancellation followed rectification of the result, the Court did not find violation of natural justice.
Cases Cited by the Court
- No prior judgments or case law are cited or relied upon in the text of this judgment.
Case Details
Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 964 of 2022
Case Title: Chhaya Chitra v. The State of Bihar and others
Citation: 2026 (5) PLJR 226
Court: High Court of Judicature at Patna
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Partha Sarthy
Date of Judgment: 18.06.2026
Nature of the Case: Writ petition under civil writ jurisdiction challenging cancellation of appointment as General Medical Officer
Advocates:
- For the Petitioner: Mr. Vasant Vikas, Advocate
- For the State of Bihar: Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9; Mr. Anil Kumar Verma, AC to AAG-9
- For the Bihar Technical Service Commission: Mr. Nikesh Kumar, Advocate; Mr. Bijay Choubey, Advocate
Link: https://patnahighcourt.gov.in/viewjudgment/MTUjOTY0IzIwMjIjMSNO-K3HGgbj4cGw=
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



