Pay scale dispute of university storekeeper sent back for hearing — Patna High Court, 2025

Sakshi Bhatnagar

Reviewed by: Sakshi Bhatnagar

License Number: BR/2891A/2019

Last Reviewed On: 08-09-2026

Sakshi Bhatanagar is a lawyer at Samvida Law Associates practicing criminal law. She represents clients in criminal proceedings before the Patna High Court and subordinate courts, handling bail applications, criminal appeals, NDPS matters, and customs-related cases. Her practice focuses on criminal defense and litigation across multiple forums in Bihar.

Non‑teaching staff member of a Bihar university challenged reduction of his pay scale. The Patna High Court did not grant him the higher scale straightaway. Instead, it held that he was not properly heard before his benefits were cut. The Court sent the matter back to the Vice Chancellor to reconsider after hearing him.

Case Background

The case arises from a long service dispute between a non‑teaching employee of a constituent college under Vir Kunwar Singh University, Ara, and the university and State authorities.

The petitioner was first appointed as Lab Incharge at H.D. Jain College, Ara. According to him, he worked to the satisfaction of his superiors. Later, by Notification in Memo No. 1040 dated 21.11.2007, he was promoted to the post of Storekeeper.

This promotion did not last long. The Vice Chancellor of Vir Kunwar Singh University cancelled the promotion through Memo No. 686 dated 20.08.2011. The petitioner challenged this cancellation in CWJC No. 16260 of 2011 before the Patna High Court.

On 16.12.2011, the High Court allowed that earlier writ petition and quashed the cancellation order dated 20.08.2011. After this, the university restored the petitioner to the post of Storekeeper. However, he was not given the higher pay scale of Rs. 5500‑9000 with effect from 01.04.1997, which he claimed was due.

The dispute over pay scale has its background in an earlier strike by non‑teaching university employees. Because studies in the universities and colleges were affected, students wrote to the then Chief Justice of the Patna High Court seeking intervention. Their letter was treated as a Public Interest Litigation and registered as CWJC No. 17870 of 2008.

In that PIL, the Court issued directions for implementation of commitments earlier made by the State Government to the employees’ federation during the strike. On the basis of those directions and subsequent orders, the State Government later issued Memo No. 1139 dated 18.06.2014 granting the pay scale of Rs. 5500‑9000, with actual payment from 01.04.1997, to employees working on valid sanctioned posts of Storekeeper.

Despite this background, the petitioner’s pay scale grievance remained unresolved. He filed representations before different authorities, but there was no satisfactory response. He then filed CWJC No. 1813 of 2017 before the Patna High Court.

By order dated 07.09.2017, that writ petition was disposed of with a direction that he should file a representation before the competent respondent. The authority was directed to decide his claim by a reasoned order within two months of receiving the representation.

After obtaining the certified copy of the Court’s order, the petitioner promptly submitted his representation. The then Vice Chancellor of Vir Kunwar Singh University disposed of it on 24.09.2018 and, by Memo No. 2525/18 dated 25.09.2018, ordered payment of arrears of salary after verification of the necessary papers by the Pay Verification Cell of the Education Department.

However, when the university forwarded the petitioner’s documents, the Pay Verification Cell, by letter No. 702 dated 25.07.2019, did not accept the pay scale earlier fixed by the university and took the stand that Memo No. 1139 dated 18.06.2014 applied only to employees duly appointed as Storekeepers with requisite qualification. Acting on this, the university issued Memo No. 693/Estab/19/3302 dated 07.12.2019, modifying the earlier order dated 24.09.2018 and Memo No. 2525/18.

Feeling aggrieved by this scaling down of benefits and rejection of his pay scale claim, the petitioner filed the present writ petition, CWJC No. 4652 of 2020.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The writ petition challenged two main orders. First, the petitioner sought quashing of Memo No. 3302 dated 07.12.2019 issued by the Vice Chancellor, by which the earlier decision in his favour dated 24.09.2018 was modified on the basis of the Pay Verification Cell’s letter. Second, he challenged letter No. 702 dated 25.07.2019 of the Pay Verification Cell, which refused to extend the higher pay scale under Memo No. 1139 dated 18.06.2014.

Along with these quashing prayers, he asked for a writ of mandamus directing the authorities to grant him the pay scale of Rs. 5500‑9000 under Memo No. 1139 with effect from 01.04.1997.

The petitioner’s counsel relied on recommendations of the Pay Revision Committee about pay scales for teaching and non‑teaching staff. On that basis, he argued that there was no minimum educational qualification prescribed for a Storekeeper to be treated as Assistant for pay purposes. He submitted that the petitioner had been validly promoted from Storekeeper to Assistant and was therefore entitled to the corresponding higher pay scale.

