Pre-deposit in RERA builder–landowner dispute reduced to 30% — Patna High Court, 2025

Sunita Kumari

Reviewed by: Sunita Kumari

License Number: BR/708/2009

Last Reviewed On: 08-09-2026

Sunita Kumari is a lawyer based in Siwan and Chapra practicing family law. She represents clients in divorce proceedings, matrimonial disputes, and POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences) matters. Her practice handles family law litigation across the region, including matrimonial property issues, inheritance disputes, and matters involving vulnerable persons.

The Patna High Court examined a builder’s challenge to a 100% pre-deposit condition imposed before hearing RERA appeals. The Court held that only 30% of the compensation amount had to be deposited, not the full amount. The builder’s appeals before the Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal were restored. The Tribunal has now been asked to decide the dispute on merits within six months.

Case Background

The dispute arose from a development agreement between a landowner pair (later arrayed as respondent numbers 4 and 5) and a real estate promoter company (the appellant) for construction of a multi-storey building.

Initially, the agreement was for construction of five floors. Later, the number of floors was increased from five to seven. After this change, the landowners and the promoter fell into dispute about which flats would be earmarked for the landowners and what extra benefits they should receive because of the additional floors.

There was also delay in completion of the work. For this delay and for the alleged shortfall in the number or earmarking of flats, the landowners claimed that they were entitled to compensation and other monetary benefits from the promoter.

What the Court Examined and Decided

The landowners approached the Adjudicating Authority under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA). They invoked their remedy as allottees/landowners under the Act, complaining that the promoter had not given them the agreed number of apartments and that the project was delayed.

The Adjudicating Officer, in case no. RERA/CC/753/2019/RERA/AO/233/2019, passed an order on 09.03.2021. This order directed the promoter (the present appellant) to pay compensation, interest and litigation costs to the landowners within 60 days.

The promoter felt aggrieved by this order. It preferred two appeals, REAT Appeal Nos. 28 of 2021 and 29 of 2021, before the Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal at Patna. These appeals were filed under Section 43(5) of the RERA Act, 2016, which lays down conditions for filing appeals.

At first, the Appellate Tribunal ordered the promoter to deposit 30% of the awarded amount as a pre-condition, treating it as sufficient for entertaining the appeals. This 30% amount was deposited by the promoter.

Later, the landowners filed a petition dated 23.07.2021 before the Tribunal, seeking review of that order. They argued that under Section 43(5) of the RERA Act, when an appeal by a promoter relates to payment of compensation and interest to an allottee, the promoter must deposit the total amount awarded, not merely 30%.

The respondents’ counsel pointed out that Sections 59 to 68 of the Act (Chapter VIII) deal with “penalties”, while Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19 deal with “interest and compensation”. They emphasised that in this case the Adjudicating Officer had not imposed any penalty on the promoter. Instead, the officer had awarded compensation, interest, and litigation cost in favour of the landowner–allottees.

On this basis, they contended that the Tribunal had two distinct options under Section 43(5):

• if the appeal was against a penalty, the minimum pre-deposit would be 30% of the penalty amount (or a higher percentage as the Tribunal may direct); but
• if the appeal involved payment of amount to the allottee including interest and compensation, then the promoter had to pre-deposit the total amount awarded.

The landowners relied on several decisions from other jurisdictions, including:

• an order of the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal in Parinee Realty Pvt. Ltd. vs. Rajiv Govind Bharwarkar and another, Misc. Application No. 490/2020 (review in Appeal No. AT006000000031724), where the Tribunal held that the entire amount was required to be deposited in such situations; and
• judgments of the Punjab & Haryana High Court in CWP No. 8548 of 2020 and connected matters, and an order of the Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal in Appeal No. 7/2019, taking a similar view about full pre-deposit for compensation and interest.

They also cited decisions of the Allahabad High Court (RERA Appeal Defective Case No. 6/2021) and the Madras High Court in W.P. No. 29933/2019 (T. Chitty Babu vs. Union of India and others). In particular, the Madras High Court had observed that the appellate authority had no discretion to reduce the statutory requirement of total deposit of compensation.

