Case Background
The case arose from an internal recruitment drive in Bihar State Power Holding Company Limited and its four subsidiary companies. The petitioner was initially appointed as a Junior Accounts Clerk and, from 10.05.2013, was working as an Accounts Assistant in the same organisation.
In 2018, the company issued Employment Notice No. 10/2018 (internal), inviting online applications from existing employees for several posts, including Assistant Personnel Officer (APO). Only those employees who had been working in the regular establishment for a minimum of five years were initially made eligible to apply.
For the post of Assistant Personnel Officer, the employment notice showed 13 vacancies in total. Within this, five posts were advertised for the unreserved (general) category, which was the petitioner’s category. The selection process was based on a written examination (OMR based). Under clause 11 of the employment notice, candidates were to be shortlisted on the basis of marks obtained in the written exam, and the minimum qualifying marks for the unreserved category were fixed at 40%.
The petitioner applied for the APO post and appeared in the examination. He later came to know that his name did not appear in the list of shortlisted candidates, even though, according to him, he had secured the cut-off marks for the unreserved category. He asserted that he had obtained the same marks as the last selected candidate, one Rajiv Kumar.
Another important development was that the company issued a corrigendum dated 30.10.2018, modifying the earlier terms. Through this corrigendum, the minimum service requirement was relaxed from five years to three years. The petitioner alleged that this change was made to favour a particular private respondent (respondent no. 7), whose name appeared at serial no. 6 in the list of shortlisted candidates.
The petitioner claimed that as per clause 7 of the Karmik Seva Samvarg Niyamawali, 2015 (referred to as Rules, 2015), the post of Assistant Personnel Officer is an entry level post in the personnel cadre, and 5% of the total sanctioned APO posts have to be filled by internal appointment from a merit list prepared on the basis of a limited written competitive examination. Under these Rules, only those employees who had completed five years of service with the company/Board were eligible to appear.
The petitioner also stated that no proper merit list, as required under Rule 7 of the Rules, 2015, was ever published. According to him, only a select list of shortlisted candidates was prepared, and only three of those shortlisted candidates actually joined as APOs. Hence, some vacancies still existed, and he could be accommodated.
After his non-selection, the petitioner submitted representations before the Director and the General Manager (Human Resources) of the company. His grievance was rejected on the ground that the last selected candidate in the unreserved category had obtained 51 marks, and since that candidate was older in age, he was given preference when both had equal marks.
What the Court Examined and Decided
The Patna High Court, presided over by Hon’ble Mr. Justice Mohit Kumar Shah, heard the writ petition challenging the rejection order dated 30.07.2019 passed by the Under Secretary of Bihar State Power Holding Company Limited. The petitioner sought quashing of that order and a direction to appoint him as Assistant Personnel Officer against the vacancies advertised under Employment Notice No. 10 of 2018.
The petitioner’s main arguments had two parts. First, he attacked the change in eligibility criteria through the corrigendum dated 30.10.2018. According to him, under Rule 7 of the Rules, 2015, only employees who had completed five years of service could appear in the limited competitive examination for APO. Reducing this minimum service period from five years to three years, after issuing the original employment notice, was described as changing the “rules of the game” midway. He claimed this was done to benefit respondent no. 7, who had not completed five years’ service when she applied, but who later appeared in the list of shortlisted candidates.
Second, he challenged the method adopted to select among candidates who had secured equal marks. He asserted that he and Rajiv Kumar both obtained 51 marks, which was the cut-off for the unreserved category. However, the company chose Rajiv Kumar purely on the basis that he was older in age (date of birth 11.10.1984) while the petitioner was slightly younger (date of birth 20.10.1984). The petitioner argued that neither the employment notice nor the Rules, 2015 provided that age should be used as a tie-breaker in such a situation.
To support his stand, the petitioner’s counsel relied on the Supreme Court decision in Bibhudatta Mohanty vs. Union of India, reported in (2002) 4 SCC 16. In that judgment, the Supreme Court held that a selection made solely on the basis of being senior in age is vitiated by extraneous considerations, though age can be considered along with merit.
On the other hand, the company defended its actions. Its counsel submitted that the cut-off marks for APO were fixed at 51. The petitioner had indeed obtained 51 marks, but so had another candidate. According to the company, it is a “settled principle” that if two candidates secure equal marks, preference is given to the one who is older in age. On this basis, Rajiv Kumar was selected.
Regarding the change in service length from five to three years, the company argued that clause 7 of the Cadre Rules, 2015 had been diluted or modified by the competent authority, who was empowered to do so. The corrigendum dated 30.10.2018 was presented as a valid exercise of this power. The company also stated that, after the written examination, a list of shortlisted candidates (merit/select list) was prepared in the ratio of 1:1, candidates were called for document verification, and a Selection Committee was constituted by office order dated 12.02.2019 to recommend eligible candidates. According to the company, there was no separate recruitment panel apart from this list.
The company’s counsel relied on another Supreme Court judgment, DP Das vs. Union of India & Others, reported in (2011) 8 SCC 115, to argue that age is a fair and valid basis for determining seniority among similarly situated candidates.
The Court first considered the complaint that the “rules of the game” were changed midway. The Court noted that the original employment notice required five years of service, but the corrigendum dated 30.10.2018 reduced it to three years. It accepted that, on this score, the respondent company had erred because they relaxed eligibility after advertising the rules.