He further contended that the Pay Verification Cell had no jurisdiction to deny the pay scale once the university had taken a decision, relying on the Supreme Court’s judgment in State of Bihar & Ors. v. Sunny Prakash & Ors., reported in (2013) 3 SCC 559. According to him, the Pay Verification Cell could not unilaterally scale down the university’s decision.

On the other hand, counsel for Vir Kunwar Singh University relied on their counter affidavit. The university pointed out that the Pay Verification Cell did not accept the scale fixed by the university in its earlier Memo No. 702 dated 25.07.2019 and that the Director, Higher Education, Government of Bihar, through letter No. 15/M1‑93/2021‑2058 dated 30.09.2021, also objected to the petitioner’s pay fixation.

The university stated that the petitioner did not possess the requisite qualification at the time of his promotion. The record showed that he passed the Madhyama examination in 2006 and intermediate in 2014, and there was no information about his graduation. It was also asserted that he had been promoted from a Class IV grade post to a Class III grade post, which is not provided for in the Bihar State University Act, 1976.

In paragraph 5 of its counter affidavit, the university explained that the petitioner’s representation (filed pursuant to the 2017 High Court order) was decided by the Vice Chancellor on 24.09.2018, leading to Memo No. 2525/18 dated 25.09.2018, which made payment of arrears subject to verification by the Pay Verification Cell.

Later, as described in paragraph 8, the Pay Verification Cell, by letter No. 702 dated 25.07.2019, reported that Memo No. 1139 dated 18.06.2014 was not applicable to the revised pay scale and only applied to employees duly appointed as Storekeepers with requisite qualification. On that basis, the university concluded that the petitioner was not entitled to the Rs. 5500‑9000 scale and modified its earlier order by Memo No. 3302 dated 07.12.2019.

The State’s counsel provided the broader background to Memo No. 1139 dated 18.06.2014. He referred to the agreement between the Employees Federation and the State Government dated 17.07.2007, which, among other points, stated that Storekeepers may be treated as Assistants and given the same pay scale, but only if they held the requisite qualification for Assistants.

The State narrated that after the Patna High Court allowed CWJC No. 10870 of 2008 by judgment dated 07.08.2008, the State filed an appeal before the Supreme Court. Civil Appeal No. 516 of 2013 was dismissed on 18.01.2013 and the State was directed to implement the High Court’s order. In compliance, Memo No. 1139 dated 18.06.2014 granted the pay scale of Rs. 5500‑9000, with actual payment from 01.04.1997, to employees legally working on valid sanctioned posts of Storekeeper. Memo No. 1192 dated 23.06.2014 similarly gave the same scale to employees on valid sanctioned posts of Assistant.

The State emphasised that both memos were issued in special circumstances and not to be treated as precedents for all cases. It was specifically stated that only those Storekeepers would get the pay scale of Assistant who possess the requisite qualification of Assistant, namely graduation.

To support its stand, the State relied on earlier Patna High Court decisions. In CWJC No. 7765 of 2019, the Court had held that the pay scale and grade of Assistant were to be given only to Storekeepers having the necessary qualification, and that a matriculate petitioner in that case was not entitled to the Rs. 5500‑9000 pay scale. Similarly, in CWJC No. 9677 of 2014 (Bishwanath Sah v. The Tilkamanjhi Bhagalpur University & Ors.), the Court had rejected the claim of a matriculate petitioner who wanted the graduate pay scale, holding that the difference in pay was based on qualification, not on the post, and that there was no discrimination.

The petitioner’s counsel, in reply, placed reliance on decisions in CWJC No. 7636 of 2014 (Dr. Kedar Nath Pandey & Ors. v. The Magadh University & Ors.) and CWJC No. 16104 of 2014 (Surya Deo Paswan v. The State of Bihar & Ors.). Those cases related to objections raised by the Pay Verification Cell and emphasised that when a decision affects civil consequences such as pay, the employee must be heard. The petitioner argued that his claim was rejected through a cryptic order, without properly considering his grounds, despite a specific Court direction to pass a reasoned order.

He also relied on Civil Appeal No. 516 of 2013 (State of Bihar & Ors. v. Sunny Prakash & Ors.), to say that the Pay Verification Cell cannot unilaterally scale down university pay decisions.

The crucial question framed by the Court was whether the petitioner possessed the requisite qualification for being promoted from Storekeeper to the Assistant cadre and for claiming the higher pay scale of Rs. 5500‑9000. The petitioner’s stand was that at the time of his original appointment as Storekeeper, matriculation was the minimum qualification, so later enhancement of qualification requirements could not be used to deny him benefits. He also claimed he was the only Storekeeper in the university, arguing that the classification between matriculate and graduate pay scales did not apply to him.