After hearing both sides, the Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, by its order dated 10.08.2021, reviewed its earlier order. It concluded that the Adjudicating Officer’s order related only to compensation, interest and litigation cost, and not to penalty. It therefore directed the promoter to deposit the total awarded amount. The 30% already deposited would be adjusted, but the balance had to be paid within one month, failing which the appeals would be dismissed as not entertainable for non-compliance with Section 43(5).

The promoter later filed another review petition dated 24.08.2021, referring to some decisions of the Supreme Court and pointing out that the validity of the pre-deposit condition for compensation and interest was under challenge before the Apex Court in Special Leave to Appeal No. 13005 of 2020.

On 10.09.2021, the Tribunal dismissed this review petition. It reiterated that if the promoter failed to pre-deposit the total amount as directed in the Adjudicating Officer’s order dated 09.03.2021 within a fortnight, both appeals would stand dismissed without further reference to the Bench.

According to the promoter, it could not deposit the 100% amount within the time fixed, and the appeals were in effect dismissed on that ground. Feeling aggrieved, the promoter approached the Patna High Court under Article 226/227 in CWJC No. 15444 of 2021. The learned Single Judge upheld the Tribunal’s insistence on full deposit, treating it as in line with Section 43(5).

Still dissatisfied, the promoter filed Letters Patent Appeal (LPA) No. 932 of 2024 before a Division Bench of the Patna High Court. The Division Bench consisted of Hon’ble the Acting Chief Justice and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Alok Kumar Sinha.

In the LPA, the main contention of the promoter was that both the Appellate Tribunal and the learned Single Judge had misapplied Section 43(5) of the RERA Act. The promoter relied upon a later judgment of the Supreme Court in its own case, Civil Appeal Nos. 6745–6749 of 2021 arising out of SLP (Civil) Nos. 3711–3715 of 2021, particularly paragraphs 121 and 122.

The Supreme Court, after extracting Section 43(5), clarified in para 122 that:

• where the appeal is against an order imposing penalty, the promoter has to deposit at least 30% of the penalty amount or such higher amount as the appellate tribunal may direct; and
• where the appeal is against any other order which involves return of the amount to the allottee, the promoter is under an obligation to deposit with the appellate tribunal the total amount to be paid to the allottee, including interest and compensation, before the appeal is instituted.

The Division Bench of the Patna High Court carefully examined the factual matrix in light of this Supreme Court interpretation. It noted that in the present case there was no question of “return of the amount to the allottee”. The landowners had not paid any purchase price to the promoter for a flat. Rather, they were owners of the land, and their complaint was about receiving the correct number of flats and appropriate compensation for delay.

The Court also recorded that the grievance before the Adjudicating Authority related to “compensation” and not to the return of any money previously paid by the landowners. This factual difference was significant.

Reading Section 43(5) together with paragraphs 121 and 122 of the Supreme Court judgment, the Division Bench held that 100% deposit was required only where the appeal involved return of the amount to the allottee. In cases like the present one, where the issue is solely compensation payable to the allottee (here, the landowners) and not refund of any sale consideration, the statutory minimum pre-deposit of 30% of the penalty or amount suffices, subject to any higher percentage that the appellate tribunal may determine.

Thus, the High Court concluded that both the Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal and the learned Single Judge had erred in directing a 100% pre-deposit. The correct view, in line with the Supreme Court’s binding interpretation, was that the appellant was required to deposit only 30% of the awarded amount.

The Court further noted that the promoter had already deposited 30% in compliance with the Tribunal’s earlier order. Since this satisfied the statutory requirement as interpreted by the Supreme Court, there was no justification to insist on further deposit as a condition for hearing the appeals.

Accordingly, the Division Bench modified the Tribunal’s orders dated 10.08.2021 and 10.09.2021, as well as the Single Judge’s order dated 28.08.2024 in CWJC No. 15444 of 2021, to the limited extent that the appellant need not deposit 100% of the compensation, interest and litigation costs.

With this modification, the Court restored REAT Appeal Nos. 28 and 29 of 2021 to the file of the Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal. It requested the Tribunal to decide both appeals on merits, after giving adequate opportunity of hearing to all parties, and to dispose of them within a reasonable period of six months from the date of receipt of the High Court’s order.

The Letters Patent Appeal No. 932 of 2024 was therefore allowed in part. All pending interlocutory applications were disposed of.