However, the Court then made a crucial observation against the petitioner. Instead of challenging the corrigendum, the petitioner voluntarily participated in the selection process without protest. He sat for the examination knowing that the service requirement had been reduced. The Court held that a candidate who takes part in a selection process without demur cannot later turn around and challenge that very process after failing in it.
For this principle, the Court relied on the Supreme Court decision in Madan Lal and others vs. State of J&K and others, reported in (1995) 3 SCC 486. On that basis, the Court rejected the petitioner’s plea that the whole selection stood vitiated merely because the rules were altered by the corrigendum.
Next, the Court examined the second issue: whether the company could select another candidate over the petitioner purely on the basis of higher age when both had secured the same marks, even though neither the advertisement nor the Rules, 2015 mentioned such a tie-breaking rule.
Here, the Court found that the respondent company failed to show any rule or clause in the Rules, 2015 authorising preference by age in such a situation. The Court analysed the two Supreme Court decisions cited by both sides.
The judgment in Bibhudatta Mohanty, relied on by the petitioner, dealt with a case where seniority in age was one of the factors, but selection was essentially based on merit. Importantly, that case recognised that a selection made solely on the basis of being senior in age is invalid, because it is based on an extraneous consideration if not backed by rules.
The DP Das judgment, relied on by the company, was found to be distinguishable. The Court noted that DP Das concerned determination of seniority among officers who had been recommended on the same day. It did not deal with an initial selection process or recruitment tied to written exam marks. Hence, the principle that age can be used to decide inter se seniority among already appointed officers did not automatically justify using age alone to decide who should be selected when the rules are silent.
The Court concluded that the selection procedure adopted by the respondent company was not free from “procedural infirmities/inconsistencies”. One glaring infirmity identified was that, although a select list seemed to exist, no proper merit list, as envisaged under the Rules, 2015, had been produced before the Court.
Despite finding these flaws, the Court did not strike down the entire selection process or cancel the appointments already made. Instead, it looked for a balanced solution that would “iron out the equities” and put an end to the dispute, taking into account both the company’s position and the petitioner’s grievance.
Since it was undisputed that some vacancies in the post of Assistant Personnel Officer still existed, and that the petitioner had obtained the same marks as the last selected candidate, the Court issued a specific direction. It ordered the Chairman-cum-Managing Director of Bihar State Power Holding Company Limited to consider the petitioner’s case for appointment to the post of Assistant Personnel Officer, keeping in view the existing vacancies.
The Court further directed that an appropriate decision must be taken within six weeks of receiving or being shown a copy of the Court’s order. With these directions, the writ petition was disposed of.
Why This Judgment Matters
This judgment is important for employees of public sector undertakings and government-linked companies who participate in internal promotions or limited competitive examinations. It sends a clear message that employers cannot casually change selection norms or use unwritten criteria like age preference unless these are clearly backed by rules or the advertisement.
At the same time, the Patna High Court also reiterated that a candidate cannot challenge a selection process after willingly taking part in it without protest. If rules are relaxed or changed, the right stage to object is before or during the process, not after the results.
For employees, the decision demonstrates that courts may grant relief even without cancelling an entire recruitment, particularly where marks are equal and vacancies remain. Instead of ordering automatic appointment, the Court directed the competent authority to reconsider the petitioner’s case in a time-bound manner.
For administrators and HR departments, the judgment highlights the need to clearly publish tie-breaking rules, follow the governing service rules like the Rules, 2015, and maintain proper merit lists as required. Any deviation can be questioned in court and may lead to additional directions or re-consideration of candidates.
Legal Issues and Answers
Issue: Can a candidate who participates in an internal selection process later challenge the process on the ground that eligibility conditions were relaxed midway?
Answer: No. Since the petitioner voluntarily took part in the selection after the corrigendum reducing service length was issued, he was held barred from challenging the process on that ground.
Issue: In absence of any rule or advertisement clause, can an employer select one candidate over another solely on the basis of higher age when both have secured equal marks?
Answer: The Court found such a method unsupported by the Rules, 2015 and noted that selection solely on age is an extraneous consideration; hence the company’s action suffered from procedural infirmity, leading to a direction to reconsider the petitioner’s case.
Issue: What relief is appropriate where procedural irregularities exist in an internal recruitment but appointments have already been made and vacancies still remain?
Answer: Instead of cancelling the entire selection, the Court directed the Chairman-cum-Managing Director to consider the petitioner’s appointment against existing vacancies within a fixed time.
Cases Cited by the Court
Bibhudatta Mohanty vs. Union of India, (2002) 4 SCC 16
DP Das vs. Union of India & Others, (2011) 8 SCC 115
Madan Lal and others vs. State of J & K and others, (1995) 3 SCC 486
Case Details
Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 21075 of 2019
Case Title: Raghwendra Kumar vs. The State of Bihar & Others
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Mohit Kumar Shah
Citation: 2022 (4) PLJR 207
Advocates:
For the petitioner: Mr. Amarnath Singh, Advocate; Mr. Anish Kumar, Advocate
For the State respondents: Mr. Abbas Haider (SC-6)
For the respondent-company: Ms. Soni Shrivastava, Advocate
Nature of the case: Writ petition (service/recruitment dispute relating to internal selection for Assistant Personnel Officer)
Link to full judgment: Patna High Court Judgment – CWJC No. 21075 of 2019
If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.