The university, however, insisted that he had initially been appointed as a Lab‑bearer (a Class IV post) and was later taken as Storekeeper (a Class III post). Therefore, according to the university, he was not originally appointed on a sanctioned Storekeeper post in the manner contemplated by Memo No. 1139, and his claim to the higher pay scale was misconceived.

While noting these rival stands, the Patna High Court focused on the process through which the petitioner’s pay was scaled down. The Court observed that many of the grounds now taken by the State and the university in their counter affidavits did not appear from the impugned order itself. The order modifying his pay scale did not show that these issues had been put to the petitioner or that he was given an opportunity to rebut them.

The Court held that the petitioner had not been given a proper hearing before his claim was rejected and his earlier benefits modified. This amounted to violation of the principles of natural justice, especially since the earlier writ (CWJC No. 1813 of 2017) had directed the authority to pass a reasoned order.

Given this, the Court did not decide whether the petitioner was ultimately entitled to the higher pay scale. Instead, it directed that the matter be reconsidered by the Vice Chancellor after giving the petitioner a full opportunity to submit his claim with supporting documents.

The Court ordered that the petitioner file a detailed representation before the Vice Chancellor (Respondent No. 4) within two weeks from the date of the judgment. If he does so, the Vice Chancellor must pass a reasoned and speaking order strictly in accordance with law. If he fails to submit the representation in time, the university must still pass an order within six weeks from the date of communication of the Court’s judgment.

The Court further directed that if, on reconsideration, the petitioner’s claim is found satisfactory, the benefits should be extended to him within one month thereafter. With these directions and observations, the writ petition was disposed of.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is important for non‑teaching employees of Bihar universities and colleges who face sudden changes in pay or service benefits.

The Patna High Court made it clear that before any authority cuts down an employee’s pay scale or modifies a favourable order, the employee must be heard. Reasons against him must be put to him, and he must be allowed to produce documents in support of his case.

The order also shows that decisions of the Pay Verification Cell cannot quietly override earlier university decisions affecting individual employees without a proper, reasoned order from the competent authority.

For workers, this judgment underlines that even when the government or university claims they are only following rules about qualification or sanctioned posts, they must still follow fair procedure and natural justice.

Legal Issues and Answers

  • Issue: Could the university and the State, relying on the Pay Verification Cell’s objection, reduce or deny the petitioner’s claimed pay scale without giving him a proper hearing?
    Answer: No. The Court held that the petitioner had not been heard and that important facts were considered behind his back. This violated principles of natural justice, so the matter was remitted for fresh consideration after hearing him.
  • Issue: Did the Patna High Court finally decide whether the petitioner is entitled to the pay scale of Rs. 5500‑9000 under Memo No. 1139 dated 18.06.2014?
    Answer: No. The Court did not grant or deny the higher pay scale on merits. It directed the Vice Chancellor to examine his qualification, appointment, and other relevant facts, and then pass a reasoned order.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • State of Bihar & Ors. v. Sunny Prakash & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 516 of 2013, reported in (2013) 3 SCC 559.
  • CWJC No. 10870 of 2008 (Public Interest Litigation regarding non‑teaching employees’ strike) and subsequent Civil Appeal No. 516 of 2013 before the Supreme Court.
  • CWJC No. 7765 of 2019 (regarding pay scale and qualification of Storekeepers).
  • CWJC No. 9677 of 2014, Bishwanath Sah v. The Tilkamanjhi Bhagalpur University & Ors.
  • CWJC No. 7636 of 2014, Dr. Kedar Nath Pandey & Ors. v. The Magadh University & Ors.
  • CWJC No. 16104 of 2014, Surya Deo Paswan v. The State of Bihar & Ors.

Case Details

Case Number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 4652 of 2020

Case Title: Md. Shahid v. The State of Bihar & Ors.

Court: High Court of Judicature at Patna

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajit Kumar

Date of Judgment: 25.08.2025

Citation: 2025(4) PLJR 135

Advocates:

For the petitioner: Mr. Sanjeev Kumar Mishra, Senior Advocate; Ms. Adya Pandey, Advocate.

For the State respondents: Smt. Binita Singh, SC‑28.

For Vir Kunwar Singh University: Mr. Arabind Nath Pandey, Advocate.

Nature of the Case: Writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging reduction of pay scale and related orders.

Impugned Orders: Memo No. 693/Estab/19/3302 dated 07.12.2019 of the Vice Chancellor, Vir Kunwar Singh University, Ara; letter No. 702 dated 25.07.2019 issued by the Pay Verification Cell, Education Department, Government of Bihar.

Final Outcome: Writ petition disposed of with directions to the petitioner to file a detailed representation before the Vice Chancellor and for fresh, reasoned decision after hearing him; possible extension of benefits if his claim is found satisfactory.

Link to Full Judgment: Click here to read the official Patna High Court judgment

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about
how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar,
you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News