Why This Judgment Matters

This judgment is important for both promoters and landowners/allottees involved in RERA disputes in Bihar.

First, it clarifies that a promoter is not always required to deposit 100% of the awarded amount to challenge an order before the Appellate Tribunal. Full deposit is mandatory only where the dispute involves return or refund of money earlier paid by the allottee.

Where the dispute is about compensation for delay, shortfall in flats, or similar claims without any refund of purchase money, the promoter’s statutory obligation is to deposit at least 30% of the amount, unless the Tribunal, for recorded reasons, fixes a higher percentage.

This distinction can make a huge difference in practice. For many promoters, arranging 100% of a large compensation award at the appeal stage can be impossible, leading to dismissal of appeals without any hearing on merits. The Patna High Court’s decision, following the Supreme Court’s interpretation, ensures that appeals in such compensation-only disputes are not shut out merely due to inability to make a total pre-deposit.

Secondly, the judgment protects the statutory right of appeal under RERA while still upholding the basic objective of Section 43(5): to discourage frivolous appeals and to safeguard allottee interests by requiring a meaningful deposit.

Thirdly, for landowners who enter into development agreements with promoters, the decision confirms that they can seek compensation under RERA for delayed or deficient delivery of promised apartments. However, if the promoter appeals, they must be prepared that only a part of the amount (30% or such percentage as fixed) will be deposited, unless their case also involves refund of money they had paid.

Finally, the decision strengthens uniform application of the Supreme Court’s reading of Section 43(5), giving guidance to the Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal and to litigants in future RERA cases.

Legal Issues and Answers

  • Issue: Under Section 43(5) of the RERA Act, 2016, was the promoter required to deposit 30% or 100% of the compensation amount awarded by the Adjudicating Officer in order to maintain its appeals before the Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal?
    Answer: Relying on paragraphs 121 and 122 of the Supreme Court’s decision in Civil Appeal Nos. 6745–6749 of 2021, the Patna High Court held that 100% deposit is required only where the order involves return of the amount to the allottee. In this case, the dispute related only to compensation, interest and litigation cost, not to refund of any money. Therefore, the promoter was required to deposit only 30%, which had already been done.
  • Issue: Whether the dismissal or threatened dismissal of the promoter’s appeals by the Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal for non-deposit of 100% of the awarded amount was valid?
    Answer: The High Court found that the Tribunal misapplied Section 43(5) in insisting on a 100% deposit in a compensation-only case. The Tribunal’s orders dated 10.08.2021 and 10.09.2021 were modified, and the promoter’s appeals (REAT Appeal Nos. 28 and 29 of 2021) were restored to the Tribunal for decision on merits.

Cases Cited by the Court

  • The Division Bench expressly relied on the Supreme Court’s interpretation of Section 43(5) in Civil Appeal Nos. 6745–6749 of 2021, arising out of SLP (Civil) Nos. 3711–3715 of 2021, particularly paragraphs 121 and 122.

Case Details

Case Number: Letters Patent Appeal No. 932 of 2024 in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15444 of 2021

Case Title: M/s Nesh India Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. The State of Bihar & Ors.

Coram: Hon’ble the Acting Chief Justice P. B. Bajanthri and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Alok Kumar Sinha

Date of Judgment: 02.09.2025

Citation: 2025(4) PLJR 123

Advocates:

For the Appellant (promoter company): Mr. Abhinav Shrivastava, Senior Advocate; Mr. Raushan, Advocate; Mr. Pushkar Bhardwaj, Advocate; Mr. Krishna Murari, Advocate; Mr. Sahil Kumar, Advocate.

For the Respondents (including landowner–allottees): Mr. D. K. Sinha, Senior Advocate; Mr. Ram Babu Sah, Advocate.

Nature of the Case: Letters Patent Appeal against a Single Judge’s order in a writ petition challenging Bihar Real Estate Appellate Tribunal orders on pre-deposit requirement under Section 43(5) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016.

Link to the Judgment: Patna High Court Judgment

If you found this explanation helpful and wish to stay informed about how legal developments may affect your rights in Bihar, you may consider following Samvida Law Associates for more updates.

Facing a similar matter before the Patna High Court?

Samvida Law Associates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News